Government drops plan to restrict jury trials, keeps limited judge-alone fraud trials
The government under Prime Minister Andy Burnham has scrapped Keir Starmer-era plans to curb Crown Court jury trials, citing the "strength of feeling" against them. Judge-alone trials remain for some fraud cases, and magistrates gain powers, which lawyers criticise.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Arab News, BBC News, Daily Mirror, GB News, The Guardian.
1 / 8
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2The government has abandoned plans to reduce the number of jury trials in the Crown Court, a policy introduced under Sir Keir Starmer, with Andy Burnham now Prime Minister. Evening StandardN “The decision is a U-turn on proposals introduced under Sir Keir Starmer’s leadership in a bid to tackle the court backlog.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ The Straits TimesRC “Britain will scrap plans to remove the historic right to trial by jury for defendants in less serious criminal cases” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Mixed · 2Justice Secretary Alex Norris said: "I have heard the strength of feeling on the proposals for increasing the number of judge-alone trials in the Crown Court and have made the decision to change course." Evening StandardN “I have heard the strength of feeling on the proposals for increasing the number of judge-alone trials in the crown court and have made the decision to change course.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ The Straits TimesRC “I have heard the strength of feeling on the proposals for increasing the number of judge-alone trials in the Crown Court and have made the decision to change course,” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Mixed · 2The Ministry of Justice said only some fraud and financial offences would still be heard by a judge alone; Reuters described these as complex fraud trials, an idea a government-commissioned review this year rejected. Evening StandardN “Only some fraud and financial offences will now be allowed to be heard before a judge alone without a jury” Read at Evening Standard ↗ The Straits TimesRC “though a government-commissioned review this year rejected the idea” Read at The Straits Times ↗
Centre · 1The original plan, championed by former justice secretary David Lammy, would have reserved jury trials for indictable-only offences such as murder and rape, and for either-way offences likely to carry a sentence of more than three years. Evening StandardN “Mr Lammy wanted to reserve jury trials for “indictable-only” offences such as murder and rape, and lesser “either-way” offences with a likely sentence of more than three years in prison.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1Lammy had told MPs the changes were "desperately needed" to spare victims "agonising delays", and MPs backed them at second reading of the Courts and Tribunals Bill earlier this year. The plans followed recommendations by Sir Brian Leveson, who found no constitutional or common law right to a jury trial. Evening StandardN “It was supported by MPs at the first Commons hurdle earlier this year.”“In his review, the former senior judge found there is “no constitutional or common law” right” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1The Crown Court backlog stood at 80,829 cases at the end of June, almost double the 2020 figure. Norris said scrapping the proposal would let the government cut the backlog faster, as it requires less structural change. Evening StandardN “MoJ figures showed there were 80,829 cases still to be dealt with at the end of June, with the backlog almost doubling since 2020.”“Mr Norris insisted that scrapping the proposal would allow the Government to reduce the backlog faster, as it would require less structural change.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Mixed · 2The MoJ is also removing the right of people accused of relatively minor either-way crimes to insist on a Crown Court jury trial, with courts having the final say, and is increasing magistrates' sentencing powers. The changes will go into the Courts and Tribunals Bill, due back in Parliament later this month. Evening StandardN “criminals accused of “relatively minor crimes” losing the right to choose a Crown Court jury trial rather than a magistrates one”“The changes will be made to the Courts and Tribunals Bill, due back in Parliament later this month.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ The Straits TimesRC “the MoJ's decision to increase sentencing powers for magistrates” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Mixed · 2Labour MP Karl Turner, a barrister who lost the Labour whip after criticising the plans, welcomed the decision and said Burnham had honoured a commitment to drop the proposed Crown Court Bench Division. He warned that unworkable proposals would not get through the House of Lords. MetroLC “Prime Minister Andy Burnham has honoured the commitment he gave me to drop the proposed Crown Court Bench Division (CCBD)” Read at Metro ↗ Evening StandardN “they will not secure the support they need in the House of Lords.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Centre · 1Shadow justice secretary Nick Timothy called it a "major victory" for defenders of jury trial but accused Labour of "restricting juries by the back door". The Law Society's president Mark Evans called it a "common-sense position" but warned that shifting cases to overstretched magistrates' courts risks serious cases facing summary justice. Evening StandardN “Labour are restricting juries by the back door, scrapping the right to elect one and dumping those cases on magistrates whose backlog is at a record high.”“risks serious cases facing summary justice” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Right · 1Reuters reported that the Criminal Bar Association broadly welcomed the decision, though its chair Andrew Thomas said "a severe threat to our trial by jury remains", and the Bar Council's chair Kirsty Brimelow said giving magistrates greater powers could be counterproductive. Reuters also noted the announcement comes as hundreds of prisoners are being released early to avoid overcrowding. The Straits TimesRC “a severe threat to our trial by jury remains”“hundreds of prisoners were released early to stop prisons becoming full” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Mixed · 2The Criminal Bar Association said removing the right to elect Crown Court trial, combined with doubling magistrates' sentencing powers to two years, would move 25,000 cases a year, including 5,500 jury trials, out of the Crown Court; its chair Andrew Thomas KC called these "serious and sensitive cases" and said it "would be a car crash if they tried to do it". BBC NewsN “would shift 25,000 cases a year - including 5,500 jury trials - out of the crown court” Read at BBC News ↗ GB NewsR “It would be a car crash if they tried to do it, especially at this time.” Read at GB News ↗ Left · 1The Guardian reported that magistrates' maximum sentencing power would rise from 12 months to 18 months, with an option to extend to two years. Bar Council chair Kirsty Brimelow called this "a dangerous experiment" and said women, black, mixed race and older people elect jury trials more often, so the change risks deepening disparities. The GuardianLC “from the current 12 months maximum to 18 months, with an option to extend to two years”“We know that women, black people, mixed race people and older people elect jury trials more often than other groups” Read at The Guardian ↗
