Bardella denies Mediapart report of antisemitic messages from 2013
Mediapart alleges National Rally president Jordan Bardella wrote antisemitic remarks in private chats in 2013. Bardella denies it, says he is suing, and calls it an attempt to destabilise the 2027 campaign.
Updated (version 4). New coverage since the last version from Arab News, Haaretz, RFI.
1 / 5
The story, neutrally told
The website Mediapart published a report alleging that Jordan Bardella, president of France's National Rally (RN), made antisemitic remarks in private chats in 2013, when he was 17 or 18. BBC NewsN “Among the statements that Mediapart alleges Bardella made when he was 17 or 18 are” Read at BBC News ↗ The Straits TimesRC “Mediapart’s investigation is built on comments in private chats allegedly written by Bardella” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The alleged remarks include "All the banks are owned by Jews" and "The Jew has to dominate other people, crush them and rob them". BBC NewsN “"All the banks are owned by Jews"; "The Jew has to dominate other people, crush them and rob them"” Read at BBC News ↗ Mediapart says it independently authenticated the conversations, but it published no screenshots. BBC NewsN “Mediapart did not produce screen-grabs of any of the alleged remarks.” Read at BBC News ↗ RFIN “nor were there any screen grabs of extracts published” Read at RFI ↗
Bardella, 31, denied the allegations and spoke of "the beginnings of a total war" to destabilise the presidential campaign. The Straits TimesRC “We are seeing the beginnings of a total war, an attempt to destabilise the presidential campaign” Read at The Straits Times ↗ RFIN “Bardella announced that he had filed a complaint for defamation.” Read at RFI ↗ He said either Mediapart was running the operation or it was being manipulated by interested parties, and that he had instructed his lawyer to sue for libel. BBC NewsN “Either Mediapart is running this operation itself, or it is being manipulated by interested parties.” Read at BBC News ↗ Marine Le Pen said Bardella has her "total confidence" and vowed the RN would "counter-attack"; she said the remarks seemed so odd they could only be a forgery. The Straits TimesRC “Le Pen reaffirmed she had “total confidence” in her young lieutenant and vowed the RN would “counter-attack”” Read at The Straits Times ↗ BBC NewsN “they can only be a forgery” Read at BBC News ↗
RN deputy Jean-Philippe Tanguy blamed members expelled for antisemitism, while left-wing politicians called on Bardella to resign and Crif head Yonathan Arfi said the remarks illustrated the limits of the RN's clean-up. BBC NewsN “Leftwing politicians called on Bardella to resign” Read at BBC News ↗ RFIN “This illustrates the limits of the effort to shed the pariah status of the National Rally” Read at RFI ↗ Julien Aubert of The Republicans said that either Mediapart is right and Bardella cannot continue, or it has taken a great risk. The Straits TimesRC “Either Mediapart is right – in which case I do not see how Jordan Bardella can continue” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Israeli diaspora minister Amichai Chikli defended Bardella, citing his statements against Hamas and his 2025 visit to Israel, and attacked Mediapart's leaders. Arab NewsRC “Bardella “is one of the clearest voices in Europe against Hamas,”” Read at Arab News ↗ HaaretzLC “Diaspora Affairs Minister Amichai Chikli defended far-right French politician Jordan Bardella on Tuesday” Read at Haaretz ↗
The claims come as Le Pen leads polls and the RN, which styles itself a "shield for the Jewish community", tries to shed its antisemitic past. BBC NewsN “The RN even styles itself as a "shield for the Jewish community".” Read at BBC News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Haaretz, running Reuters copy, focuses on the Israeli angle: Chikli's defence of Bardella as cementing Israeli government ties with Europe's far right.
- Emphasis
- Israeli government relations with the European far right; describes the comments as widely condemned.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Bardella's denial, the lawsuit and Mediapart's authentication are not in the available text.
- Charged language
- “further cementing Chikli's and the Israeli government's ties with Europe's far right”
- For example
-
“further cementing Chikli's and the Israeli government's ties with Europe's far right” — Haaretz
Centre3 outlets
- Framing
- BBC, France 24 and RFI lead with Bardella's denial, his "total war" claim and the planned lawsuit, and place the row against Le Pen's poll lead and the RN's image repositioning.
- Emphasis
- Denial and legal action, Le Pen's backing, reactions from the left and Crif, and what it means for the 2027 race.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Little on the Israeli minister's defence of Bardella in the centre articles read.
- Charged language
- “total war”“hard-right”
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- AFP copy carried by the Straits Times stresses Le Pen's defiance and Bardella's denial; AFP copy carried by Arab News leads with Chikli's defence of Bardella.
- Emphasis
- Le Pen's vow to counter-attack and Kevlar remark; Chikli's attacks on Mediapart and Bardella's Israel visit.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Arab News item leaves out Crif and left-wing calls to resign.
- Charged language
- “Kevlar vest”“activist media”
- For example
-
“Mediapart that needs to be told to put on its Kevlar vest” — The Straits Times
“Israeli minister defends French far-right’s Bardella in antisemitism row” — Arab News
What every side reports
- Mediapart alleges Bardella wrote antisemitic remarks in private chats in 2013.
- Bardella denies the allegations and says he is taking legal action.
- Mediapart published no screenshots.
- Le Pen expressed total confidence in Bardella.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the messages are authentic
- Left
- Haaretz's Reuters copy calls them resurfaced comments by Bardella.
- Centre
- Reported as allegations Bardella denies; Mediapart says it authenticated them without publishing screenshots.
- Right
- Reported as allegations; Bardella calls it a smear by an "activist media".
-
Who is behind the report
- Left
- Not addressed in the available text.
- Centre
- Bardella says Mediapart either ran or was manipulated into an operation; Tanguy blames expelled members.
- Right
- Le Pen says opponents will do anything to derail momentum; Chikli attacks Mediapart's leaders.
-
Bardella wrote antisemitic remarks in private written chats in 2013.
Reported- Supports 1
- Haaretz
- Reports 5
- BBC News, France 24, RFI, Arab News, The Straits Times
-
The antisemitism allegations against Bardella are a fabrication aimed at destabilising the 2027 campaign.
Reported- Reports 5
- BBC News, France 24, RFI, Arab News, The Straits Times
-
Mediapart authenticated the chats but published no screenshots.
Reported- Reports 4
- BBC News, France 24, RFI, The Straits Times
-
The Mediapart report is a plot to derail Le Pen's campaign.
Reported- Reports 4
- BBC News, France 24, RFI, The Straits Times
Jordan Bardella person
Denies the remarks, calls the report part of a "total war" to derail the campaign, and is suing.
“He denounced what he called a bid to “kill my political career”.” — The Straits Times
Marine Le Pen person
Backs Bardella, says opponents will stoop to anything, and vows a counter-attack against Mediapart.
“Le Pen said she had "total confidence" in Bardella” — RFI
Mediapart organisation
Says it investigated for months and independently authenticated the conversations, corroborated by witness statements.
“It said it had "independently authenticated" the conversations” — BBC News
Amichai Chikli person
Defends Bardella as a clear voice against Hamas and attacks Mediapart's leadership.
“He met survivors. He spoke in Jerusalem against antisemitism.” — Arab News
Israel1 outlet
Haaretz frames the story through Chikli's support for Bardella and Israel's ties with the European far right.
“further cementing Chikli's and the Israeli government's ties with Europe's far right” — Haaretz
Haaretz
Europe2 outlets
RFI covers domestic reactions including allies, the left and Jewish groups.
“Several members of the RN party spoke out in defence of Bardella.” — RFI
France 24, RFI
Left1 article
-
HaaretzLC · · via Reuters
Israeli diaspora minister backs French far-right leader amid antisemitism allegations
Critical Reuters copy in Haaretz presents Chikli's defence as deepening Israeli government ties with the European far right.

