Gunmen attack Binnari village in Taraba, Nigeria; death toll put at 25 to 52
Gunmen on motorcycles raided Binnari in Nigeria's Taraba State on Friday, looting and burning shops. Counts of the dead range from 10 to 52 depending on the source, and Amnesty International accuses the authorities of failing to protect rural communities.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Centre · 2Gunmen on motorcycles attacked the village of Binnari, in the Karim Lamido area of Taraba State, northeast Nigeria, shortly after Friday prayers, looting and burning shops and houses. BBC NewsN “The gunmen reportedly swooped on the village of Binnari in the Karim Lamido area mounted on motorcycles just after midday Muslim prayers on Friday” Read at BBC News ↗ Gulf NewsN “killing dozens of people shortly after Friday prayers. They also looted and burned stores.” Read at Gulf News ↗ Centre · 1A community leader, Malam Abubakar Saifullahi, told AFP the attackers came on about 50 motorcycles, two men apiece, and took cash, food and abandoned motorcycles; the BBC reported the rampage lasted up to four hours. BBC NewsN “the attackers had arrived on about 50 motorcycles, two men apiece.”“a rampage that went on for up to four hours” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1The reported death toll rose over time and differs by source. Police first said they had recovered 10 bodies with gunshot wounds, while survivors counted at least 20 dead. BBC NewsN “police said they recovered 10 bodies with gunshot wounds after officers responded to a distress call.”“Survivors who spoke to AFP said they had counted at least 20 dead.” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 2Amnesty International said on Saturday that at least 40 people were killed, and its Nigeria director, Isa Sanusi, said families told the group up to 50 had died, noting that the initial funeral had 37 people. The Taraba State government put the toll at 25 on Sunday, a discrepancy Anadolu said could not immediately be reconciled. Anadolu AgencyN “Amnesty International said Saturday evening that at least 40 people were killed in the assault, while the Taraba State government on Sunday put the death toll at 25.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ BBC NewsN “"The initial funeral had 37 people," he said.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1By Sunday, AFP reported the toll had reached at least 50, after residents said seven bodies were found on Friday and another 43 in a river on Saturday; Amnesty later gave a toll of 52. Gulf NewsN “"The following day, Saturday, we discovered another 43 bodies in the river, bringing the total to 50,"”“Amnesty International gave a toll of 52 on Sunday” Read at Gulf News ↗ Centre · 1Police and Amnesty both said some victims drowned while fleeing, and Amnesty said some were chased into the river by the gunmen. State police spokesman Victor Msheliza (named Mshelizah by the BBC) said officers were still searching the area and more deployments were being sent. Gulf NewsN “Both police and Amnesty said some of the victims had drowned while trying to flee the attackers.”“Police were immediately deployed to the area after the attack, more deployments being sent, he said.” Read at Gulf News ↗
Centre · 1Police told the BBC the attackers had fled before officers arrived and that no casualties occurred on either side, which they attributed to difficult terrain the gunmen know well. BBC NewsN “"We were able to disperse the unknown gunmen though there was no casualty on their side and ours because the terrain is difficult and they're used to the terrain,"” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 2AFP described the attackers as a suspected "bandit" gang; bandits in Nigeria are described as driven by money rather than ideology, kidnapping for ransom and killing in poorly policed rural areas. No group has been named as responsible in the coverage, and the BBC called them unknown gunmen. Gulf NewsN “Driven by money rather than ideology, the bandits in Nigeria target poorly policed rural areas, kidnapping for ransom and killing.” Read at Gulf News ↗ BBC NewsN “Unknown gunmen have raided a remote village in the northeast Nigerian state of Taraba” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 2Amnesty called for an impartial investigation and accused the authorities of leaving rural communities "at the mercy of gunmen that repeatedly commit atrocities with impunity". Gulf NewsN “"at the mercy of gunmen that repeatedly commit atrocities with impunity."” Read at Gulf News ↗ Anadolu AgencyN “Amnesty International called for an impartial investigation into the killings, justice for the victims and stronger protection for communities at risk of further attacks.” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗
Centre · 1Governor Agbu Kefas condemned the killings and urged security agencies to step up protection and arrest those responsible, while his reelection campaign council warned politicians against politicizing the tragedy after criticism of the state government's handling of insecurity. Anadolu AgencyN “State Governor Agbu Kefas on Sunday condemned the killings and called on security agencies to intensify efforts to protect residents and apprehend those responsible.”“The governor’s reelection campaign council separately warned politicians against politicizing the tragedy” Read at Anadolu Agency ↗ Centre · 2The attack comes amid wider insecurity in Nigeria, including a jihadist insurgency in the northeast lasting nearly two decades and banditry in the northwest and central regions. BBC NewsN “The country is also battling a jihadist insurgency in its northeast that has lasted nearly two decades” Read at BBC News ↗ Gulf NewsN “Banditry has become a growing problem in northwest and central Nigeria” Read at Gulf News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre3 outlets
- Framing
- All three outlets report the attack as a mass-casualty raid with an uncertain, rising toll, and give prominence to Amnesty International's criticism of the authorities.