Mixed · 2Victims' commissioner Claire Waxman questioned whether what remains "will be enough" to deliver swifter justice, while courts minister Sarah Sackman KC said other steps could include AI to help list cases, more virtual hearings and getting defendants to court on time. The Magistrates' Association said magistrates can "rise to this new challenge" if properly trained and resourced. The GuardianLC “Victims are entitled to ask whether what remains will be enough to meet the challenge”“using AI to help list cases, more virtual hearings and ensuring defendants arrive to court on time” Read at The Guardian ↗ GB NewsR “magistrates can rise to this new challenge” Read at GB News ↗ Mixed · 2The BBC noted indications that the backlog is stabilising after unlimited funding for extra judge sitting days, though official projections put it at 100,000 before the next general election; the Guardian said the MoJ is selling the U-turn as a quicker route to cutting the backlog because it avoids setting up a judge-only bench division. BBC NewsN “There are, however, indications the backlog is now stabilising” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “The Ministry of Justice is selling the U-turn as a quicker way to address the problem” Read at The Guardian ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left3 outlets
- Framing
- Metro, the Mirror and the Guardian present a reversal of Starmer-era policy after backlash; the Mirror stresses praise for Burnham, the Guardian adds victims' concerns about what is lost.
- Emphasis
- Legal bodies' welcome, Norris's quotes, Turner's thanks, and (Guardian) Waxman's warning and Brimelow's concerns on disparities.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Mirror and Metro do not give the CBA's 25,000-case estimate or Conservative reaction.
- Charged language
- “Andy Burnham praised for axing controversial plan”“common-sense position”
- For example
-
“Andy Burnham has scrapped the controversial plan to curb jury trials in a move praised as “common-sense” by legal groups.” — Daily Mirror
“Critics say scrapping of plans” — The Guardian
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- The Standard calls it a U-turn with the fullest cross-party reaction; the BBC reports it as a scrapping while giving the CBA's warning about magistrates' courts and noting the backlog may be stabilising.
- Emphasis
- Turner's welcome, Norris's statement, Conservative claim of a "major victory", and the CBA's 25,000-case figure.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The BBC does not mention the early prisoner releases.
- Charged language
- “major victory”“car crash”
Right3 outlets
- Framing
- GB News leads on barristers calling the move a "car crash" for pushing cases to magistrates; the Reuters copy in the Straits Times and Arab News frames a government retreat after backlash amid a wider justice crisis.
- Emphasis
- CBA's 25,000-case estimate, Nick Timothy's "back door" charge, magistrate shortages and early prisoner releases (Reuters).
- Leaves out or plays down
- GB News gives no Norris quote or Turner's welcome; Reuters gives no party-political reaction.
- Charged language
- “car crash”“U-turn”“restricting juries by the back door”
What every side reports
- The government has dropped the plan to curb Crown Court jury trials.
- Justice Secretary Alex Norris said he had heard the 'strength of feeling' and changed course.
- Some fraud trials can still be heard by a judge alone.
- The Crown Court backlog was about 81,000 cases at the end of June, almost double 2020.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether jury trial is truly preserved
- Left
- Metro reports juries will be retained for most cases and quotes the Law Society's concern about more cases going to magistrates.
- Centre
- The Standard quotes Conservative Nick Timothy saying Labour is restricting juries 'by the back door' by scrapping the right to elect a jury.
- Right
- Reuters, carried by the Straits Times, says lawyers welcomed the change but warned 'a severe threat to our trial by jury remains'.
-
The Crown Court backlog stood at about 80,829 cases at the end of June, roughly double the 2020 figure.
Reported- Reports 6
- Metro, The Guardian, BBC News, Evening Standard, Arab News, The Straits Times
-
Jury trials will be retained for most cases, with only some fraud and financial offences heard by a judge alone.
Reported- Reports 7
- Daily Mirror, Metro, The Guardian, BBC News, Evening Standard, Arab News, The Straits Times
-
Defendants' right to elect Crown Court jury trial for either-way offences is still being removed.
Reported- Reports 4
- The Guardian, BBC News, Arab News, GB News
Alex Norris person
Says he heard the strength of feeling and changed course, and that this lets the government start cutting the backlog sooner while remaining committed to structural reform.
“This allows us to start that work far earlier” — Evening Standard
Karl Turner person
Welcomes the decision, credits Burnham for keeping a commitment, but says the fight is not over and warns the Lords may block unworkable proposals.
“the fight to protect access to justice and ensure justice is properly served for both victims and the accused does not end here” — Evening Standard
Andy Burnham person
Described by Turner as having honoured a commitment to drop the Crown Court Bench Division; the coverage quotes no direct statement from him.
“I am hugely grateful to Andy Burnham for his support during my campaign” — Metro
Left3 articles
-
MetroLC ·
Andy Burnham abandons plans to curb jury trials over ‘strength of feeling’
Neutral Reports Burnham's abandonment of the plan with background on the backlog and stakeholder reactions.

