Bono says Ed Sheeran was wary of politics on U2's Ukraine war song
In a Rolling Stone UK interview, Bono said Ed Sheeran told U2 he did not want to "get into politics" while working on "Yours Eternally", a song about the war in Ukraine. The remarks come amid backlash over Sheeran's handling of Macklemore's exit from his US tour.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Bono, U2's frontman, said in a new Rolling Stone UK interview that Ed Sheeran was reluctant to get involved in politics when they worked together on the song "Yours Eternally". VarietyLC “Bono told Rolling Stone UK in a new interview that Sheeran expressed his resistance to U2 about doing such a politically-minded song.” Read at Variety ↗ Irish IndependentRC “Bono has revealed that Ed Sheeran was reluctant to get political when he collaborated with U2 on the song Yours Eternally earlier this year.” Read at Irish Independent ↗ Bono recalled Sheeran saying, "You're not going to get me into politics, are you?". Bono said he replied that the soldier who inspired the song loved Sheeran and that Sheeran had worked on it, and Sheeran answered: "Yeah, but I just want to keep my thing free." VarietyLC ““And I said, ‘This soldier who inspired us, he loved you Ed and you’ve worked on this song.’ [He responded], ‘Yeah, but I just want to keep my thing free.’”” Read at Variety ↗ Irish IndependentRC “Bono claimed that Sheeran responded: “Yeah, but I just want to keep my thing free.”” Read at Irish Independent ↗ "Yours Eternally" is on U2's "Days of Ash" EP, released in February. It features a Ukrainian musician, named as Taras Topolia by Variety and Taras Topalia by the Irish Independent. Its lyrics are written from the perspective of a Ukrainian soldier writing to friends at home during the war with Russia. VarietyLC “the lyrics take the perspective of a Ukrainian soldier writing to his friends back home amid the country’s ongoing war with Russia.” Read at Variety ↗ Irish IndependentRC “The song features Ukrainian singer Taras Topalia, and is written from the perspective of a Ukrainian soldier during the ongoing war with Russia.” Read at Irish Independent ↗
Bono was asked about the collaboration after the backlash Sheeran faced when Macklemore left his US tour. Variety says stadium owners such as Robert Kraft banned the rapper over "Free Palestine" speeches he made while opening at two MetLife Stadium concerts. The Irish Independent says Sheeran dropped Macklemore over those remarks. VarietyLC “The rapper exited Sheeran’s tour after stadium owners such as Robert Kraft banned him from performing due to the “Free Palestine” speeches” Read at Variety ↗ Irish IndependentRC “Sheeran’s apolitical image has been put under the spotlight in recent weeks after he dropped Macklemore from his US tour over the rapper’s “Free Palestine” remarks.” Read at Irish Independent ↗ Bono said he did not want to personalise the dispute or dwell on "Ed and Macklemore". He cited Brian Eno's comment that pop stars are like little fish in a large sea of huge forces, religion and politics. VarietyLC “I don’t want to dwell on Ed and Macklemore and that incident.” Read at Variety ↗ Irish IndependentRC “Brian Eno said today that pop stars are like little fish in a large sea of huge forces and religion and politics.” Read at Irish Independent ↗ Variety reports Bono saying U2 aligns more with Macklemore because the band has never shied away from politics. He said they are also happy to recognise that others do not want that kind of fight, and that people must be persuaded by reason, not forced. The Irish Independent quotes him saying the episode showed that "you can't be pushing people around". VarietyLC “Bono later added that U2 aligns more with Macklemore as the band has never been one to shy away from politics in their music and performances.” Read at Variety ↗ Irish IndependentRC “Bono said the situation showed him that “you can’t be pushing people around”.” Read at Irish Independent ↗
According to the Irish Independent, drummer Larry Mullen Jr said artists are entitled to choose whether to be involved and that it is not U2's job to criticise that. He said the band is "absolutely clear" in opposing billionaire promoters or venue owners influencing what artists say on stage, after Patriots owner Robert Kraft, who owns Gillette Stadium, personally called Sheeran to say Macklemore would not be allowed to perform there. Irish IndependentRC ““We are absolutely clear about promoters or billionaire owners, and the idea that they could have some influence on what you say or what you do on a stage,” Mullen said.” Read at Irish Independent ↗ Sheeran had posted an Instagram statement saying he does not use his professional platform for politics because his audience includes young people and children, and that he respects Macklemore's "strength of purpose". At his 19 September concert, his first since Macklemore's exit, he said Gaza was a "humanitarian issue" and he could not hide his feelings anymore. He also called the 7 October attack on Israel "horrific" and the situation in Gaza "catastrophic and unjustifiable, and disproportionate". VarietyLC ““There is a reason I do not use my professional platform for politics – my audience includes young people, often children, of all backgrounds.”