Bill's Included: Rob Brydon's BBC One sitcom gets mixed reviews
Two left-leaning UK outlets review Bill's Included, a six-part BBC One sitcom starring Rob Brydon as a lonely 60-year-old landlord. Both say Brydon dominates and the supporting characters are thin, but The Guardian praises him while The Independent finds the show unoriginal.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2Bill's Included is a six-part BBC One sitcom led by Rob Brydon, with 30-minute episodes, written by Ben Ashenden and Alexander Owen of the social media duo The Pin. The IndependentLC “a six-part sitcom led by Rob Brydon” Read at The Independent ↗ The GuardianLC “Written by The Pin’s Ben Ashenden and Alexander Owen” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 2Brydon plays Bill Beam, who has turned 60, been left by his wife and is short of money, and who takes in four students displaced by a fire at the local student halls. The IndependentLC “He’s turned 60 and his wife has left him, leaving him lonely and strapped for cash.” Read at The Independent ↗ The GuardianLC “Enter, stage left, a fire at the local student halls” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 2The tenants are Zahra (Yasmin Al-Khudhairi), James (Harry Baxendale), Christian (Dylan Brady) and Hettie (Ada Player). Kevin Eldon plays Bill's friend Drew and Samantha Spiro plays his neighbour Siobhan. The GuardianLC “Zahra (Yasmin Al-Khudhairi), James (Harry Baxendale), Christian (Dylan Brady) and Hettie (Ada Player)” Read at The Guardian ↗ The IndependentLC “Bill’s neighbour, Siobhan (Samantha Spiro)” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 2Both reviewers quote Bill's line "Don't think of me as a landlord" and his claim to be a "land friend", and both compare the character to Brydon's earlier roles, notably Uncle Bryn in Gavin & Stacey. The IndependentLC “He is, essentially, Brynn from Gavin and Stacey, with slightly more experience of the real world.” Read at The Independent ↗ The GuardianLC “a character as exquisitely excruciating as Gavin & Stacey’s Uncle Bryn” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 1The Guardian's Sarah Dempster calls Brydon's performance "sublime" and the show "very sweet", describing it as a big, broad, unapologetically traditional vehicle for him, and says his performance outweighs the show's faults. The GuardianLC “The problem with Bill’s Included is that beyond Brydon’s sublime performance there is, alas, not much.”“it is a big, broad and unapologetically traditional vehicle for Rob Brydon” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 1Dempster is critical of the writing, calling the storylines "made from string", the supporting characters flimsy ciphers, and noting that attempts to flesh them out make "the chuckles turn to dust". She also suspects the makers were unsure whether to go mainstream or lean into sharper, darker elements. The GuardianLC “The storylines are made from string and the supporting characters from abandoned sausage casings.”“there may have been some in-development swithering between whether to go full-mainstream or to lean in to the series’ sharper, darker elements” Read at The Guardian ↗
Left · 1The Independent's Nick Hilton is more negative. He places the show against what he calls a BBC comedy crisis of cut budgets and the closure of BBC Three as a broadcast channel, and says it shows "the future of British comedy looks a lot like its past". The IndependentLC “the future of British comedy looks a lot like its past”“The BBC is facing a comedy crisis, with budgets slashed and its main channel for new talent, BBC Three, taken off air.” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1Hilton says the show "is doing nothing original". He compares its student archetypes with those in Channel 4's It Gets Worse and Break Clause, which he says treat generational stereotypes more interestingly, and he likens Bill to Keith from Marion and Geoff. The IndependentLC “Which is to say that Bill’s Included is doing nothing original.”“both those shows are playing with generational stereotypes in a more interesting, comically fruitful way” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1Hilton says Brydon operates as a "comedic black hole", leaving the show unbalanced and its six episodes too short to develop the characters or a budding student romance. He concedes the writers can construct a joke, citing a supergluing prank, and calls it "perfectly adequate" as a vehicle for Brydon's schtick but "disposable", built for a middle-aged, middle-ground audience. The IndependentLC “Brydon operates as a comedic black hole, sucking all other narrative threads (and punchlines) into his sheer mass of charisma”“As a vehicle for Brydon’s schtick, Bill’s Included is perfectly adequate.” Read at The Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both are opinion reviews. The Guardian leads with praise for Brydon's character while faulting the writing. The Independent uses the show as a test of BBC comedy commissioning and finds it derivative.
- Emphasis
- Brydon's central performance, comparisons to Uncle Bryn and Keith, and thin supporting characters. The Independent adds BBC budget context and rival Channel 4 sitcoms.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither covers the show's viewing figures, broadcast schedule or the BBC's own account of the commission; only left-leaning outlets are in this set.
- Charged language
- “comedic black hole”“sublime”“Brydonicity”“disposable”
- For example
-
“Not a good sign for the future of British comedy” — The Independent
“The comic is sublime as a middle-aged landlord attempting to befriend student tenants.” — The Guardian
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Bill's Included is a BBC One sitcom starring Rob Brydon as Bill, a newly single older landlord with four student lodgers.
- Both reviewers say the show centres almost entirely on Brydon and that the student characters are thinly drawn.
- Both link Bill to Brydon's earlier characters, including Uncle Bryn in Gavin & Stacey.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Brydon's dominance of the show is a strength
- Left
- The Guardian: his "sublime performance" and "ineffable Brydonicity" are brilliant enough to excuse the show's weaknesses. The Independent: his dominance is "for worse" and leaves the show unbalanced.
-
Whether the show is original and what it says about British comedy
- Left
- The Independent: derivative and recycled, "not a good sign for the future of British comedy". The Guardian: a deliberately traditional sitcom and does not frame it as a verdict on the industry.
Rob Brydon person
As the lead, Brydon is treated by both reviewers as the show's centre: the Guardian celebrates the performance, while the Independent says his charisma crowds out everything else. Neither quotes him directly.
“the series is fiercely and unrelentingly focused on Rob Brydon” — The Guardian
“If you like Brydon – and given his ubiquity on British television, it’s clear that many viewers do – then that is no bad thing.” — The Independent
Bill's Included product
The show is described as a traditional, broad sitcom, sweet but thinly written; the makers and BBC are not quoted in these reviews.
“It’s all very sweet” — The Guardian
“it feels purpose-built to please a specific, middle-aged, middle-ground audience” — The Independent
Left2 articles
-
The IndependentLC · · Opinion
Bill’s Included review – Not a good sign for the future of British comedy
Critical Treats the sitcom as unoriginal and a worrying sign for BBC comedy, though conceding Brydon's appeal.

-
The GuardianLC · · Opinion
Bill’s Included review – Rob Brydon’s new character is as glorious as Gavin & Stacey’s Uncle Bryn
Mixed Enthusiastic about Brydon's performance and Bill as a character, while calling the storylines and supporting cast flimsy.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 20 Nov 22:00 First The IndependentLC Bill’s Included review – Not a good sign for the future of British comedy Opinion
- 20 Nov 22:00 +1m The GuardianLC Bill’s Included review – Rob Brydon’s new character is as glorious as Gavin & Stacey’s Uncle Bryn Opinion
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…