Skip to content
Bramble

Entertainment

Bill's Included: Rob Brydon's BBC One sitcom gets mixed reviews

Two left-leaning UK outlets review Bill's Included, a six-part BBC One sitcom starring Rob Brydon as a lonely 60-year-old landlord. Both say Brydon dominates and the supporting characters are thin, but The Guardian praises him while The Independent finds the show unoriginal.

2 outlets · 2L · 0C · 0R First reported Account updated
Image: The Independent
Image: The Guardian

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Left · 2Bill's Included is a six-part BBC One sitcom led by Rob Brydon, with 30-minute episodes, written by Ben Ashenden and Alexander Owen of the social media duo The Pin. Left · 2Brydon plays Bill Beam, who has turned 60, been left by his wife and is short of money, and who takes in four students displaced by a fire at the local student halls. Left · 2The tenants are Zahra (Yasmin Al-Khudhairi), James (Harry Baxendale), Christian (Dylan Brady) and Hettie (Ada Player). Kevin Eldon plays Bill's friend Drew and Samantha Spiro plays his neighbour Siobhan.

Left · 2Both reviewers quote Bill's line "Don't think of me as a landlord" and his claim to be a "land friend", and both compare the character to Brydon's earlier roles, notably Uncle Bryn in Gavin & Stacey. Left · 1The Guardian's Sarah Dempster calls Brydon's performance "sublime" and the show "very sweet", describing it as a big, broad, unapologetically traditional vehicle for him, and says his performance outweighs the show's faults. Left · 1Dempster is critical of the writing, calling the storylines "made from string", the supporting characters flimsy ciphers, and noting that attempts to flesh them out make "the chuckles turn to dust". She also suspects the makers were unsure whether to go mainstream or lean into sharper, darker elements.

Left · 1The Independent's Nick Hilton is more negative. He places the show against what he calls a BBC comedy crisis of cut budgets and the closure of BBC Three as a broadcast channel, and says it shows "the future of British comedy looks a lot like its past". Left · 1Hilton says the show "is doing nothing original". He compares its student archetypes with those in Channel 4's It Gets Worse and Break Clause, which he says treat generational stereotypes more interestingly, and he likens Bill to Keith from Marion and Geoff. Left · 1Hilton says Brydon operates as a "comedic black hole", leaving the show unbalanced and its six episodes too short to develop the characters or a budding student romance. He concedes the writers can construct a joke, citing a supergluing prank, and calls it "perfectly adequate" as a vehicle for Brydon's schtick but "disposable", built for a middle-aged, middle-ground audience.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left2 outlets

Framing
Both are opinion reviews. The Guardian leads with praise for Brydon's character while faulting the writing. The Independent uses the show as a test of BBC comedy commissioning and finds it derivative.
Emphasis
Brydon's central performance, comparisons to Uncle Bryn and Keith, and thin supporting characters. The Independent adds BBC budget context and rival Channel 4 sitcoms.
Leaves out or plays down
Neither covers the show's viewing figures, broadcast schedule or the BBC's own account of the commission; only left-leaning outlets are in this set.
Charged language
“comedic black hole”“sublime”“Brydonicity”“disposable”
For example
“Not a good sign for the future of British comedy” — The Independent
“The comic is sublime as a middle-aged landlord attempting to befriend student tenants.” — The Guardian

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right0 outlets

No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Ask about this story

Loading…