Brawl at girls' softball game in Texas hospitalises two men; couple charged
A dispute among parents at a 12-year-olds' girls' softball game in Sugar Land, Texas, turned violent on Saturday. Two men were hospitalised and a married couple were arrested and charged with assault.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2A dispute among parents at a girls' softball game in Texas turned violent over the weekend, ending in hospitalisation and criminal charges. CBS NewsLC “Parents get violent at girls' softball game in Texas, ending in hospitalization, criminal charges” Read at CBS News ↗ BreitbartR “Life-threatening violence broke out at a 12-year-olds girls’ softball game over the weekend” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1Breitbart, citing ABC 13, says the game was at Imperial Park in Sugar Land, a Houston suburb, on Saturday. Kiarious Marshun Hall and his wife, Jazmine Hall, were there to watch their daughter play. BreitbartR “Kiarious Marshun Hall and his wife, Jazmine Hall, were attending their daughter’s game at Imperial Park in the Houston suburb of Sugar Land, Texas, on Saturday” Read at Breitbart ↗ Mixed · 2According to the Daily Mail as relayed by Breitbart, the row began when a parent from the opposing Timbergrove Thunder team complained to Kiarious Hall about his allegedly disruptive cheering before pitches. CBS News describes it as a sportsmanship dispute. BreitbartR “a parent from the opposing Timbergrove Thunder team approached Kiarious to complain about his allegedly disruptive cheering before pitches” Read at Breitbart ↗ CBS NewsLC “Parents get violent at girls' softball game in Texas” Read at CBS News ↗
Right · 1Breitbart says a viral video shows Kiarious Hall hitting one of the fathers on the head with a metal water bottle during the argument, knocking him unconscious. The unidentified man suffered a broken jaw, a fractured skull and brain bleeds, and remained at St. Luke's Hospital according to his attorney. BreitbartR “Kiarious, without warning, smashes a metal water bottle against the head of one of the fathers, instantly knocking him unconscious, the video shows.”“remains hospitalized at St. Luke’s Hospital, according to his attorney” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1Grandfather Gary Greaser said he tried to intervene to disarm Hall. A fight followed in which Greaser ended up on the ground and, Breitbart says, a woman apparently Jazmine Hall hit him. The Mail reported that Greaser suffered a broken hip and needed seven stitches on his chin. BreitbartR ““I took him, I wanted to disarm the guy, because he’s going to do it to somebody else.””““Greaser sustained a broken hip, and required seven stitches on his chin,” the Mail reported.” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1Bystanders pulled the couple off before Sugar Land police arrived. The Halls were booked into Fort Bend County Jail on charges of assault causing bodily injury, according to news outlets cited by Breitbart. BreitbartR “They have been booked into the Fort Bend County Jail on charges of assault causing bodily injury, according to news outlets.” Read at Breitbart ↗
Right · 1Jazmine Hall, an assistant principal at Lamar Junior High School in Rosenberg, resigned. Lamar Consolidated ISD said she voluntarily reported the incident to human resources and that it happened outside school and was not tied to any district event. BreitbartR “The incident occurred outside of school and was not associated with any Lamar CISD-sponsored event or activity.” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1Breitbart says the video prompted a racial debate on social media. It quotes one account that portrayed the Black couple as defending themselves against an angry white mob, and says other users pointed to court documents and the video as showing otherwise. The CBS item, as seen, does not mention race. BreitbartR “A racial component has erupted in the social media reactions to the fight”“Others responded by pointing out court documents and the video that show otherwise.” Read at Breitbart ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- CBS News presents it as a news video item about parents behaving violently at a youth game, framed around a sportsmanship dispute and its consequences (hospitalisation, charges).
- Emphasis
- Parental behaviour at a children's game, injuries and criminal charges.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The CBS item gives no names, no account of who struck first and no mention of the social media race debate.
- Charged language
- “Parents get violent”
- For example
-
“Parents get violent at girls' softball game in Texas, ending in hospitalization, criminal charges” — CBS News
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Breitbart leads with the video and the injuries, naming the couple and putting Kiarious Hall's bottle strike at the centre. It then covers the racial reaction online and the wife's resignation.
- Emphasis
- Severity of injuries, who is seen striking first, the grandfather's account, and the social media racial dispute.
- Leaves out or plays down
- It does not give the Halls' account of events. It relies on secondhand sources (ABC 13, Daily Mail) and an unnamed victim's attorney.
- Charged language
- “Life-threatening violence”“pummeling”“melee”
What every side reports
- Parents fought at a girls' softball game in Texas over the weekend.
- At least one man was hospitalised.
- Criminal charges followed against a husband and wife.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the incident had a racial dimension
- Left
- The CBS item as seen makes no mention of race.
- Right
- Breitbart reports a racial argument on social media, quoting a post that cast the Black couple as defending themselves against a white mob and noting others disputed it.
Left1 article
-
Parents get violent at girls' softball game in Texas, ending in hospitalization, criminal charges
Neutral Short video item framing the event as parents turning violent over a sportsmanship dispute, with hospitalisation and charges.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Critical Detailed account built on the video and secondary reports, focused on the Halls' violence and the injuries, and noting the online racial argument.
- 28 Oct 18:31 First BreitbartR WATCH: Violence Breaks Out at a 12-Year-Old Girls' Softball Game -- Father, Grandfather Hospitalized, Two Arrested
- 28 Oct 23:41 +5h 10m CBS NewsLC Parents get violent at girls' softball game in Texas, ending in hospitalization, criminal charges
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…