Birmingham woman avoids jail over seven years of harassing neighbours with rubbish
Sufina Aslam, 42, of Yardley, Birmingham, pleaded guilty to two counts of harassment and breaching a restraining order after throwing nappies and other waste into a neighbour's garden. A judge gave her a 12-month supervision order instead of jail.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Right · 2Sufina Aslam, a 42-year-old mother of seven from Yardley, Birmingham, was given a 12-month supervision order at Birmingham Magistrates' Court after a campaign against her neighbours that lasted about seven years. Daily MailR “The mother-of-seven pleaded guilty to two counts of harassment and one of breaching a restraining order, but avoided jail.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “A mum-of-seven has been handed a 12-month supervision order after a "seven-year torture campaign" against her neighbour.” Read at GB News ↗ Right · 1She pleaded guilty to two counts of harassment and one count of breaching a restraining order. GB NewsR “Although Aslam admitted two counts of harassment and one count of breaching a restraining order, she avoided jail.” Read at GB News ↗ Right · 2Video footage released this week, filmed earlier this year, shows her throwing dirty nappies, sanitary towels, crisp packets and food packaging into the garden next door, and tipping bags of rubbish into a garden already covered in litter. In other clips she is seen smirking over the fence while throwing pans of cooking oil. Daily MailR “Shocking footage released this week but taken earlier this year shows the mother repeatedly tipping bin bags full of rubbish into a garden already filled with litter.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “In another video, Aslam is seen smirking and peering over the fence as she hurls cooking pans full of oil into their garden.” Read at GB News ↗
Right · 1Prosecutor Fahad Gazge told the court that dirty nappies, sanitary towels and food were thrown over the fence, and that there was banging and shouting through the walls. Daily MailR “'Dirty nappies, sanitary towels and food were thrown over the garden fence. There was banging on the walls and shouting through the walls.'” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Right · 2The neighbours had to pay £4,000 to clear the waste and repair damage to their home, according to the Daily Mail; GB News describes the sum as cleaning costs. Daily MailR “Aslam's neighbours were left with no choice but to fork out £4,000 to clean up the mess and repair damage to their family home.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “were forced to pay £4,000 in cleaning costs to remove the waste from their back garden.” Read at GB News ↗ Right · 1In a victim impact statement, a 50-year-old neighbour said she could not sleep, her health was deteriorating and her children's education was affected, calling it "a constant mental torture for all of us". Daily MailR “'I can't sleep and my health is deteriorating. My children's education is affected. It's a constant mental torture for all of us. I panic when I hear her voice.'” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Right · 2Another neighbour said it had gone on for six or seven years at all hours of day and night, and that Aslam had stopped about six months ago; GB News identifies him as a 53-year-old man who was unsure why they were targeted. GB NewsR “Another of Aslam's neighbours, a 53-year-old man, said he was unsure why Aslam had targeted them.” Read at GB News ↗ Daily MailR “She's now stopped for about six months and doing nothing.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Right · 2District Judge Michelle Smith said an intense supervision order rather than custody was appropriate, but warned that any further offending could lead to a prison sentence. Aslam was also ordered to pay £70 to her neighbours. GB News quotes the judge as calling the offending "persistent". Daily MailR “District Judge Michelle Smith said an 'intense supervision court order rather than custody' was appropriate in this case but warned any more offending could see Aslam jailed.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “Ms Smith said the intense supervision court order rather than custody was "appropriate in this case"” Read at GB News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets present it as a 'neighbour from hell' story built around the CCTV footage, with the victims' hardship and the lenient sentence in the background.
- Emphasis
- The smirking footage, the items thrown, the 'torture' language from a victim and the £4,000 cost.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither outlet gives any explanation or account from Aslam or her representatives, or a reason for the dispute.
- Charged language
- “Neighbour from hell”“mental torture”“seven-year torture campaign”“brazenly smirking”
- For example
-
“This is the moment a mother-of-seven smirks as she brazenly hurls nappies, crisp packets and sanitary towels into the garden next door.” — Daily Mail
“Neighbour from hell hurls dirty nappies into homeowner's garden in seven-year 'torture' campaign” — GB News
What every side reports
- Sufina Aslam, 42, of Yardley, Birmingham, is a mother of seven.
- She pleaded guilty to two counts of harassment and one of breaching a restraining order.
- She received a 12-month supervision order rather than jail and was ordered to pay £70 to her neighbours.
- The neighbours paid £4,000 to clean up.
- District Judge Michelle Smith warned further offending could lead to custody.
Where accounts differ
-
What the £4,000 covered
- Right
- The Daily Mail says it covered cleaning up and repairing damage to the family home; GB News describes it as cleaning costs to remove waste from the back garden.
Sufina Aslam person
Aslam admitted the offences in court; the coverage carries no statement from her or her representatives.
“Although Aslam admitted two counts of harassment and one count of breaching a restraining order, she avoided jail.” — GB News
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Critical Leads with the footage of Aslam smirking as she throws waste, and quotes the victim's 'mental torture' statement.

-
GB NewsR ·
Neighbour from hell hurls dirty nappies into homeowner's garden in seven-year 'torture' campaign
Critical Calls her a 'neighbour from hell' and frames the case as a seven-year 'torture' campaign, with the same court quotes.

- 27 Oct 01:02 First Daily MailR Moment mother-of-seven hurls dirty nappies and sanitary towels into neighbour's garden in campaign of 'mental torture'
- 27 Oct 15:53 +14h 51m GB NewsR Neighbour from hell hurls dirty nappies into homeowner's garden in seven-year 'torture' campaign
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…