Australia's opening pairing unsettled ahead of second Test v South Africa in Gqeberha
After a 214-run win in Durban, Australia still have no settled opening pair before the second Test in Gqeberha on Sunday, while South Africa drop two batters and recall Kagiso Rabada.
Updated (version 2). Rewritten with the latest reporting.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 1Australia beat South Africa by 214 runs in the first Test in Durban, which ended on Tuesday, but the win did not settle who will open the batting for the second Test, which starts on Sunday in Gqeberha. CNAN “done little to resolve the uncertainty over their opening combination ahead of the second test in Gqeberha.” Read at CNA ↗ CNAN “The hosts suffered a 214-run defeat to Australia in the first test that ended in Durban on Tuesday” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1Matt Renshaw, an opener by trade, batted at number five in Durban and scored 190 and 82; Nic Maddinson, in his first Test in nearly 10 years, opened with Travis Head. Maddinson made a 33-ball duck in the first innings and 48 from 38 balls in the second, and Head made 20 runs in total. CNAN “Selectors surprised by picking Nic Maddinson to open the batting with Travis Head in the series-opening win in Durban” Read at CNA ↗ CNAN “Head managed a total of 20 runs in Durban operating with Nic Maddinson”“smashed 48 from 38 balls in his second innings after an ugly, 33-ball duck” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1Captain Pat Cummins said it would take a compelling argument to move Renshaw again, though he still thinks Renshaw "can be a great opener". Former captain Allan Border said his gut feeling was that Head is better off in the middle order, and Steve Waugh urged selectors to "pick and stick" and keep Renshaw at number five. CNAN “"I still think he can be a great opener, and now he's got another string to his bow that he's found this week,"”“my gut feel is that he's better off in the middle order," said former Australia captain Allan Border.” Read at CNA ↗ CNAN “"They've got to pick and stick now," Waugh told Australian media” Read at CNA ↗
Centre · 1Coach Andrew McDonald, who sits on the selection panel with George Bailey and Tony Dodemaide, said selectors are "open-minded" about the batting order and could make further changes depending on the surface in Gqeberha. CNAN “Selectors are open-minded about Australia's batting order and could make further changes for the second test against South Africa depending on the surface at Gqeberha” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1Cameron Green, who missed Durban with an abdominal strain, had yet to start batting as of Thursday and would be limited to batting if cleared. Josh Inglis, recovering from a broken finger, was further advanced, and a Friday preview said Green's return is likely delayed. CNAN ““Cam hasn’t started batting yet, he’s done some physical (work),” the coach said.” Read at CNA ↗ CNAN “with Cameron Green’s return from injury likely delayed” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1In the bowling attack, Josh Hazlewood took a career-best 6-49 in the fourth innings in Durban. Scott Boland is a possible inclusion as Australia monitor the workloads of Cummins, Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc, who each bowled at least 29 overs in the first Test. CNAN “Josh Hazlewood's career-best 6-49 in the fourth innings” Read at CNA ↗ CNAN “Scott Boland is brought into the attack as Australia monitor the workloads of Pat Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc after all three bowled at least 29 overs” Read at CNA ↗
Centre · 1Hazlewood said reverse swing could be decisive in the three-Test series because the pitches are abrasive and hard underfoot, and that St George's Park wickets are expected to be similar to Kingsmead. CNAN “Hazlewood predicts reverse swing may be crucial to the outcome of the three-test series against South Africa”““It’s abrasive wickets. It's very hard underfoot,” he explained.” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2South Africa have made changes after their batting failed in Durban, where only Aiden Markram passed 50. Coach Shukri Conrad dropped Tristan Stubbs and Kyle Verreynne; Marques Ackerman is tipped for a debut, Matthew Breetzke is expected to open with Markram, and Ryan Rickelton takes the gloves. ABC News (Australia)LC “Aiden Markram was the only Protea to pass 50 in the Test”“Batters Marques Ackerman and Matthew Breetzke are expected to come in at St George’s Park, with Ryan Rickelton to take gloves from Verreynne.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ CNAN “Matthew Breetzke is set to be given a renewed chance to open alongside Markram.” Read at CNA ↗ Mixed · 2Kagiso Rabada is set to return after a hamstring tear that kept him out of the ODIs and first Test, with one spinner expected to make way. David Bedingham said South Africa must take Australia's bowlers to 80, 100 or 120 overs, because "everyone gets tired eventually". ABC News (Australia)LC “showing no signs of the hamstring tear that sidelined him for through the ODIs and first Test.”“"It's just about trying to take them to 80 overs, 100 overs, 120 overs,"” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ CNAN “That means they will drop one spinner.” Read at CNA ↗
Mixed · 2South Africa, the reigning World Test champions after beating Australia at Lord's last year, are trying to avoid their first home series defeat since England toured in 2019-20. Persistent rain and damp conditions are forecast for Gqeberha, particularly on the first two days, which could cause delays or a shortened match. CNAN “South Africa secured a dramatic five-wicket victory over Australia to win the World Test Championship last year at Lord’s in London”“Persistent rain and damp conditions are forecast for Gqeberha, particularly on the opening two days” Read at CNA ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “the Proteas fight to avoid their first home series defeat since England toured in 2019-20.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- ABC Australia frames the story from South Africa's side: how the hosts plan to recover from a batting collapse by tiring Australia's pacemen.
