Skip to content
Bramble

Crime

Anthony Williams trial: defence says schizophrenia relapse after LNER train stabbings

At Cambridge Crown Court, Anthony Williams, 33, accepts carrying out the attacks but denies attempted murder of 10 people on an LNER train to Huntingdon. The defence psychiatrist says he was in an acute schizophrenic relapse.

2 outlets · 1L · 1C · 0R First reported Account updated
Image: Daily Mirror
Image: BBC News

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2Anthony Williams, 33, of Langford Road, Peterborough, is on trial at Cambridge Crown Court accused of attempting to murder 10 people on a Doncaster to London King's Cross LNER service, which made an unscheduled stop at Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire, on 1 November last year. Mixed · 2He also denies four further counts of attempted murder: three people in Peterborough on 31 October, two of them on a footbridge over the River Nene, and a 17-year-old boy at Pontoon Dock DLR station in east London in the early hours of 1 November. Left · 1On Monday 16 November, prosecutor Christopher Paxton KC read jurors facts agreed between prosecution and defence: on-board staff member Samir Zitouni, then 48, had stab wounds including three to the back, suffered "catastrophic blood loss", needed four blood transfusions and was admitted to intensive care in a "life-threatening condition", with medics at the scene fearing he would "stop breathing".

Left · 1The court was also told that Stephen Crean, 61, had a scalp wound within 0.79cm of his brain, with no brain damage, and that Sachin Balakrishnan, 29, was stabbed in the chest at the level of the heart, collapsing his left lung, with the blade tip close to his heart. Left · 1Jurors had previously heard that Mr Zitouni tried to fight Williams off with a frying pan. Left · 1Detective Sergeant Nicholas Thompson agreed that on arrest Williams gave his name as John Johnson and said he had drunk no alcohol. Jurors were shown a bottle of Magnum tonic wine (16.5% alcohol) that CCTV showed him throwing from the train at Huntingdon, and the knife, which he dropped when Tasered by officers in the station car park.

Left · 1The prosecution case then closed, and the judge, Mr Justice Calver, adjourned until 2pm the next day for legal discussions. Centre · 1On Tuesday 17 November the defence case began. Gillian Jones KC said she would not call Williams to give evidence, and the judge told jurors they must not hold this against him. Centre · 1Dr Bernard Chin, a consultant forensic psychiatrist instructed by the defence, diagnosed schizophrenia, an opinion shared by a prosecution expert, and said Williams was suffering an acute relapse at the time of each alleged offence, with paranoid persecutory delusions that he was the target of an organised conspiracy by the devil.

Centre · 1Chin said Williams nonetheless "retained the capacity to form intent" and that the defence of insanity had not been met; he said Williams was likely intoxicated but this was "unlikely to have caused or sustained the psychosis". Centre · 1The court heard that Williams contacted his GP on 30 September saying his mental state was deteriorating and his medication was not working; he was taking 100mg rather than 200mg, did not attend a arranged meeting, and did not respond when the GP called back on 23 October. A report by psychiatrist Dr Alan Smith, written the day after the attack, said Williams had stopped quetiapine three days earlier and that voices worsened afterwards. Centre · 1Williams told Dr Chin he heard voices on the train saying "you're a nonce" and that "these people are going to attack you", and that "I just needed to protect myself. It was me or them." He also said he had gone to the river in Peterborough because no cars could run him over there. The court heard he punched a police officer in custody, believing the officer was calling him a "nonce".

Mixed · 2The court has been told that whether Williams carried out the attacks is not in question; jurors must decide whether he intended to kill. The trial continues.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
The Daily Mirror reports the prosecution's agreed medical facts, centring on the severity of victims' injuries.
Emphasis
Near-fatal wounds, blood loss, millimetre-close escapes, and arrest details such as the false name and tonic wine.
Leaves out or plays down
Nothing of the defence's psychiatric evidence, which came a day later.
Charged language
“catastrophic blood loss”
For example
“suffered "catastrophic blood loss" and required four blood transfusions” — Daily Mirror

Centre1 outlet

Framing
BBC News leads with the defence psychiatric evidence that Williams had delusions of a 'conspiracy by the devil'.
Emphasis
Schizophrenia diagnosis, medication history, Williams' account of voices, and the intent question.
Leaves out or plays down
Details of victims' injuries, which appear only as links to earlier BBC stories.
Charged language
“knifeman”“conspiracy by the devil”
For example
“A knifeman accused of trying to kill passengers on a moving train had a delusional belief his life was at risk because of a "conspiracy by the devil"” — BBC News

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Ask about this story

Loading…