Afghan defence ministry says it killed 41 fighters who crossed from Pakistan
Afghanistan's defence ministry says it killed 41 and captured 62 fighters in Nuristan who crossed "with the support" of Pakistan. The claim is unconfirmed and Pakistan has not yet responded.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Afghanistan's defence ministry said its forces killed 41 fighters it described as insurgents and captured 62 others in Kamdesh district, Nuristan province, from Sunday to Tuesday. Arab NewsRC “It said it had killed 41 and captured another 62 in the Kamdesh district of the northeastern province of Nuristan from Sunday to Tuesday.” Read at Arab News ↗ The HinduLC “It said it had killed 41 and captured another 62 in the Kamdesh district of the northeastern province of Nuristan from Sunday to Tuesday.” Read at The Hindu ↗ The ministry said the group included Islamic State members and had crossed "with the support" of Pakistan. The HinduLC “The Defence Ministry said the fighters had crossed into Afghanistan “with the support” of Pakistan.” Read at The Hindu ↗ Arab NewsRC “The insurgents included members of the Daesh group, the ministry said” Read at Arab News ↗ Pakistan had not commented at the time of reporting, but its Ministry of Information has rejected similar claims before, and the claims could not be independently confirmed. Arab NewsRC “There was no immediate comment from Pakistan, but its Ministry of Information has rejected similar claims in the past.” Read at Arab News ↗ The HinduLC “The claims could not be independently confirmed.” Read at The Hindu ↗
The ministry warned that anyone who tries again to undermine security will face "an even greater response". The HinduLC ““If anyone attempts to do so again, they will face an even greater response.”” Read at The Hindu ↗ Afghanistan's foreign ministry also summoned Pakistan's chargé d'affaires on Tuesday to deliver a protest letter, accusing Islamabad of harbouring recruitment and training camps for fighters. Arab NewsRC “It accused Islamabad of harboring recruitment and training camps for fighters it then sends across the border.” Read at Arab News ↗ The HinduLC “Afghanistan's Foreign Ministry summoned Pakistan's charge d'affaires on Tuesday (September 29)” Read at The Hindu ↗ Tension between the two countries has been rising, with cross-border fighting and Pakistani airstrikes, and the UN mission in Afghanistan documented over 1,100 civilian deaths and injuries from cross-border violence this year. Arab NewsRC “The United Nations Mission in Afghanistan said last week it had documented over 1,100 civilian deaths and injuries in Afghanistan from cross-border violence so far this year.” Read at Arab News ↗ The HinduLC “Tension between Pakistan and Afghanistan has been spiralling” Read at The Hindu ↗
Pakistan frequently accuses the Taliban government of letting the Pakistani Taliban (TTP) operate from Afghan territory, which Kabul denies. The HinduLC “Kabul denies providing the group a safe haven and has rejected Pakistan's accusations.” Read at The Hindu ↗ Arab NewsRC “The TTP is separate from Afghanistan’s Taliban but is allied with it.” Read at Arab News ↗ Afghanistan does not recognise the 2,600-km Durand Line as an international border. Arab NewsRC “Afghanistan does not recognize its frontier with Pakistan as an international border.” Read at Arab News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Hindu presents the Afghan ministry's claim with attribution and caveats, leading on the ministry saying the fighters crossed with Pakistan's support.
- Emphasis
- Ministry's statement, dated details (29 September), and Kabul's denial of harbouring the TTP.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Content is near-identical to Arab News; it omits the sentence that the ministry accuses Pakistan of ferrying in ex-military fighters' details only in part and does not add Pakistan's response.
- Charged language
- “claims”
- For example
-
“The Defence Ministry said the fighters had crossed into Afghanistan “with the support” of Pakistan.” — The Hindu
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Arab News frames it as an Afghan claim that fuels tensions between the two countries.
- Emphasis
- Ministry claims and escalating tension; the lede says Pakistani support is 'fueling tensions'.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not carry Pakistan's side beyond noting past rejections.
- Charged language
- “claims”“fueling tensions”
- For example
-
“The ministry claims the insurgents, including Islamic State members, had Pakistani support, fueling tensions between the countries.” — Arab News
What every side reports
- Afghanistan's defence ministry said it killed 41 and captured 62 fighters in Kamdesh, Nuristan, from Sunday to Tuesday.
- The ministry said the fighters crossed with Pakistan's support and included Islamic State members.
- Pakistan had not commented, and the claims could not be independently confirmed.
- Afghanistan's foreign ministry summoned Pakistan's chargé d'affaires on Tuesday.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Pakistan supported the fighters
- Left
- Reports the Afghan ministry's claim, noting Pakistan has rejected similar claims in the past.
- Right
- Reports the Afghan ministry's claim, noting Pakistan has rejected similar claims in the past.
Afghanistan place
Its defence ministry says it killed 41 and captured 62 infiltrators backed by Pakistan and warns of a greater response; its foreign ministry protested to Pakistan.
“Ministry of Defense’s security and defense forces will not permit anyone to undermine security in the country,” — Arab News
Left1 article
-
Afghanistan's Defence Ministry claims forces killed 41 insurgents crossing from Pakistan
Neutral Near-identical account with the claim attributed to the ministry and dated details.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Afghanistan’s defense ministry claims forces killed 41 insurgents crossing from Pakistan
Neutral Reports the ministry's claim with caveats, and the headline and lede stress 'claims' and tensions.
- 30 Sep 13:43 First Arab NewsRC Afghanistan’s defense ministry claims forces killed 41 insurgents crossing from Pakistan
- 30 Sep 17:00 +3h 17m The HinduLC Afghanistan's Defence Ministry claims forces killed 41 insurgents crossing from Pakistan
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.