- Emphasis
- Bedingham's comments on wearing down bowlers, Rabada's return, and South Africa's dropped batters; live-blog promotion.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not cover Australia's opening-pair debate, Green's fitness or selector comments.
- Charged language
- “bowling machines”“meek surrender”“arch-villain”
- For example
-
“the batters' meek surrender in Durban” — ABC News (Australia)
“Proteas urged to wear down Australia's bowling machines in second Test” — ABC News (Australia)
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- CNA's pieces centre on Australia's unresolved selection puzzle and the pre-match outlook for both sides, in a measured, reporting-led tone.
- Emphasis
- Opening-pair doubts, Renshaw's role, Green's fitness, bowler workloads, reverse swing and the weather forecast.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Little on South Africa's own bowling plans beyond Rabada's return; no South African players quoted on tactics.
- Charged language
- “mauling”“revolving door of selections”“time-worn attack”
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Australia won the first Test in Durban by 214 runs.
- The second Test starts on Sunday in Gqeberha.
- Kagiso Rabada is expected to return for South Africa.
- South Africa dropped Tristan Stubbs and Kyle Verreynne.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Australia's opening pairing and batting order should change
- Left
- Not addressed.
- Centre
- McDonald says selectors are open-minded; Waugh and Border urge stability or Head in the middle order; Cummins still sees Renshaw as a future opener.
Australia national cricket team organisation
Captain Cummins and coach McDonald stress options and flexibility rather than fixed roles.
“we’re more open-minded than that, but it doesn’t make it right either.” — CNA
South Africa national cricket team organisation
South Africa admit batting fragility and are changing the side, aiming to tire Australia's bowlers.
““We’ve been heavily reliant on (captain) Temba (Bavuma) and (opener) Aiden Markram and then the lower order runs,” he said” — CNA
“"I know they're machines, but everyone gets tired eventually.” — ABC News (Australia)
Matt Renshaw person
Renshaw's 190 and 82 at number five make him a strong middle-order option; Cummins still rates him as an opener.
“Renshaw producing a majestic 190 and second-innings 82 batting at number five” — CNA
Andrew McDonald person
McDonald says the batting order will depend on opponent and surface, and Green must prove fitness.
“McDonald said all-rounder Cameron Green had yet to prove his fitness” — CNA
Left1 article
-
Proteas urged to wear down Australia's bowling machines in second Test
Mixed South Africa-focused preview about wearing down Australia's bowlers and bouncing back from a batting failure.
Centre4 articles
-
CNAN ·
Renshaw's heroics do little to solve Australia's opening puzzle
Mixed Says Renshaw's success leaves Australia's opening question open, quoting Cummins and Border.
-
CNAN ·
Australia open-minded about batting order, Green still to prove fitness for second test: coach
Neutral Relays McDonald's open-minded selection stance alongside Waugh's call to stop tinkering and Green's fitness update.
-
CNAN ·
South Africa look to re-establish test credentials after Australia mauling
Neutral Previews South Africa's bid to prove their champion status, with expected changes and rain forecast.
-
CNAN ·
Hazlewood says reverse swing may be a factor in South Africa test series
Neutral Reports Hazlewood's view that reverse swing on abrasive pitches may decide the series.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 14 Oct 06:09 First CNAN Renshaw's heroics do little to solve Australia's opening puzzle
- 15 Oct 03:20 +21h 11m CNAN Australia open-minded about batting order, Green still to prove fitness for second test: coach
- 16 Oct 13:31 +55h 22m CNAN South Africa look to re-establish test credentials after Australia mauling
- 16 Oct 13:37 +55h 28m CNAN Hazlewood says reverse swing may be a factor in South Africa test series
- 16 Oct 20:53 +62h 44m ABC News (Australia)LC Proteas urged to wear down Australia's bowling machines in second Test
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…