- Emphasis
- Differing death tolls (BBC lead at 10, Anadolu at 25 vs 40, AFP at 50); AFP adds the drowning and the bandit context; Anadolu adds the governor and election-campaign politics.
- Leaves out or plays down
- BBC and Anadolu do not report the later river discoveries; AFP does not report the state government's figure of 25 or the governor's response.
- Charged language
- “massacre”“bandit”
- For example
-
“Death toll rises in Nigeria’s Taraba massacre as residents flee” — Anadolu Agency
“Toll in Nigeria 'bandit' attack jumps to at least 50” — Gulf News
“Gunmen kill at least 10 villagers and loot shops in northeast Nigeria” — BBC News
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Gunmen on motorcycles attacked Binnari in Taraba State, Nigeria, on Friday, looting and burning property.
- Amnesty International called for an impartial investigation and criticised the authorities' failure to protect rural communities.
- The death toll is higher than the 10 bodies police first recovered, and police were still searching the area.
Where accounts differ
-
Death toll
- Centre
- BBC: police 10 recovered, survivors 20, Amnesty up to 50. Anadolu: state government 25, Amnesty 40. AFP via Gulf News: at least 50 per survivors, Amnesty 52.
-
Attackers on motorcycles raided Binnari village in Taraba State, Nigeria, looting shops and burning property.
Reported- Reports 3
- Anadolu Agency, BBC News, Gulf News
-
The death toll from the Binnari attack is at least 50 (survivors and Amnesty).
Mixed- Supports 1
- Gulf News
- Disputes 1
- Anadolu Agency
- Reports 1
- BBC News
-
Amnesty International accused Nigerian authorities of failing to protect rural communities and called for an impartial investigation.
Reported- Reports 3
- Anadolu Agency, BBC News, Gulf News
Nigeria place
Nigerian authorities are accused by Amnesty of failing to protect rural communities; police say they responded and are still searching, and the Taraba government puts the toll at 25.
“the Taraba State government on Sunday put the death toll at 25” — Anadolu Agency
“the authorities were accused by Amnesty International of failing to protect rural communities” — BBC News
Taraba place
Taraba's governor condemned the killings and urged security agencies to protect residents; his campaign council warned against politicizing the tragedy.
“The governor’s reelection campaign council separately warned politicians against politicizing the tragedy” — Anadolu Agency
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre3 articles
-
Gunmen kill at least 10 villagers and loot shops in northeast Nigeria
Neutral Early report leading with police's count of 10 while flagging much higher estimates from survivors and Amnesty.

-
Death toll rises in Nigeria’s Taraba massacre as residents flee
Neutral Focuses on the dispute between the state government's and Amnesty's tolls and the political reaction.

-
Gulf NewsN · · via AFP
Toll in Nigeria 'bandit' attack jumps to at least 50
Neutral AFP copy carried by Gulf News reporting a toll of at least 50 with drownings, and explaining banditry in Nigeria.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 25 Oct 03:20 First BBC NewsN Gunmen kill at least 10 villagers and loot shops in northeast Nigeria
- 25 Oct 13:41 +10h 22m Anadolu AgencyN Death toll rises in Nigeria’s Taraba massacre as residents flee
- 26 Oct 00:48 +21h 28m Gulf NewsN Toll in Nigeria 'bandit' attack jumps to at least 50 via AFP
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…