Balakrishnan says Wong and Prabowo committed to resolving Singapore-Indonesia issues, haze
After a visit to Jakarta, Singapore's foreign minister said PM Lawrence Wong and President Prabowo Subianto have set a political commitment to do what is necessary on haze and other bilateral issues. The visit followed tensions over haze and Indonesian gas export cuts.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 2Singapore's Foreign Minister Vivian Balakrishnan said on Wednesday 28 October that Prime Minister Lawrence Wong and Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto had communicated "at the highest level" and set a political commitment to do what is necessary on bilateral challenges, including haze. CNAN “Communication has occurred at the highest level between my prime minister and President Prabowo,”” Read at CNA ↗ South China Morning PostN “Prabowo and Singaporean Prime Minister Lawrence Wong had already corresponded “at the highest level”.” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Centre · 1Balakrishnan said the plans now had to be implemented, but gave no details of what the two leaders discussed. CNAN “He did not give further details on what was discussed between both leaders.”“now we'll have to implement those plans, execute that commitment,” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1The remarks followed a two-day visit to Jakarta. On Tuesday Balakrishnan met Indonesian Foreign Minister Arrmanatha Nasir, and they announced a joint task force to coordinate investigations into errant companies by sharing information and cross-border evidence. The two countries also announced a new hotline for handling differences. CNAN “announced a joint task force to coordinate investigations into errant companies by sharing information and cross-border evidence.”“Singapore and Indonesia also announced a new hotline to handle any differences in bilateral issues.” Read at CNA ↗
Centre · 1Arrmanatha said tackling haze was a "top national priority" for Prabowo and that "No border should shield those who profit from burning our forests". CNAN ““No border should shield those who profit from burning our forests,” he said.” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1The South China Morning Post reported that Balakrishnan met Prabowo at the president's private residence on Wednesday. It said Indonesian Cabinet Secretary Teddy Wijaya, as cited by local media, described the visit as sudden and requested at Singapore's initiative. South China Morning PostN “Balakrishnan met Prabowo at his private residence on Wednesday”“Singapore’s foreign minister had flown in “suddenly” and requested an audience with Prabowo” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Centre · 1Balakrishnan said the trip was meant to ensure "high-level direct communication", adding that "You can't conduct diplomacy just by the phone or through the media". South China Morning PostN ““You can’t conduct diplomacy just by the phone or through the media, with all due respect.” Read at South China Morning Post ↗
Centre · 1Gas supply was another point of friction. Indonesia began reducing natural gas exports to Singapore on 24 October to divert supplies to domestic electricity needs, and Indonesian minister Bahlil Lahadalia said on 26 October the cuts were within contractual limits. Wong told a People's Action Party convention that Singapore expected all parties to "honour their commitments". CNAN “On Oct 24, Indonesia began reducing natural gas exports to Singapore to divert more supplies to domestic electricity needs.”“These cuts are within contractual limits, said Indonesian Coordinating Minister for Downstreaming and Energy Transition Bahlil Lahadalia on Oct 26.” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1Asked about the gas contracts, Balakrishnan said both sides shared a common commitment to the "sanctity of contract", which he said bears on the credibility and competitiveness of both economies. CNAN “Dr Balakrishnan said Indonesia and Singapore have a “common commitment” to the sanctity of contracts” Read at CNA ↗ Centre · 1The SCMP said tensions had also been fuelled by allegations of economic sabotage. Former Indonesian trade minister Muhammad Lutfi claimed Temasek and GIC were pushing MSCI to downgrade Jakarta's market status, which both firms swiftly denied. Observers noted Balakrishnan did not explicitly raise these incidents during the visit. South China Morning PostN “prompting swift denials from both firms.”“Observers noted that Balakrishnan did not explicitly raise both incidents during his visit.” Read at South China Morning Post ↗