-
Ministers drop plans to cut jury trials in England and Wales after outcry
Mixed Reports the U-turn after outcry while giving space to the victims' commissioner's worry that the compromise leaves victims vulnerable.

-
Andy Burnham praised for axing controversial plan to curb jury trials
Sympathetic Presents Burnham as praised for axing the plan, quoting legal bodies' welcome.

Centre4 articles
-
Controversial plan to curb jury trials scrapped
Neutral Comprehensive account of the U-turn with broad cross-party and legal reaction.

-
Burnham scraps controversial plans to curb jury trials
Neutral Straight account of the scrapping with Norris, CBA, Conservatives and Turner, plus backlog context.

-

-

Right3 articles
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via Reuters
Britain scraps heavily criticised plans to curb jury trials after backlash
Mixed Reuters wire copy presenting the scrapping as a response to backlash amid a wider justice crisis, with lawyers still concerned about magistrates' powers.
-
GB NewsR ·
Barristers brand Andy Burnham's jury trials move 'car crash' within seconds of U-turn
Critical Leads on barristers' warning that shifting cases to magistrates will be a "car crash", with Conservative criticism.

-
Arab NewsRC · · via Reuters
Britain scraps heavily criticized plans to curb jury trials after backlash
Neutral Reuters copy framing a government retreat after backlash within a wider criminal justice crisis.

- 3 Oct 10:29 First MetroLC Andy Burnham abandons plans to curb jury trials over ‘strength of feeling’
- 4 Oct 00:01 +13h 32m Evening StandardN Controversial plan to curb jury trials scrapped
- 4 Oct 00:01 +13h 32m The GuardianLC Ministers drop plans to cut jury trials in England and Wales after outcry
- 4 Oct 00:02 +13h 33m Daily MirrorL Andy Burnham praised for axing controversial plan to curb jury trials
- 4 Oct 00:08 +13h 39m The Straits TimesRC Britain scraps heavily criticised plans to curb jury trials after backlash via Reuters
- 4 Oct 01:04 +14h 35m GB NewsR Barristers brand Andy Burnham's jury trials move 'car crash' within seconds of U-turn
- 4 Oct 01:26 +14h 58m Arab NewsRC Britain scraps heavily criticized plans to curb jury trials after backlash via Reuters
- 4 Oct 04:07 +17h 38m BBC NewsN Burnham scraps controversial plans to curb jury trials
- 4 Oct 06:31 +20h 2m Evening StandardN Andy Burnham scraps controversial Keir Starmer plan to axe jury trials
- 4 Oct 10:31 +24h 2m Evening StandardN Court backlogs will still fall despite jury trials U-turn, Alex Norris says
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…