““What is happening in Gaza is catastrophic and unjustifiable, and disproportionate,” Sheeran said.” Read at Variety ↗ The Irish Independent adds that Sheeran's other opening acts, including Aaron Rowe and Finneas, withdrew from the tour and that protesters gathered outside his first show without Macklemore. At Lincoln Financial Field he said he was "so sorry" for disappointing fans, and it says he was reading from a teleprompter. It reports that it contacted Sheeran's representatives for comment. Irish IndependentRC “His response led his other opening acts, including Irish singer Aaron Rowe and American producer Finneas, to withdraw from the tour.”“The Independent has contacted Ed Sheeran’s representatives for comment.” Read at Irish Independent ↗
Macklemore has announced a "Free Palestine" tour with shows in Dublin (26 October), Paris (29 October) and London (30 October), with proceeds going to charities aiding Palestinians in Gaza. Both outlets report the shows sold out. Bono is promoting U2's album "Carnaval de Luz", due 13 November. VarietyLC “Macklemore recently announced all three shows have sold out.”“Bono is currently touting U2’s upcoming album “Carnaval de Luz,” set to drop Nov. 13.” Read at Variety ↗ Irish IndependentRC “announced on Wednesday that the tour had sold out immediately.” Read at Irish Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Variety leads with Sheeran's reluctance, then spends most of the piece on the Macklemore controversy, Sheeran's statements and Macklemore's sold-out tour.
- Emphasis
- Sheeran's Instagram statement and his reversal on 19 September; Bono's view that U2 aligns more with Macklemore.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include Larry Mullen Jr's comments, the withdrawal of other opening acts, or the protests.
- Charged language
- “changed his tune”“ignited widespread backlash”
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The Irish Independent frames the story around Sheeran's 'apolitical image' being under scrutiny, adding bandmate Larry Mullen Jr's remarks and the fallout for his tour.
- Emphasis
- Mullen's criticism of billionaire owners, the withdrawal of other opening acts, protests, and Sheeran's apology and request for comment.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Bono's statement that U2 aligns more with Macklemore, or Sheeran's Instagram statement on keeping politics away from young audiences.
- Charged language
- “apolitical image”“billionaire owners”
- For example
-
“Sheeran’s apolitical image has been put under the spotlight in recent weeks” — Irish Independent
“We are absolutely clear about promoters or billionaire owners” — Irish Independent
What every side reports
- Bono told Rolling Stone UK that Sheeran said 'You're not going to get me into politics, are you?' while they made 'Yours Eternally'.
- The song is about a Ukrainian soldier and features a Ukrainian singer.
- Bono said he did not want to dwell on the Sheeran-Macklemore incident.
- Macklemore's own 'Free Palestine' tour has sold out.
Where accounts differ
-
Why Macklemore left Sheeran's tour
- Left
- Variety says stadium owners such as Robert Kraft banned him from performing over his 'Free Palestine' speeches.
- Right
- The Irish Independent says Sheeran dropped him over the remarks, and that Kraft personally phoned Sheeran to say Macklemore would not be allowed to perform at Gillette Stadium.
Ed Sheeran person
Sheeran says he avoids politics on his platform because his audience includes children, and favours diplomacy and open conversation. After the backlash he spoke out on Gaza at concerts. Bono says Sheeran wanted to 'keep my thing free' on the Ukraine song. The Irish Independent says it has asked his representatives for comment.
“I choose to use my fame and platform to be a place of safety and sanctuary, to maintain diplomacy and keep conversations open, not closed.” — Variety
“The Independent has contacted Ed Sheeran’s representatives for comment.” — Irish Independent
U2 organisation
Bono says U2 has never shied from politics but respects those who choose not to, and that people should be persuaded by reason. Mullen says artists may choose, and the band opposes billionaire owners influencing what artists say on stage.
“we’re also happy to recognise if there’s other people don’t want to get into that kind of fight.” — Variety
“it’s not our job to criticise that, no matter how we feel.” — Irish Independent
Left1 article
-
Neutral Entertainment report built on Bono's quotes, placing the Ukraine song anecdote within the Sheeran-Macklemore controversy.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Ed Sheeran didn’t want to ‘get into politics’ on U2 collab track, Bono says
Neutral Presents Bono's comments as a fresh angle on Sheeran's 'apolitical image', with extra comments from Mullen on venue owners.

- 1 Oct 14:44 First VarietyLC Ed Sheeran Told U2 He Didn’t Want to ‘Get Into Politics’ on Song About Ukraine’s War With Russia, Says Bono
- 2 Oct 05:30 +14h 45m Irish IndependentRC Ed Sheeran didn’t want to ‘get into politics’ on U2 collab track, Bono says
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.