AI engineer says GPT-6 Astra deciphered 1809 coded letter to General Marmont
Carter Church, an engineer at SentinelOne, says he used OpenAI's GPT-6 Astra to decode in six hours a 1809 cipher letter sent to General Auguste de Marmont on Napoleon's behalf. The two UK outlets covering it report the same core account but differ on detail and emphasis.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Carter Church, an engineer at the cybersecurity firm SentinelOne, says he used OpenAI's GPT-6 Astra model to decipher a coded letter sent in 1809 to the French general Auguste de Marmont, which had gone unread for 217 years. GB NewsR “Carter Church announced this week that he employed OpenAI's GPT-6 Astra system to unlock and transcribe a letter dispatched to General Auguste de Marmont in 1809” Read at GB News ↗ Daily MailR “Now, Carter Church, an engineer at cybersecurity company SentinelOne, has cracked the code using AI.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The letter was written by Napoleon's stepson Eugène, the Viceroy of Italy, on the emperor's orders. The Daily Mail says Napoleon asked Eugène on 16 March 1809 to send it to Marmont, whose troops were in Dalmatia, cut off by Austrian territory from every other French army. GB NewsR “The letter was written by Napoleon's stepson Eugène, who wrote it under the emperor's direct orders.” Read at GB News ↗ Daily MailR “On March 16, 1809, Napoleon wrote from Paris to his stepson, Eugene, asking him to send a letter to Auguste de Marmont” Read at Daily Mail ↗ The Daily Mail says the first line is in French and the next 24 lines are two-digit numbers, stray letters and invented symbols. GB News describes a 1,300-character note whose symbols stood for both individual letters and archaic words. Both say the key was lost. Daily MailR “The first line is written in French, but the 24 lines that follow consist of two-digit numbers, stray letters, and invented symbols.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “The 1,300-character coded note used symbols that stood for both individual letters and archaic words, making manual decryption extraordinarily difficult.” Read at GB News ↗
Church said on X that Astra completed the whole multi-modal workflow in six hours from a single image and goal. In a blog post he said it cut the 1,202 by 1,836 plate into rows, read the signs and decided which of 175 hand-drawn marks were the same sign written twice before breaking the cipher. Daily MailR “Astra completed the entire multi-modal workflow in six hours from a single image and goal”“Astra cut the 1,202 by 1,836 plate into rows, read the signs, decided which of 175 hand–drawn marks were the same sign written twice, and only then began breaking the cipher” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB News adds that the system started from earlier cryptographers' identification of 33 characters, then used a method called "simulated annealing" to test word candidates against Marmont's known writings. GB NewsR “It began by cross-referencing its analysis against prior efforts by cryptographers who had identified 33 of the characters.”“The system then applied a method called "simulated annealing," systematically testing potential word candidates and checking them against Marmont's known writings.” Read at GB News ↗ The decoded text sets out the positions and strengths of French and allied forces, including Bavarian, Polish, Saxon and French corps, and tells Marmont that "Austria will be attacked at once on every side. She is consequently hastening toward her ruin." It also tells him not to be intimidated by "a few troops or a gathering of rabble" when the order to march comes. Daily MailR “you see that Austria will be attacked at once on every side. She is consequently hastening toward her ruin.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “The decoded message disclosed the positions and strength of both French and Austrian forces” Read at GB News ↗
GB News says the intelligence "proved vital", with Marmont's forces fighting their way out of Croatia to join Napoleon at the Battle of Wagram, after which Marmont was made a Marshal. The Daily Mail does not make this claim. GB NewsR “Marmont's forces successfully fought their way out of Croatia and joined Napoleon in defeating Austria at the Battle of Wagram, after which Marmont received the prestigious rank of Marshal.” Read at GB News ↗ Church said the cipher itself is not difficult and cryptographers could have cracked it given time and energy. He said the hard part was the multi-disciplinary work of transcribing, cataloguing and translating, and that outsiders will increasingly shorten the backlog of niche unsolved problems. GB News instead stresses that no cryptographer had ever completed the task, though it was theoretically achievable by hand. Daily MailR “The cipher itself isn't difficult, and cryptographers could have cracked this easily given the time/energy.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “Though theoretically achievable by human hand, no cryptographer had ever completed the task.” Read at GB News ↗ GB News says Church had no prior codebreaking experience and was inspired by another developer, Carter Leffen, who used the same tool to crack an unsolved 1941 Enigma message in about 10 hours. It also notes researchers' warnings that such capabilities could be used to identify anonymous internet users. GB NewsR “Mr Church had no prior experience in deciphering codes but was motivated to try after witnessing another tech developer, Carter Leffen”“researchers have warned that these same capabilities could be turned toward identifying anonymous internet users” Read at GB News ↗
Both reports rely on Church's own account. Neither cites an independent historian or cryptographer verifying the transcription. Daily MailR “'I used GPT–6 Astra to break an unsolved cipher to one of Napoleon's generals that had gone unread for 217 years.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “Carter Church announced this week that he employed OpenAI's GPT-6 Astra system” Read at GB News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets treat it as a feel-good AI breakthrough story: a centuries-old mystery 'cracked' by an outsider with a new OpenAI model. GB News leads on the baffled-cryptographers angle and the claimed battlefield impact. The Daily Mail leads on Church's own words and the decoded text, then adds a long section of background on Napoleon, Britain and Waterloo.