Centre · 1Online rhetoric escalated as well. Former Singapore nominated MP Calvin Cheng floated cutting undersea cables, and Indonesian Communications Minister Meutya Hafid replied that severing them would put 80 per cent of Singapore's connectivity capacity at risk. Protests over the government's handling of forest fires broke out in Jakarta on Wednesday. South China Morning PostN ““Should they be severed, whether accidentally or intentionally, 80 per cent of Singapore’s connectivity capacity would be at risk of collapse,” she wrote on social media.”“Protests led by student leaders and civil society groups broke out in Jakarta on Wednesday” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Centre · 1Analysts quoted by the SCMP described the trip as consistent with Singapore's "quiet diplomacy" toward its larger neighbour. Lina Alexandra of CSIS called the task force a "good start" that needs follow-up, and Jefferson Ng of RSIS said the overall relationship was strong enough to "weather the storm", citing 26 agreements signed in July. South China Morning PostN “said the task force was a “good start” but would require high levels of inter-agency cooperation.”“In July, leaders of the two countries signed 26 agreements which spanned areas such as economy, energy and defence.” Read at South China Morning Post ↗ Centre · 1Balakrishnan acknowledged that recent weeks were a "period of concern, anxiety and anger" in Singapore, where air quality had breached "very unhealthy levels". South China Morning PostN “a “period of concern, anxiety and anger” for residents in Singapore” Read at South China Morning Post ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- CNA reports the minister's statements and the announced mechanisms (task force, hotline); the SCMP frames the trip as quiet diplomacy to defuse tensions, with analyst commentary.
- Emphasis
- CNA stresses political commitment, haze cooperation and the sanctity of contract. The SCMP stresses nationalist rhetoric, the gas cut, the MSCI allegation, the cable spat and Jakarta protests.
- Leaves out or plays down
- CNA does not mention the meeting with Prabowo, the protests or the MSCI and cable disputes. The SCMP gives the gas dispute less detail than CNA, including Wong's remarks and Bahlil's contractual-limits statement.
- Charged language
- “quiet diplomacy”“surprise visit”“terse exchanges”
- For example
-
“it sets the political commitment on both sides to do what is necessary” — CNA
“underscores a bid to defuse growing tensions and seek a direct channel to President Prabowo Subianto.” — South China Morning Post
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Balakrishnan visited Jakarta and met Indonesian Foreign Minister Arrmanatha Nasir on 27 October.
- A joint task force on companies linked to haze-causing fires was announced.
- Wong and Prabowo have communicated at the highest level, with no details given.
- Indonesia began cutting gas exports to Singapore on 24 October.
Vivian Balakrishnan person
Says the two leaders have set a political commitment to do what is necessary, that direct face-to-face contact matters, and that contracts must be upheld.
“Look at actions, not just at words … Contracts mean something, and the sanctity of contract is upheld.” — CNA
“There’s face-to-face direct explanation, conveying concerns, and also looking for solutions,”” — South China Morning Post
Lawrence Wong person
Said Singapore expects all parties to gas contracts to honour their commitments and that its gas importer will protect its rights and interests.
“honour their commitments” — CNA
Prabowo Subianto person
Described through his foreign minister as a national-priority supporter of haze action, and as having corresponded with Wong; he did not comment directly in the coverage.
“Tackling the haze issue is a “top national priority” for Indonesia President Prabowo Subianto” — CNA
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre2 articles
-
CNAN ·
Neutral Straight report of Balakrishnan's post-visit remarks on leader-level commitment, the task force and hotline, and gas contracts.
-
Singapore wields ‘quiet diplomacy’ in minister’s surprise visit to Indonesia amid haze tensions
Mixed Analysis presenting the visit as a de-escalation bid amid nationalist rhetoric, with expert commentary.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 28 Oct 11:53 First CNAN PM Wong, Prabowo committed to ‘do what is necessary’ to tackle bilateral issues, including haze: Vivian Balakrishnan
- 29 Oct 14:35 +26h 43m South China Morning PostN Singapore wields ‘quiet diplomacy’ in minister’s surprise visit to Indonesia amid haze tensions
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…