Centre10 articles
-

-

-

-
French hard-right leader accuses opponents of 'total war' after claims of antisemitism
Neutral BBC sets out the allegations, denial and reactions with poll context, noting Mediapart is avowedly left-wing.
Show 6 moreShow fewer
-

-
RFIN ·
Le Pen ally Bardella sues over antisemitism claims, alleges 'total war'
Neutral RFI reports the denial, lawsuit and wide-ranging reactions from allies, the left and Jewish groups.

-

-

-

-

Right2 articles
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via AFP
France’s Le Pen defiant after top ally hit by anti-Semitism claims
Neutral AFP copy in the Straits Times centres on Le Pen's defiance and includes Mediapart's authentication and Aubert's comment.
-
Arab NewsRC · · via AFP
Israeli minister defends French far-right’s Bardella in antisemitism row
Neutral AFP copy in Arab News leads with Israeli minister Chikli's defence and his attacks on Mediapart leaders.

- 29 Sep 12:06 First France 24N French far-right leader Bardella denies anti-Semitism allegations
- 29 Sep 12:35 +30m France 24N French far-right says anti-Semitism claims part of 'total war' to derail presidency bid
- 29 Sep 12:37 +31m France 24N French far-right leader Bardella says filed lawsuit over anti-Semitic remarks claim
- 29 Sep 13:20 +1h 14m BBC NewsN French hard-right leader accuses opponents of 'total war' after claims of antisemitism
- 29 Sep 13:33 +1h 28m France 24N France's Le Pen vows to 'counterattack' after top ally Bardella hit by anti-Semitism claims
- 29 Sep 14:32 +2h 26m RFIN Le Pen ally Bardella sues over antisemitism claims, alleges 'total war'
- 29 Sep 15:00 +2h 54m The Straits TimesRC France’s Le Pen defiant after top ally hit by anti-Semitism claims via AFP
- 29 Sep 15:10 +3h 5m France 24N France's Le Pen defiant after top ally hit by antisemitism claims
- 29 Sep 15:11 +3h 5m France 24N French far-right leader Bardella denies anti-Semitism accusations
- 29 Sep 23:47 +11h 41m Arab NewsRC Israeli minister defends French far-right’s Bardella in antisemitism row via AFP
- 30 Sep 00:19 +12h 13m France 24N Still the same far-right? Le Pen's National Rally denies fresh antisemitism claims
- 30 Sep 11:58 +23h 52m France 24N 'People have been buying into the detoxification of the National Rally.' says Andrew Smith
- 30 Sep 13:16 +25h 10m HaaretzLC Israeli diaspora minister backs French far-right leader amid antisemitism allegations via Reuters
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.