- Emphasis
- The 217-year span, the six-hour completion time, Church's lack of codebreaking experience (GB News), the translated passages (Daily Mail) and Church's remark that outsiders will increasingly clear specialists' backlogs.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither cites independent verification by historians or cryptographers. GB News leaves out Church's statement that the cipher was not difficult. The Daily Mail does not report the claim that the letter shaped the outcome at Wagram, and neither explains what GPT-6 Astra is beyond OpenAI's model.
- Charged language
- “finally cracked”“baffled cryptographers”“striking passage”“mysterious letter”“whizz through it”
- For example
-
“A Napoleonic letter that had baffled cryptographers for more than two centuries has finally been deciphered with the help of AI.” — GB News
“Napoleon's code is cracked after 217 years: Scientist uses AI to read a mysterious letter written by the Emperor in 1809” — Daily Mail
“which was able to whizz through it in just six hours” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- Carter Church of SentinelOne used OpenAI's GPT-6 Astra to decode the letter.
- The letter was sent to General Auguste de Marmont in 1809 by Napoleon's stepson Eugène.
- The AI took about six hours.
- The original key was lost and the letter had gone unread for 217 years.
- The decoded text says Austria 'will be attacked at once on every side' and tells Marmont not to be intimidated by 'a gathering of rabble'.
Where accounts differ
-
How hard the cipher was and how significant the feat is
- Right
- GB News stresses that the letter had baffled cryptographers for two centuries and that no one had completed the task. The Daily Mail quotes Church saying the cipher itself isn't difficult, and that the multi-disciplinary workflow is what made it impressive.
-
The letter's historical effect
- Right
- GB News says the intelligence 'proved vital' and led to Marmont's breakout and the Wagram victory. The Daily Mail makes no such claim and describes the letter only as setting out army positions.
Carter Church person
Church presents the result as showing the value of the AI's end-to-end multi-modal workflow rather than the codebreaking itself. He says specialists lack the bandwidth for niche problems and outsiders will increasingly clear them.
“What makes this impressive isn't actually the codebreaking, but that Astra completed the entire multi-modal workflow in six hours from a single image and goal” — Daily Mail
“the people shortening those lists will increasingly be outsiders who were simply curious” — Daily Mail
Napoleon Bonaparte person
Napoleon appears as the author of the orders behind the letter. In the decoded text, relayed through Eugène, he sets out the disposition of the armies and expects Austria's ruin.
“The letter was written by Napoleon's stepson Eugène, who wrote it under the emperor's direct orders.” — GB News
“Austria will be attacked at once on every side.” — Daily Mail
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
GB NewsR ·
Napoleon Bonaparte's letter to general finally cracked after 217 years
Celebratory Presents the decipherment as a triumph that solved a two-century puzzle and credits the letter with helping Marmont and Napoleon win at Wagram, closing with a caution about AI de-anonymising internet users.

-
Sympathetic Reports Church's own words and the decoded text in full, includes his caveat that the cipher was not hard, and pads the piece with general Napoleonic and Waterloo background.

- 2 Oct 12:00 First GB NewsR Napoleon Bonaparte's letter to general finally cracked after 217 years
- 2 Oct 12:27 +27m Daily MailR Napoleon's code is cracked after 217 years: Scientist uses AI to read a mysterious letter written by the Emperor in 1809
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.