American tourist, 36, dies in fall from Dolomites slope after leaving marked path
A 36-year-old American woman, Michelle Alejandra Rubio Leiva, died on 17 October after falling down a steep slope near Forcella Pordoi in the Italian Dolomites. Italian media said she had left a marked path to take a photo; the rescue service's log says only that she slipped at an exposed point.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Michelle Alejandra Rubio Leiva, a 36-year-old American woman from the Miami area of Florida, died on 17 October after falling down a steep slope in the Italian Dolomites while on a family holiday. MetroLC “Michelle Alejandra Rubio Leiva from Florida was on holiday with her family in the Dolomites when the incident took place on October 17” Read at Metro ↗ Fox NewsR “died Oct. 17 after stepping off a marked trail, local news outlets reported” Read at Fox News ↗ Mixed · 2Italian outlets reported that she had left a designated path to find a spot to take a photograph; Fox News cites Corriere della Sera for the location, Forcella Pordoi, an alpine pass at roughly 2,750 metres (about 9,000 feet), while Metro places the hike in the Val di Fassa, in Trentino. Fox NewsR “Rubio Leiva was hiking near Forcella Pordoi, an alpine pass with an altitude of roughly 9, 000 feet, when she allegedly left the designated path to find a vantage point for a photograph” Read at Fox News ↗ MetroLC “Leiva had been hiking in the Val di Fassa, a scenic alpine valley in Trentino, when she reportedly strayed from a designated mountain path to take a photo.” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2The reported length of the fall varies: CNN, as cited by Metro, and the Trentino Alpine and Speleological Rescue, as cited by Fox News, put it at about 1,000 feet (around 300 metres), while Il Dolomiti reported roughly 656 feet. MetroLC “However, other reports differ on how far she fell, as Il Dolomiti reported it was approximately 656 feet.” Read at Metro ↗ Fox NewsR “after falling for approximately 300 meters in the Forcella Pordoi area, at an altitude of about 2,750 meters” Read at Fox News ↗
Mixed · 2Her sister saw the fall and called emergency services at around midday local time; a mountain rescuer already nearby went to the site and gave coordinates to the helicopter crew. MetroLC “called emergency services around 12pm local time.” Read at Metro ↗ Fox NewsR “A mountain rescuer already in the vicinity went to the scene to provide the helicopter crew with exact coordinates, the rescue team's statement said.” Read at Fox News ↗ Mixed · 2Medical staff were lowered to the slope, and a doctor pronounced her dead at the scene. Her family members were airlifted to the nearby town of Canazei and her body was recovered by helicopter, with the operation reported to have ended at about 2:30pm. Fox NewsR “Medical personnel were lowered onto the mountainside by 12:30 p. m., where a doctor pronounced Rubio Leiva dead at the scene” Read at Fox News ↗ MetroLC “The recovery operation lasted several hours and concluded at about 2:30pm local time, Il Dolomiti reported.” Read at Metro ↗ Right · 1The Trentino Alpine and Speleological Rescue said in a translated statement that the hiker "slipped, plunging into the void below" at an exposed point; Fox News notes that its official logs mention only a slip, whereas Italian media cited the attempt to take a picture. Fox NewsR “While Italian media cited her attempt to take a picture, the official alpine rescue logs noted only that she slipped at an exposed point on the mountain.” Read at Fox News ↗
Mixed · 2Metro reports that her death was announced later in the week after next of kin were notified, and that the group was heading to a cable car station for Sass Pordoi, where they planned to dine at a mountaintop restaurant. Fox News, citing Il Dolomiti, says the group planned to visit the Maria refuge on Sass Pordoi. MetroLC “death was announced later in the week after her next of kin were notified, police say.” Read at Metro ↗ Fox NewsR “originally planned to visit the Maria refuge on Sass Pordoi” Read at Fox News ↗ Mixed · 2She was born in Guatemala, graduated from Brigham Young University and worked in communications, marketing and business development; Fox News, citing Corriere della Sera, says she was a manager at Rubio Contesse Advisors, and Metro says she worked remotely from Rome in 2025. MetroLC “graduated from Brigham Young University, a private research institution, in Provo, Utah, in 2012.” Read at Metro ↗ Fox NewsR “The Brigham Young University graduate worked as a manager for Rubio Contesse Advisors in Florida, according to Corriere della Sera” Read at Fox News ↗ Mixed · 2Both outlets set the death against rising visitor numbers in the Dolomites. Metro, citing CNN, says more than 80 people have died there this year against a typical average of about 10 mountain deaths a year, and cites Italian Alpine Rescue on steep slopes, loose gravel and falling rocks; Fox News points to crowds at Tre Cime di Lavaredo and online criticism of photo-driven tourism. MetroLC “The outlet reported that more than 80 people have died in the Dolomites this year alone.” Read at Metro ↗ Fox NewsR “Viral videos have led to outrage online, with many commenters arguing that visitors were more interested in taking photos than enjoying the mountains” Read at Fox News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Metro frames the death as a tragedy tied to social-media-driven mountain tourism, with context on rising fatalities.
