Arizona lawmakers seek independent probe of ASU hockey workout that hospitalised player
Two Arizona legislators asked the state's Board of Regents to appoint an independent investigator into an Aug. 20 Arizona State hockey workout after which player Matthew Mayich was hospitalised. Players and the player's parents dispute ASU's own review and want coaches placed on leave.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Arizona's House and Senate education committee chairs, Matt Gress and Hildy Angius, asked the Arizona Board of Regents on Monday to retain an independent investigator into an Aug. 20 Arizona State University hockey workout. Fox NewsR “called on the Arizona Board of Regents to retain an independent investigator to examine the workout” Read at Fox News ↗ NBC NewsLC “calling on Arizona Board of Regents Chairman Doug Goodyear to retain an independent investigator to probe Mayich’s collapse” Read at NBC News ↗ Player Matthew Mayich, a St. Louis Blues draft pick from Ontario, collapsed during the outdoor workout and remains hospitalised. Fox NewsR “Matthew Mayich remains on life support after an Aug. 20 workout” Read at Fox News ↗ NBC NewsLC “Drafted by the St. Louis Blues, Mayich is from Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, according to the NHL.” Read at NBC News ↗ Family attorney Rob Carey said Mayich is under care at the Barrow Neurological Institute and has no chance of recovery. NBC NewsLC ““He is incapacitated with no chance of recovery,” the lawyer said.” Read at NBC News ↗
Gress said ASU should not investigate its own conduct. Fox NewsR “ASU should not be left to investigate its own conduct and decide whether anyone should be held accountable.” Read at Fox News ↗ NBC NewsLC “ASU should not be left to investigate its own conduct and decide whether anyone should be held accountable.” Read at NBC News ↗ Seven anonymous players sent a letter disputing ASU's Sept. 21 internal report, saying the only water break lasted seconds and that Mayich showed distress before collapsing. Fox NewsR “The first of us to finish had a few seconds at the bottles before being ordered back” Read at Fox News ↗ NBC NewsLC “the workout continued despite some players displaying signs of distress” Read at NBC News ↗ The players also said the Army veteran leading the session left before the final event, and that head coach Greg Powers called Mayich's condition a "little heat stroke". NBC NewsLC “The players allege that the Army veteran leading the exercises left before the final event” Read at NBC News ↗ Fox NewsR “They said that he simply suffered a "little heat stroke,"” Read at Fox News ↗
ASU's report found an athletic trainer assessed Mayich, called 911 and moved him to shade, but it also acknowledged that no training plan was submitted and that he had inadequate hydration and medical care, according to Fox News. NBC NewsLC “The report found an athletic trainer assessed Mayich’s condition, told him to stay down” Read at NBC News ↗ Fox NewsR “Mayich didn’t receive proper hydration and had inadequate medical care after collapsing” Read at Fox News ↗ Mayich's parents asked ASU's president to place the coaches on leave during an independent investigation. NBC NewsLC “while an independent investigation gets to the truth” Read at NBC News ↗ ASU police are investigating, and Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell said her office will review the matter afterwards. The lawmakers asked the Regents to respond by Oct. 9. NBC NewsLC “my office will review this matter at the highest level.” Read at NBC News ↗ Fox NewsR “A response by Gress and Angius was requested from the Board of Regents by Oct. 9.” Read at Fox News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left3 outlets
- Framing
- NBC leads with the parents' call to put coaches on leave, then sets out the players' letter, ASU's report and the legal follow-up.
- Emphasis
- Family and legal actors, weather data, ASU's account, and the police and prosecutor review.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the Oct. 9 deadline or the Green Beret's alleged remark about water.
- For example
-
“The parents of an Arizona State University hockey player who collapsed during a summer team workout and remains hospitalized” — NBC News
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Fox News (OutKick) leads with the lawmakers' demand and the player's coma, drawing heavily on the players' letter.
- Emphasis
- Lawmakers' quotes, retaliation fears, and vivid details of the workout.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the parents' letter, the police investigation and the county attorney's review.
- Charged language
- “blazing Arizona heat”“still fighting for his life”“grueling”
- For example
-
“still fighting for his life in a coma” — Fox News
What every side reports
- Matthew Mayich collapsed during an Aug. 20 ASU hockey workout and remains hospitalised.
- Gress and Angius asked the Board of Regents for an independent investigator.
- Seven anonymous players disputed ASU's review, citing fear of retaliation.
- Coach Greg Powers has not addressed the incident in detail.
Where accounts differ
-
Length and timing of the water break
- Left
- Players say Mayich got no water in a break lasting only seconds.
- Right
- Players say the break came about 40 minutes into a 75-minute workout, versus ASU's account of around 20 minutes.
-
Mayich's condition
- Left
- Family attorney says he is incapacitated with no chance of recovery.
- Right
- Described as on life support and in a coma.
Arizona State University organisation
ASU released an internal review on Sept. 21 that describes staff actions; it did not immediately respond to NBC's request for comment on the new claims.
“The university did not immediately respond to a request for comment Tuesday” — NBC News
Matthew Mayich person
Through the family's lawyer, his parents want coaches on leave pending an independent investigation.
““The players shouldn’t have to worry about retaliation from the people they report to every day,”” — NBC News
Left4 articles
-
Parents of hospitalized Arizona State hockey player call for coaches to be placed on leave
Neutral Frames the story around the family's demand and the players' rebuttal of ASU's report, adding weather data and legal context.

-

-

-

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Arizona lawmakers demand independent investigation into ASU hockey workout that left player in coma
Alarmist Frames the story as a lawmaker-driven demand for accountability, using dramatic language about the heat and the player's fight for life.

-

- 29 Sep 23:53 First Fox NewsR Arizona lawmakers demand independent investigation into ASU hockey workout that left player in coma
- 30 Sep 05:21 +5h 28m NBC NewsLC Parents of hospitalized Arizona State hockey player call for coaches to be placed on leave
- 30 Sep 21:49 +21h 56m NBC NewsLC ASU hockey coach is put on leave as hospitalized player remains on life support
- 30 Sep 21:56 +22h 3m The IndependentLC ASU hockey coach on leave after player collapsed during outdoor workout
- 30 Sep 23:02 +23h 9m CBS NewsLC ASU hockey coach put on leave after player collapsed during workout
- 30 Sep 23:30 +23h 37m Fox NewsR Arizona State hockey coach placed on paid leave as investigation into tragic workout continues
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.