Australia return to Newlands for series-deciding third Test, with Steve Smith in focus
Australia and South Africa meet in the third and deciding Test at Newlands, Cape Town, from Tuesday, with the series level at 1-1. The venue of the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal puts attention on Steve Smith, whose form on tour has been modest.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Australia and South Africa begin the series-deciding third Test at Newlands, Cape Town, on Tuesday, with the series level at 1-1 after big wins for each side in the first two games. CNAN “The series is level at 1-1 after big wins for both sides in the opening two games” Read at CNA ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “the series-deciding third Test against South Africa starts at Newlands on Tuesday” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Mixed · 2Newlands was the scene of the 2018 Sandpapergate ball-tampering scandal, and both reports say the contest may be as much mental as technical for several Australian players. CNAN “The battle may be mental as much as one of skill for several of the Australian players” Read at CNA ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “Australia returns to the scene of one of the darkest days in the country's cricket history” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Mixed · 2Former captain Steve Smith was at the centre of the scandal and bore the brunt of the fallout; he is averaging a little over 20 with the bat on this tour, and the reports say he would see the match as a chance to put that right. CNAN “Smith bore the brunt of the considerable fallout in Australia eight years ago” Read at CNA ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “averaging a little over 20 with the bat, he would see this as the perfect time to put that right” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
Centre · 1Current captain Pat Cummins, fast bowler Josh Hazlewood and spinner Nathan Lyon were also in the 2018 side; they say they had no knowledge of the attempt to alter the ball with sandpaper. CNAN “they say they had no knowledge of the attempt to alter the condition of the ball with a piece of sandpaper” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2Opener Travis Head said Smith "will be fine", pointing to his response in England in 2019, and said the team supports him because he has been through a lot and handles it well. CNAN “"He'll be fine," Australia opener Travis Head said of Smith.” Read at CNA ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “We support him.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Centre · 1There has been little talk of Sandpapergate in South Africa so far, but that could change at Newlands, where ticket sales for the first three days are strong after sparse crowds at the first two Tests in Durban and Gqeberha. CNAN “There has so far been little chatter in South Africa about Sandpapergate” Read at CNA ↗
Mixed · 2Wicketkeeper Alex Carey said the pitch looked another good surface, noting that Durban went five days and produced a contest between bat and ball. CNAN “it looked to be another good test-match pitch” Read at CNA ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “it looks another great surface” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Mixed · 2South Africa will be without fast bowler Anrich Nortje, who injured his groin in the second Test; captain Temba Bavuma said they would pick for the conditions from options including Gerald Coetzee, Dane Paterson, Corbin Bosch and Senuran Muthusamy. CNAN “South Africa will be without fast bowler Anrich Nortje, who injured his groin in the second test.” Read at CNA ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “the hosts would pick horses for courses in terms of his replacement” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Centre · 1No Test has been played at Newlands in October, and only three in November, all against Australia: Australia won in 1902 and 1921, and South Africa won by eight wickets in 2011, when Australia were bowled out for 47 in their second innings. CNAN “There has never been a test match played at Newlands in October, and just three in November, all against Australia.” Read at CNA ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- ABC News (Australia) leads with Smith's return to the Sandpapergate venue and Head's backing of him, and promotes its own live blog and radio coverage.
- Emphasis
- Smith's personal challenge and the scandal's legacy.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Nothing material omitted relative to the centre report; the body text is near-identical.
- Charged language
- “Sandpapergate”“one of the darkest days”
- For example
-
“Travis Head backs Steve Smith to be "fine" on his return to the ground where he made the decision that threatened his career.” — ABC News (Australia)
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- CNA frames the match as a test of more than bat and ball, with the scandal's psychological weight on Australia.
- Emphasis
- Mental challenge, ticket sales, pitch and venue history.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not state Smith's role in the 2018 decision as directly as the ABC intro does.
- Charged language
- “Sandpapergate”“one of the darkest days”
- For example
-
“The battle may be mental as much as one of skill for several of the Australian players” — CNA
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The third Test starts at Newlands on Tuesday with the series level at 1-1.
- Steve Smith was central to the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal and is averaging a little over 20 on this tour.
- Travis Head said Smith will be 'fine'.
- Anrich Nortje is out with a groin injury and South Africa must choose a replacement.
Steve Smith person
Smith is described as carrying the scandal's burden and under pressure for runs; Head says he handles it well and may be brought out best by it.
“Sometimes it brings the best out of him, as we've seen in the past.” — CNA
Australia national cricket team organisation
Australia's players present the pitch as promising and back Smith; those in the 2018 side say they knew nothing of the ball tampering.
“We support him.” — CNA
Left1 article
-
Smith will be 'fine' as Australia returns to Cape Town
Neutral Near-identical preview with a headline and intro focused on Smith being 'fine' and Sandpapergate, plus ABC coverage promotion.
Centre1 article
-
CNAN ·
Newlands to provide test of more than bat and ball for Australia
Neutral Preview framing the match as a mental as well as technical test for Australia at Newlands.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 25 Oct 10:33 First CNAN Newlands to provide test of more than bat and ball for Australia
- 25 Oct 20:55 +10h 23m ABC News (Australia)LC Smith will be 'fine' as Australia returns to Cape Town
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…