- Emphasis
- The conflicting fall distances, the surge in Dolomites deaths (more than 80 this year versus about 10 typical) and the victim's background.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the rescue service's statement that the logs record only a slip.
- Charged language
- “Tragically”“social media tourism”
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Fox News frames it as a family holiday ending in tragedy, led by the photo-chase angle, and links it to the selfie-tourism backlash.
- Emphasis
- The rescue service's statement, the distinction between media accounts and official logs, and overcrowding at Tre Cime di Lavaredo.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not give the figure of more than 80 deaths in the Dolomites this year.
- Charged language
- “chasing perfect mountain photo”“SELFIE TOURISM BACKLASH ERUPTS ONLINE”“tragic death”
What every side reports
- A 36-year-old American woman, Michelle Alejandra Rubio Leiva, died on 17 October in the Dolomites after a fall.
- Italian local media said she had left a marked path to take a photo.
- Her sister witnessed the fall and emergency services were called.
- She was pronounced dead at the scene and her family was airlifted to Canazei.
- The fall was reported as about 1,000 feet by both outlets.
Where accounts differ
-
How far she fell
- Left
- Metro cites CNN for almost 1,000 feet but notes Il Dolomiti reported about 656 feet.
- Right
- Fox News gives about 1,000 feet (300 metres), citing the rescue service.
-
Whether the photo attempt is established as the cause
- Left
- Metro says she reportedly strayed from the path to take a photo and lost her footing.
- Right
- Fox News says Italian media cited the photo attempt, but official rescue logs note only that she slipped at an exposed point.
-
Where the group was heading
- Left
- Metro says they were going to a cable car station for dinner at a mountaintop restaurant on Sass Pordoi.
- Right
- Fox News, citing Il Dolomiti, says they planned to visit the Maria refuge on Sass Pordoi.
UK and Ireland1 outlet
Metro stresses the conflicting distance figures and the Dolomites' rising death toll.
“The outlet reported that more than 80 people have died in the Dolomites this year alone.” — Metro
Metro
North America1 outlet
Fox News stresses the rescue service's statement and the selfie-tourism backlash.
“the official alpine rescue logs noted only that she slipped at an exposed point on the mountain.” — Fox News
Fox News
Left1 article
-
MetroLC ·
Tourist falls ‘1,000 feet’ to her death in Italy while taking photo
Sympathetic Reports the fall as a photo-related accident and sets it against a sharp rise in Dolomites deaths linked to viral tourism.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
American tourist falls 1,000 feet to her death while chasing perfect mountain photo
Mixed Leads with the photo-chasing angle and the selfie-tourism backlash, yet notes that official rescue logs record only a slip.

- 26 Oct 14:06 First MetroLC Tourist falls ‘1,000 feet’ to her death in Italy while taking photo
- 26 Oct 20:00 +5h 54m Fox NewsR American tourist falls 1,000 feet to her death while chasing perfect mountain photo
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…