Skip to content
Bramble

UK

Heathrow third runway: industry expects Burnham to back it as critics urge a block

After Prime Minister Andy Burnham and transport secretary Heidi Alexander declined to endorse the Heathrow third runway, aviation executives told City A.M. they expect it to proceed. A Guardian columnist argues Burnham should block it.

2 outlets · 1L · 0C · 1R First reported Account updated
Image: City A.M.
Image: The Guardian

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Right · 1Prime Minister Andy Burnham refused five times in a BBC interview to say whether the government supports a third runway at Heathrow, saying it was "a matter for London and Londoners" to decide. Right · 1Transport secretary Heidi Alexander told the News Agents podcast that expansion was a "very significant infrastructure project" to be weighed against climate obligations and its impact on locals. Mixed · 2The remarks were widely read as a cooling from the Starmer government's backing, when then-chancellor Rachel Reeves said the government supported a third runway and invited proposals.

Right · 1Several aviation figures told City A.M. they are confident the project will survive, arguing that the refusal to endorse it showed Burnham had not yet assessed expansion and that work across government is not being slowed or stopped. Right · 1They also argued that the economic case would prevail and that Treasury officials would balk at the cost of abandoning the project. One airline executive said Burnham "doesn't know what he thinks yet" and is treading carefully because a process could be legally challenged later. Right · 1The public consultation on the National Policy Statement, the framework for judging applications from Heathrow and rival bidder Heathrow West, has closed, and a final draft is expected early next year.

Mixed · 2Heathrow's owner has conceded that Reeves's 2035 target is not achievable. City A.M. reports it said flights could start a decade after planning approval in 2029, and the Guardian column puts the estimated completion date at 2039. Right · 1Heathrow West's Surinder Arora said he hopes the government is reconsidering and will favour his group's simpler scheme. A spokesman for British Airways owner IAG said expansion, if affordably scoped, would boost jobs and trade. Right · 1A Department for Transport spokeswoman said there is no live planning application and that the timeline has always been ambitious.

Left · 1In a Guardian opinion column, George Monbiot argues Burnham should block the runway. He cites Department for Transport analysis putting its net cost at £23.4bn to £62.5bn and its GDP boost at 0.03% to 0.05%, against the 0.43% Reeves cited from an airport-commissioned report. Left · 1Monbiot also cites the Climate Change Committee's warning on aviation emissions and argues that sustainable aviation fuel cannot solve the problem. He calls for a frequent flyer levy and describes the "growth" case as cover for lobbyists.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
A Guardian opinion column urging Burnham to block the runway on cost, climate and fairness grounds.
Emphasis
Government cost-benefit figures, climate emissions, scepticism of sustainable aviation fuel, frequent flyer levy and lobbying.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not give industry's view that the economic case will win or the Department for Transport's statement on the process.
Charged language
“expensive disaster”“techno-bollocks”“wealthy, selfish minority”
For example
“Burnham needs to block it” — The Guardian
“we continue to subsidise a wealthy, selfish minority” — The Guardian

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right1 outlet

Framing
A news report on industry confidence that Burnham will not abandon the flagship expansion, led by sources inside the sector.
Emphasis
Industry reading of the Prime Minister's remarks, Treasury economics, process and timeline, and rival Heathrow West bid.
Leaves out or plays down
Gives little space to climate or health costs beyond Alexander's remark, and no environmental voices.
Charged language
“flagship expansion”“megaproject”“thrown into disarray”
For example
“The aviation industry is confident that Andy Burnham won’t abandon the government’s flagship expansion of Heathrow” — City A.M.
“The future of the third runway was thrown into disarray this week” — City A.M.

Ask about this story

Loading…