9-1-1 season 10 premiere: sinkhole turns volcano as Athena starts detective work
Collider and Screen Rant reviewed the season 10 premiere of ABC's 9-1-1, "That Sinking Feeling". Both praise the start and highlight Athena's new detective role and a sinkhole that erupts with lava.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 2ABC's 9-1-1 returned for its tenth season with the premiere "That Sinking Feeling", which airs Thursdays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC. ColliderN “Season 10 premiere, "That Sinking Feeling," puts all of last season's changes into action.” Read at Collider ↗ Screen RantN “New episodes of 9-1-1 season 10 air each Thursday at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Centre · 2The episode opens with several groups of people on the road during what first looks like a sinkhole collapse in downtown LA; Collider reports that every member of the 118 gets a moment to save someone and everyone affected survives. ColliderN “Every member of the 118 on this call gets their moment to step up and save someone, and ultimately, all of those impacted make it out alive.” Read at Collider ↗ Screen RantN “a massive sinkhole that strikes downtown LA” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Centre · 2Maddie (Jennifer Love Hewitt), still running dispatch while Sue recovers from a stroke, attends her first post-mortem review, led by Ty Worrell (Rob Huebel) of the Office of Emergency Management. She audits calls in the area and finds a 20% uptake in calls in the two days before the sinkhole, plus a pattern of strange incidents, including an aquarium worker burned by unusually acidic water. ColliderN “Maddie realizes that there was a 20% uptake of calls in the surrounding area in the two days leading up to it.” Read at Collider ↗ Screen RantN “Maddie is tasked with auditing all emergency calls in the vicinity, revealing a pattern of strange disturbances.” Read at Screen Rant ↗
Centre · 1Worrell dismisses Maddie's concern at first, but the next day he calls her about a strange noise from the growing sinkhole. The 118 saves everyone, and then the sinkhole erupts with lava, revealing a volcano, according to Collider. ColliderN “The 118 tends to it and saves everyone, but it then explodes with lava, revealing itself as a volcano.” Read at Collider ↗ Centre · 2In a parallel plot, Athena (Angela Bassett), now a detective, takes on the case of an unconscious man with severe burns, with a ring as his only possession, and works with new partner Detective Jace Newell (Rick Otto). His coworkers at a construction company say it was a workplace injury and Newell urges her to drop it, but Athena keeps investigating alone. ColliderN “Athena suspects that there's more to the case, but Newell encourages her to just accept the win and drop it.” Read at Collider ↗ Screen RantN “Athena decides to go rogue and continue the investigation on her own” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Centre · 2Her inquiry leads to a jewelry store whose safe was robbed through a tunnel. She goes inside and is trapped underground when the volcano erupts, which both outlets describe as a cliffhanger, with Collider saying it sets up next episode's opening emergency. ColliderN “The safe was robbed through a tunnel in the ground, so Athena goes inside to investigate, trapping her when the volcano interrupts.” Read at Collider ↗ Screen RantN “leaving her trapped underground as the sinkhole suddenly starts erupting lava” Read at Screen Rant ↗
Centre · 1Athena also tells May that she doubts she can be a detective and wonders whether she was promoted only because she was shot on the job. May (Corinne Massiah) has a new job at the hospital, which Collider says broadens the show's focus. ColliderN “She has been wondering if she only got the promotion because she was shot on the job”“Athena (Angela Bassett), May (Corinne Massiah), and Maddie (Jennifer Love Hewitt) have all started new jobs” Read at Collider ↗ Centre · 2On the personal side, Buck (Oliver Stark) has been fostering Theo since last season's finale. He keeps getting hurt when Theo plays too rough, and Eddie (Ryan Guzman) worries that Buck does not discipline Theo. A dinner at the Diaz house, where Theo knocks a crutch out from under Christopher, ends without a fight or a resolution. ColliderN “Buck and Eddie don't get into a fight, and they don't get the chance to resolve this by the end of the episode” Read at Collider ↗ Screen RantN “Eddie (Ryan Guzman) attempts to help Buck (Oliver Stark) navigate fatherhood” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Centre · 1Screen Rant adds context: the show has felt different since Bobby Nash (Peter Krause) was killed off at the end of season 8, and Chimney (Kenneth Choi) is now the newest leader of station 118. It notes that, despite promotion that presented the volcano as the opening emergency, the premiere instead sets up two mysteries that collide. Open questions it lists include why the construction workers robbed the jeweler and why they gave Athena a false confession. Screen RantN “Despite promotional materials marketing 9-1-1's contentious volcano tragedy as the opening emergency, the season 10 premiere instead lays the groundwork for two distinct mysteries”“It's unclear why the construction workers robbed a jeweler and, more importantly, why they surrendered a false confession to Athena.” Read at Screen Rant ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Both centre outlets are positive. Collider reviews the episode as a suspenseful, action-packed opener that shows change is not always bad. Screen Rant uses it to argue that the show's shift toward detective-style mystery, through Athena, is the key change and may set up its future.
- Emphasis
- Collider covers the plot beat by beat, including the Buck and Theo parenting storyline. Screen Rant concentrates on Athena's detective arc and the show's mystery tradition ("Ocean's 9-1-1", "The Devil You Know").
- Leaves out or plays down
- Screen Rant gives little detail on the Buck and Theo plot. Collider does not mention Bobby Nash's death or the show's history.
- Charged language
- “captivating”“fantastic start”“delightfully grating”“do or die”
- For example
-
“making for a captivating and suspenseful opening episode.” — Collider
“9-1-1 season 10 is off to a fantastic start.” — Screen Rant
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Season 10 premiered on ABC, and 9-1-1 airs Thursdays at 8 p.m. ET.
- A sinkhole in LA ends with lava erupting and Athena trapped underground.
- Athena is now a detective investigating a burned man and a jewelry store robbery.
- Maddie is running dispatch and finds a pattern of strange calls before the sinkhole.
- Both outlets review the premiere favourably.
Where accounts differ
-
What the premiere's opening emergency is
- Centre
- Collider presents the sinkhole as the opening emergency and says the volcano sets up next episode's big opening emergency. Screen Rant says promotion marketed the volcano as the opening emergency but the premiere builds two mysteries instead.
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre2 articles
-
ColliderN · · Opinion
'9-1-1' Signals the Beginning of a Brand New Era With Its Season 10 Premiere | Review
Celebratory Spoiler-heavy review that praises the faster, higher-stakes calls and emotional character scenes as a fresh new era.

-
9-1-1 Is Completely Changing Formats After 8 Years
Celebratory Opinion-style analysis that frames Athena's turn to detective work as a transformative format change that could revitalise the series.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 16 Oct 02:02 First ColliderN '9-1-1' Signals the Beginning of a Brand New Era With Its Season 10 Premiere | Review Opinion
- 16 Oct 20:00 +17h 58m Screen RantN 9-1-1 Is Completely Changing Formats After 8 Years
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…