AI and tech firms lobby CMS and health officials in a government-run Slack workspace
A KFF Health News investigation, republished by CBS News, says a Slack workspace run by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services has given AI and tech companies a direct line to Trump administration health officials. CMS declined to answer questions about its legality.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2A Slack workspace managed by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has let tech executives, financiers and senior Trump administration officials spend about a year planning a campaign to get Americans to use AI-powered apps to manage their healthcare and medical records, according to a KFF Health News investigation. KFF Health NewsN “A cadre of elite techies, financiers, and high-level Trump administration officials have spent a year quietly charting an extraordinary and rapid campaign” Read at KFF Health News ↗ CBS NewsLC “A cadre of elite techies, financiers, and high-level Trump administration officials have spent a year quietly charting an extraordinary and rapid campaign” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2KFF Health News said it reviewed thousands of Slack messages, meeting transcripts and video recordings. It said these show industry had a direct line to top officials, including Amy Gleason, the former acting head of the Department of Government Efficiency. KFF Health NewsN “KFF Health News reviewed thousands of Slack messages, meeting transcripts, and video recordings” Read at KFF Health News ↗ CBS NewsLC “KFF Health News reviewed thousands of Slack messages, meeting transcripts, and video recordings” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2The workspace began in August 2025, when Gleason welcomed members and pointed them to a code of conduct. That code says the group is not an "advisory committee" and will not be used to obtain advice or recommendations for HHS or CMS officials. Membership has grown to 1,700, and includes companies such as Oura Health, Palantir and the venture firm 8VC, but only a handful of patient advocates, doctors and hospital representatives. KFF Health NewsN “While the Slack’s member count has ballooned to 1,700 over the past year, only a handful of patient advocates, doctors, and hospital representatives are in it.” Read at KFF Health News ↗ CBS NewsLC “noting that the group does not constitute an "advisory committee,"” Read at CBS News ↗
Mixed · 2In February, an invitation posted in the Slack workspace asked companies including Microsoft, Anthropic, OpenAI, Apple and Google to a Food and Drug Administration listening session on conversational AI products for patients. At least 35 industry organisations attended. The meeting was not on the FDA's public calendar or in regulatory notices, and the public was not invited. KFF Health NewsN “Representatives from at least 35 industry organizations attended the meeting held by the Food and Drug Administration” Read at KFF Health News ↗ CBS NewsLC “But the meeting did not appear on the FDA's public calendar or regulatory notices, nor was the public invited.” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2Joseph Daval, a former FDA lawyer now at Harvard Medical School, reviewed messages at KFF's request. He said the chat room in some ways resembles a federal advisory committee, which would face independence and fair-balance membership requirements and must operate in public view. CMS has not formally announced the workspace through federal regulatory channels, though officials have mentioned it at industry conferences. KFF Health NewsN “it would be subject to certain “membership requirements having to do with independence and fair balance.”” Read at KFF Health News ↗ CBS NewsLC “The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services has not formally announced the chat room through federal regulatory channels, though CMS officials have talked about it at industry conferences.” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2On video calls, CMS officials told participants the agency would promote their apps. Jacob Shiff, chief AI and technology officer at CMS' Innovation Center, said in February he hoped the work would be a "sales engine" for the apps. CMS senior policy adviser Morgan Taylor said at an April 7 meeting that apps listed on medicare.gov would be ones enrollees would trust. The Medicare App Library now promotes about two dozen commercial apps, and the recording of the February call was made private the day after KFF asked about it. KFF Health NewsN “told industry representatives in a Zoom meeting in February that he hoped the agency’s work would be a “sales engine” for the health apps.” Read at KFF Health News ↗ CBS NewsLC “A recording of the call had been publicly available through a Google Drive link but was made private the day after KFF Health News asked about comments made during the meeting.” Read at CBS News ↗
Mixed · 2CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz said in September the aim was to "give industry a chance to play in the sandbox of government-supported healthcare." Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said last week that AI is "much better informed than any doctor in the country." KFF Health NewsN ““We wanted to give industry a chance to play in the sandbox of government-supported healthcare,” CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz said in September” Read at KFF Health News ↗ CBS NewsLC “claiming it is "much better informed than any doctor in the country."” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2John Whyte, CEO of the American Medical Association, said "Some of these tools just aren't ready for primetime" and noted there is no liability if they get things wrong. KFF Health NewsN ““Some of these tools just aren’t ready for primetime,” said John Whyte, CEO of the American Medical Association.” Read at KFF Health News ↗ CBS NewsLC “There's no liability if these tools get things wrong."” Read at CBS News ↗ Mixed · 2CMS officials declined to answer several questions, including about the workspace's legality, how apps are chosen for the library and why employees promised to promote products. The FDA did not respond. Gleason, now chief product officer of CMS's Office of Health Technology and Products, said in an emailed statement that the Health Technology Ecosystem is "an open, voluntary technical collaboration." KFF Health NewsN “CMS officials declined to answer several questions about the Slack workspace, including about its legality.” Read at KFF Health News ↗ CBS NewsLC “The Health Technology Ecosystem is an open, voluntary technical collaboration.” Read at CBS News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- CBS News carries the KFF Health News investigation essentially unchanged, under a headline saying AI leaders 'lobby' officials, and so presents the same critical account of industry access to government.
- Emphasis
- Industry access, lack of public notice, and the 'sales engine' remarks, with added subheads such as 'A "sales engine"'.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Adds no reporting of its own and no byline; CMS's position appears only through Gleason's statement and its declined questions.
- Charged language
- “war room”
- For example
-
“A Slack workspace has served as a war room for AI industry insiders and Trump administration officials” — CBS News
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- KFF Health News presents an investigative account of a closed channel through which industry shaped health AI policy outside public view.
- Emphasis
- Leaked-style detail from messages and recordings, legal experts' view that the workspace resembles an advisory committee, and doctors' concerns.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Includes CMS's reply only briefly; no outside defender of the workspace is quoted.
- Charged language
- “extraordinary war room”“quietly charting”
- For example
-
“has served as an extraordinary war room for AI industry insiders and Trump administration officials” — KFF Health News
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- CMS manages a Slack workspace of about 1,700 members that includes AI and tech companies and senior federal health officials.
- An FDA listening session on conversational AI was announced in the Slack workspace, not on the FDA's public calendar.
- CMS declined to answer questions about the workspace's legality.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the workspace functions as a federal advisory committee
- Left
- Reports the legal expert's view that it resembles one and would need to operate in public.
- Centre
- Reports the same view; the workspace's code of conduct says it is not an advisory committee and CMS calls it an open, voluntary collaboration.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services organisation
CMS declined to answer questions about the workspace, including its legality. Gleason described the Health Technology Ecosystem as an open, voluntary collaboration focused on giving beneficiaries greater access to their health information.
“CMS officials declined to answer several questions about the Slack workspace, including about its legality.” — KFF Health News
“The Health Technology Ecosystem is an open, voluntary technical collaboration.” — KFF Health News
Left1 article
-
AI leaders lobby Trump health officials in government-run chat room
Critical Republishes the KFF investigation with the same critical framing and added subheads.

Centre1 article
-
AI, Tech Leaders Are Lobbying Trump Health Officials in a Government-Run Chat Room
Critical Investigative piece portraying the Slack workspace as a closed channel giving industry privileged access to officials.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 9 Oct 10:00 First KFF Health NewsN AI, Tech Leaders Are Lobbying Trump Health Officials in a Government-Run Chat Room
- 9 Oct 10:00 First CBS NewsLC AI leaders lobby Trump health officials in government-run chat room
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.