Skip to content
Bramble

Technology

France blames Iran's Revolutionary Guards for October cyberattacks on supermarket fridges

France on 9 November attributed the October cyberattacks on supermarket refrigeration to Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps and promised EU-level sanctions. One article in this group, an ABC piece on a Canberra data centre moratorium call, covers an unrelated topic.

7 outlets · 2L · 2C · 3R First reported Account updated
Image: ABC News (Australia)
Image: France 24
Image: IJR
Image: CBS News
Image: Arab News
Image: The Jerusalem Post

1 / 6

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2On 9 November, French Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot said Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) carried out the October 11–12 cyberattacks on French supermarket refrigeration systems, calling the attack "unprecedented in both its scale and its level of aggression". Mixed · 2Barrot said the attack targeted 700 sites; the Paris prosecutor's office said it caused "significant food spoilage and triggered roughly twenty fires" as temperatures in refrigeration units shot up. Left · 1The prosecutor's office said attackers gained remote control of the equipment through web interfaces, starting indefinite defrost cycles while disabling temperature alerts, and cited use of Farsi and IP addresses tracing to devices in Iran.

Mixed · 2Paris prosecutor Laure Beccuau opened a judicial investigation targeting the head of "Shahid Kaveh", a cyber unit affiliated with the IRGC's Electronic and Cyber Center, his two deputies and anyone else identified; charges include fraudulent interference with a data-processing system, aggravated by acting to serve a foreign power. Right · 1Barrot said France would impose sanctions at European level, had summoned the Iranian ambassador to lodge a "very strong protest", and would take other "necessary and proportionate measures"; EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said "our response should be strong". Mixed · 2Iran did not immediately respond to the allegations; Reuters noted that Iran routinely denies carrying out malicious cyber operations.

Mixed · 2Similar incidents followed elsewhere: AFP reported that on 2 November grocery stores in at least nine other European countries were hit by a suspected freezer-system cyberattack, while CBS reported hacks in Belgium, Luxembourg and Sweden and an attack that affected French blood banks without damaging products. No official has yet said all incidents are connected. Mixed · 2Cybersecurity experts told Reuters the attack appeared easy to carry out, and the manufacturer of many of the units said several were obsolete or ran outdated firmware; the FBI has urged organisations to take such controllers off the public internet. Mixed · 2Reuters, citing two people familiar with the matter, described the hacks as among the most disruptive cyberattacks of the war with Iran that began in February; CBS added that Iran has threatened to widen retaliation for the US-launched war and the US naval blockade of its ports.

Left · 1Separately, one article filed with this story, from ABC News (Australia), is unrelated: the ACT Conservation Council called for a moratorium on new data centres in Canberra until tougher rules are in place, citing pressure on energy and water. Its director Simon Copland said the proposed second CDC centre in Beard would use double the 5 per cent of ACT peak energy expected for its first stage, while CDC chief executive Greg Boorer said the company already uses closed-loop cooling and the sector must engage communities better.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left2 outlets

Framing
CBS leads with the prosecutor's findings and the investigation, adding US context: Army investigation of base refrigeration outages and FBI advice.
Emphasis
Technical method, evidence of Iranian origin, the caveat that incidents are not officially linked, and US-Iran war context.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not quote Barrot's sanctions pledge or the Kallas response.
Charged language
“costly grocery store refrigeration hacks”“the regime”
For example
“the regime has threatened for months to expand its retaliation for the war launched by the U.S.” — CBS News
“There has been no assertion yet by officials in France, the U.S. or the other European nations hit by the hacks that all of the incidents were connected.” — CBS News

Centre2 outlets

Framing
Hindustan Times leads with France's accusation, the probe and sanctions, then explains what happened.
Emphasis
Barrot's quotes, impact (units heated to 50°C, fires, blood banks) and equipment vulnerability.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not mention the war with Iran or the prosecutor's evidence of Iranian origin.
Charged language
“unprecedented”
For example
“Paris has launched an investigation and said it would push for European-level sanctions against Tehran.” — Hindustan Times

Right3 outlets

Framing
Arab News (AFP) reports the official French attribution and diplomatic response; the Jerusalem Post (Reuters) runs an early, hedged report of suspicion tied to the wider war.
Emphasis
Barrot's strong language, European sanctions, the Kallas reaction; the war context and prior alleged Iranian cyber incidents.
Leaves out or plays down
Neither gives the prosecutor's technical evidence of Iranian origin.
Charged language
“unprecedented”“first large-scale cyberattack aimed at sabotage on our national territory”
For example
“It marks the first large-scale cyberattack aimed at sabotage on our national territory” — Arab News
“two people familiar with the matter said Monday” — The Jerusalem Post

Ask about this story

Loading…