Skip to content
Bramble

Entertainment

Ali G: Who Iz I? opens for a two-day cinema run amid mixed reviews, boycott calls and lawsuits

Sacha Baron Cohen's mockumentary Ali G: Who Iz I? had a two-day cinema release on Friday and Saturday, with some Israeli chains extending it. Coverage focuses on mixed reviews, a boycott campaign, participants who say they were duped, and one stooge who says he was in on the joke.

3 outlets · 1L · 0C · 2R First reported Account updated
Image: The Jerusalem Post
Image: The Guardian
Image: Daily Mail

1 / 3

The story, neutrally told

Right · 2Sacha Baron Cohen's mockumentary Ali G: Who Iz I? was released in cinemas on Friday for a two-day run, with a later release planned on Amazon's Prime Video. Right · 1The Jerusalem Post reported that Planet, Cinema City, Movieland, Rav-Chen and Hot Cinemas in Israel extended the release until Wednesday. Right · 2The film follows Ali G, whose HBO series was cancelled over 20 years ago, as he prepares for the birth of his first child with girlfriend Julie, played by Morgana Robinson, and goes to Los Angeles chasing a promised $3 million payment.

Mixed · 2Baron Cohen also plays other characters, including the ex-Mossad agent Col Erran Morad and a Berkeley professor, Dr Nira Cain-N'Degeocello, and the film stresses that people he meets in these guises were not in on it. Mixed · 2The Jerusalem Post said the film says only Baron Cohen and Robinson were in on the joke, and that he faces lawsuits from participants who regret giving permission; the Guardian reported that Michael Aboud, chair of the El Paso county Republican party, has called Cohen a “liar” and a “pervert” and intends to sue. Left · 1Joshua Loudermilk, a 54-year-old aspiring actor from North Carolina, told the Guardian he recognised Baron Cohen early in the shoot but kept pretending to be a hard-right Maga sympathiser, hoping to trick the star; he said he took part mainly for money and welcomes the publicity.

Left · 1Loudermilk said he signed a non-disclosure agreement he was not given a copy of, which he considers breached now that the film names him. Right · 1The Daily Mail reported that Ali G, in a video on the character's Instagram account, pulled Noel Gallagher, 59, from his seat at a Saturday-night screening and mocked the Oasis reunion. Right · 1Reviews were mixed: the Daily Mail cited a 50 per cent critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes, four stars from The Times, and two stars each from the Guardian, Empire and the Telegraph.

Right · 1Before release, the media-monitoring platform NewsCord ran a campaign urging cinemas to refuse to screen the film over claims it perpetuates racist stereotypes; the UK Cinema Association's Phil Clapp said cinemas are not there to act as censors. Right · 2Baron Cohen has said he revived Ali G because he is terrified of where society is headed and wants to show extremism on both sides; he told The Hollywood Reporter he is not surprised that prominent Jews are being targeted over the film.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
The Guardian led with an exclusive interview with a stooge who says he secretly played along, treating the film's claims about its participants with scepticism.
Emphasis
Loudermilk's account of recruitment through a Craigslist ad, payment and the shoot; Aboud's threat to sue.
Leaves out or plays down
Reviews, boycott campaign and Israeli release are not covered in this piece.
Charged language
“gravy train”“butt-gun”
For example
“Joshua Loudermilk says suspicions first raised during filming by gun shaped like wearable plastic bottom” — The Guardian
“I want some George Soros money. I’ll pretend to be whatever.” — The Guardian

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right2 outlets

Framing
The Daily Mail treats the release as celebrity news and a review round-up, with the boycott campaign as backdrop; the Jerusalem Post reviews the film as political satire of both Left and Right, noting the Israeli release.
Emphasis
Gallagher stunt, critics' star ratings, the NewsCord campaign and Baron Cohen's defence (Mail); the Hebrew jokes, targets on both sides and Baron Cohen's comments on Jews being targeted (Jerusalem Post).
Leaves out or plays down
Neither mentions Loudermilk's claim of being in on the joke; the Mail does not mention lawsuits by participants.
Charged language
“sinister campaign”“useful idiots”“red-faced”
For example
“a sinister campaign being launched amid claims the film and character are 'enforcing racist stereotypes'” — Daily Mail
“He recruits a few young, woke, useful idiots to help in his pursuit of Ali.” — The Jerusalem Post

Ask about this story

Loading…