Athletics' Zack Gelof sues Tigers over knee injury at Comerica Park
Athletics player Zack Gelof has sued the Detroit Tigers and others over a July 9 knee injury caused by a metal fence at Comerica Park. The Tigers say they do not comment on pending litigation.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Athletics player Zack Gelof has filed a lawsuit over a knee injury he suffered at Detroit's Comerica Park. Fox NewsR “Athletics outfielder Zack Gelof has filed a lawsuit against the Detroit Tigers, Ilitch Holdings and the Detroit-Wayne County Stadium Authority for damages” Read at Fox News ↗ The IndependentLC “A player for the Athletics Major League Baseball team is suing the Detroit Tigers” Read at The Independent ↗ The injury happened in the third inning of a game on July 9, when Gelof made a sliding catch and his right knee hit a metal fence. Fox NewsR “Gelof was hurt in the third inning of a 4-1 loss to the Tigers on July 9 while making a sliding catch in foul territory and colliding with a metal fence.” Read at Fox News ↗ The IndependentLC “Gelof made a sliding catch in an attempt to snag the fly ball” Read at The Independent ↗ He was left with a deep cut below the kneecap, and Fox News, citing the Associated Press, says he did not play again until Aug. 10. Fox NewsR “He was left with a deep cut under his right knee cap, just missing the tendon, and didn’t play again until Aug. 10.” Read at Fox News ↗
The Independent reports the suit says he missed 30 days and describes the fence as sharp, exposed and inadequately padded. The IndependentLC “Gelof further claims he was forced to miss 30 days of work and games due to his injury.”“The lawsuit argues that the metal fencing was sharp, exposed, and was not properly protected” Read at The Independent ↗ It also alleges the Tigers failed to repair, redesign, relocate or warn about the fence, and that they knew or should have known of the risk. The IndependentLC “the Tigers organization failed to repair, redesign, or relocate the fence, and that it failed to warn players about the potential hazard” Read at The Independent ↗ Gelof's attorney, Jon Marko, said the injury could have been prevented with basic, inexpensive design, and that padding was added after Gelof was hurt. Fox NewsR “"This injury could have easily been prevented through the most basic and inexpensive design," said Gelof’s attorney, Jon Marko.”“All they had to do was put cheap padding up like they did after Zack was injured” Read at Fox News ↗
Gelof seeks compensation for pain and suffering, lost wages, economic loss, emotional distress, medical bills and attorney fees. The IndependentLC “Gelof is seeking compensation for “severe” pain and suffering, lost wages, economic loss, mental and emotional distress” Read at The Independent ↗ The Independent says the suit was filed in Wayne County Circuit Court on Monday, Sept. 28. The IndependentLC “The lawsuit was filed in the Wayne County Circuit Court on Monday, September 28.” Read at The Independent ↗ The Tigers said on Tuesday they are aware of the suit and do not comment on pending litigation. Fox NewsR “"We are aware of the lawsuit and do not comment on pending litigation," the Tigers said in a statement on Tuesday.” Read at Fox News ↗ The IndependentLC “"We are aware of the lawsuit and do not comment on pending litigation," the Tigers said in a statement on Tuesday.” Read at The Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Detailed account of the allegations in the complaint, attributed to the lawsuit and ESPN.
- Emphasis
- The specific claims of negligence, the damages sought, the court and filing date.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not list the other named defendants, Gelof's return date or his season statistics.
- Charged language
- “violently struck”
- For example
-
“claims his right knee "violently struck an exposed dangerous metal fence on the side wall that protruded into or alongside the playing area,”” — The Independent
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Explainer-style piece on why Gelof is suing, built around the attorney's quotes and the injury's impact, with an AP report.
- Emphasis
- The attorney's comments that padding was added afterwards, the injury's severity, and Gelof's season and the team's record.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not give the complaint's specific allegations, the damages sought, or the filing court and date.
- Charged language
- “recipe for disaster”“slammed”
- For example
-
“sharp metal fencing in an area where players are required to slide and play around is a recipe for disaster like the one that occurred here.” — Fox News
What every side reports
- Gelof filed a lawsuit over a July 9 knee injury at Comerica Park
- He hit a metal fence while making a sliding catch in the third inning
- The Tigers said they do not comment on pending litigation
Where accounts differ
-
Gelof's position and the defendants
- Left
- The Independent calls him a third baseman and names the Tigers as defendant, referring generally to 'Defendants'.
- Right
- Fox News calls him an outfielder (and infielder) and lists the Tigers, Ilitch Holdings and the Detroit-Wayne County Stadium Authority as defendants.
Zack Gelof person
Through his attorney, Gelof says the fence was a foreseeable, preventable hazard and seeks damages.
“to recover the full measure of Gelof’s physical, professional, and economic damages.” — The Independent
Detroit Tigers organisation
The Tigers acknowledge the suit but decline to comment on it.
“"We are aware of the lawsuit and do not comment on pending litigation,"” — Fox News
Left1 article
-
Athletics player Zack Gelof sues Detroit Tigers after getting hurt in their stadium
Neutral Sets out the lawsuit's allegations and requested damages, attributing them to Gelof and his lawyers.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Why Athletics Outfielder Zack Gelof Is Suing Tigers For Damages
Sympathetic Leads with the attorney's pointed quotes and the injury details, in a brief AP-based explainer.
- 29 Sep 18:33 First Fox NewsR Why Athletics Outfielder Zack Gelof Is Suing Tigers For Damages
- 29 Sep 23:55 +5h 22m The IndependentLC Athletics player Zack Gelof sues Detroit Tigers after getting hurt in their stadium
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.