Atlantic reports Fetterman fundraising appeals routed through Republican-aligned firms
The Atlantic reports that Sen. John Fetterman's campaign is using Republican-aligned firms to raise money from conservative donors after his Democratic fundraising firm left. Hot Air, a right-leaning blog, relays the findings and frames them around Democratic discontent and Senate leverage.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
The Atlantic reported on 30 September that Pennsylvania Democratic Senator John Fetterman has begun fundraising through Republican-aligned firms. The AtlanticLC “After losing his Democratic fundraisers, the Pennsylvania senator found a new firm with MAGA-world ties.” Read at The Atlantic ↗ It obtained a message in which an account associate at Blitz Digital Group, a GOP-aligned firm, circulated a Fetterman-signed appeal that she said had been "doing crazy numbers". The AtlanticLC ““It has been doing crazy numbers for us.”” Read at The Atlantic ↗ Hot AirR “GOP-aligned firm Blitz Digital Group” Read at Hot Air ↗ The appeal's subject line read "I’m always going to reject Socialism and the anti-American way of life", and donations ran through Anedot, a payment processor used by Republicans. The AtlanticLC “the money flowed through a payment-processing firm, Anedot, that is used by Republicans” Read at The Atlantic ↗
Under a 75% split, groups sending the appeal would keep most of each new donor's first gift, while Fetterman would gain donor contact information for a future campaign list, a Republican consultant told The Atlantic. The AtlanticLC “Fetterman would profit largely by gaining the contact information of new donors” Read at The Atlantic ↗ The Atlantic says the appeals were circulated by more than a dozen political operations with domains such as TrumpTruths.org, and that Republican Senator Mike Lee forwarded one to his own list, saying Fetterman was "basically a Republican now". The AtlanticLC ““I just got an email from John. He’s basically a Republican now,” Lee wrote” Read at The Atlantic ↗ Hot AirR “TheDesantisDaily.com, and TrumpTruths.org” Read at Hot Air ↗ The shift follows the end in June of his relationship with MissionWired, a Democratic-aligned firm, and a joint fundraising committee with Republican Senator Dave McCormick. The AtlanticLC “his longtime relationship with a Democratic-aligned digital fundraising firm, MissionWired, ended” Read at The Atlantic ↗ Hot AirR “He also set up a joint fundraising committee with McCormick” Read at Hot Air ↗
Fetterman says he has no interest in becoming a Republican and that his views have not changed; the Atlantic says neither his campaign nor Blitz Digital responded to requests for comment. The AtlanticLC ““I’m not going to be a Republican!””“did not respond to requests for comment. Neither did the Fetterman campaign.” Read at The Atlantic ↗ The Atlantic cites a New York Times poll finding 12 percent of Pennsylvania Democrats view him favorably, and quotes Democrats such as Conor Lamb saying his Democratic career is over. The AtlanticLC “Only 12 percent of Democrats now view Fetterman favorably”““His career as a Democrat is over. We didn’t push him away. He threw it away,”” Read at The Atlantic ↗ Hot Air's Ed Morrissey suggests Fetterman may have changed his messaging because he concluded his party had turned toward socialists, and says Fetterman could hold leverage if the Senate splits evenly after the midterms. Hot AirR “If the Senate splits 50/50, Fetterman will have lots of leverage.” Read at Hot Air ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Original investigative reporting, based on obtained internal messages, on Fetterman's Republican-aligned fundraising and what it means for his party status and 2028 prospects.
- Emphasis
- Documents, the 75% split mechanics, polling collapse among Democrats, and quotes from Democrats and Senate leaders.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No comment from Fetterman's campaign, Blitz Digital or Lee's office is available; it gives little weight to a purely ideological explanation for his messaging.
- Charged language
- “Right-Wing Fundraising Deals”“MAGA-world ties”
- For example
-
“After losing his Democratic fundraisers, the Pennsylvania senator found a new firm with MAGA-world ties.” — The Atlantic
““Dems are bitter and resentful, and these guys are sitting there with open arms.”” — The Atlantic
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Opinion commentary that re-quotes the Atlantic's findings at length and uses them to mock Democrats' handling of Fetterman and their 'big tent'.
- Emphasis
- Senate leverage in a 50-50 split, the pairing of Fetterman with McCormick, and a charitable reading of his motives.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the Atlantic's polling on Democratic views of Fetterman and the quotes from Democrats such as Lamb and Deluzio.
- Charged language
- “Marxists”“radicalism”“the pig got up and slowly walked away”
What every side reports
- Fetterman's fundraising appeals were written to attract Trump-sympathetic donors and routed through Republican-aligned firms and Anedot.
- His relationship with Democratic-aligned MissionWired ended in June.
- He formed a joint fundraising committee with Republican Sen. Dave McCormick.
- Fetterman says he will not become a Republican.
Where accounts differ
-
Why Fetterman's fundraising and messaging shifted
- Left
- The Atlantic presents the shift as following his rejection by Democrats and deepening 'the mystery around his political intentions', and quotes Democrats blaming him for leaving.
- Right
- Hot Air says the shift may reflect Fetterman concluding the party 'had sold out to the Marxists' and needing funding to amplify his warnings, while also suggesting he is 'Getting More Republican'.
John Fetterman person
Says he has not changed his views, is mystified by Democratic rejection, and will not become a Republican.
““I can’t explain it. I mean, I haven’t changed my views,”” — The Atlantic
Dave McCormick person
Republican senator who formed a joint fundraising committee with Fetterman and whom Fetterman introduced at the GOP midterm convention.
“he introduced McCormick, whose campaign Fetterman had aggressively opposed in 2024” — The Atlantic
Democratic Party party
Leaders say the party is big enough for him, while some Democrats say he has left it.
“the party is big enough to accommodate his views” — The Atlantic
“Fetterman has become a distraction as the party tries to win midterm races” — The Atlantic
Left2 articles
-
John Fetterman’s Right-Wing Fundraising Deals
Critical Investigative piece portraying Fetterman's fundraising as a deliberate drift toward Republican donors and operatives.
-
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Hot AirR · · Opinion
Follow the Money: Fetterman Getting More Republican?
Mixed Opinion post that amplifies the Atlantic's findings while offering a sympathetic reading of Fetterman and attacking Democrats' embrace of socialists.
- 30 Sep 11:00 First The AtlanticLC John Fetterman’s Right-Wing Fundraising Deals
- 30 Sep 17:40 +6h 40m Hot AirR Follow the Money: Fetterman Getting More Republican? Opinion
- 30 Sep 19:11 +8h 12m Raw StoryL Outrage after Fetterman’s MAGA-linked fundraising deals exposed: ‘He betrays the people'
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.