Skip to content
Bramble

Sport

Brewers beat Padres 3-2 in NLDS Game 1 after ball hits roof on Ty France fly

Milwaukee won Game 1 of the NL Division Series 3-2 on Saturday, Oct. 3. A ninth-inning fly ball by San Diego's Ty France hit the roof of American Family Field and was caught for an out.

2 outlets · 0L · 1C · 1R First reported Account updated
Image: Fox News
Image: Newsweek

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2The Milwaukee Brewers beat the San Diego Padres 3-2 in Game 1 of their best-of-five National League Division Series at American Family Field on Saturday, Oct. 3. Right · 1Fox News reports that the Padres took a 2-0 lead, helped by a Luis Campusano single in the second inning, and that Jackson Chourio's two-run homer in the third tied the game. Right · 1According to Fox News, the game stayed tied until William Contreras hit a solo home run off Adrian Morejon with two out in the bottom of the seventh inning, putting Milwaukee ahead.

Mixed · 2In the top of the ninth, Padres first baseman Ty France hit a fly ball that both sides' coverage says looked like a possible go-ahead home run. It struck part of the roof structure, which Fox calls a truss and Newsweek calls a rail high over left field, and came back into play. Mixed · 2Brewers left fielder Jackson Chourio caught the ball for an out. The umpires ruled that it hit the roof in fair territory, so it stayed live. Fox says the Padres challenged and the call stood. Centre · 1Padres manager Craig Stammen said the umpires had joked about this scenario at that day's pre-game meeting. He called it a bad break: "Looked like it was a possible home run; just didn't go our way."

Centre · 1Newsweek says it is impossible to know whether the ball would have cleared the fence. It had not reached its apex when it hit the rail. But Statcast data show a ball hit at a 49-degree launch angle would have been a home run in only one of the 30 MLB parks, Daikin Park in Houston. Mixed · 2Newsweek says the argument was not over whether the umpires applied the rule correctly, but over whether a rule that lets a roof take away a home run is fair. Fox calls the play one of the most bizarre, unlucky things in a major league game. Right · 1Fox reports that Jackson Merrill then lined out to end the game. Game 2 was scheduled for Sunday afternoon in Milwaukee.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left0 outlets

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre1 outlet

Framing
Newsweek treats the ending as a fairness debate about the roof ground rule and weighs whether the ball would really have been a home run.
Emphasis
Statcast launch-angle data, Padres manager Craig Stammen's quotes, and whether the rule is fair.
Leaves out or plays down
Gives little of the game's earlier scoring or the individual performances.
Charged language
“Miraculously for Milwaukee”“dissatisfying”
For example
“The end result is dissatisfying: an obscure ground rule, not the batter or the pitcher, decided the outcome of the first game of a playoff series.” — Newsweek

Right1 outlet

Framing
Fox News (OutKick) gives an upbeat full game recap, with the roof play as the bizarre highlight and Chourio's catch as clutch.
Emphasis
Pitching matchup, scoring sequence, Contreras' go-ahead homer, and the entertainment value of the game.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not question the home run call or cite data on whether the ball would have left the park.
Charged language
“sure-fire home run”“must-see TV”
For example
“Chourio made a clutch play to track it down and keep the tying run from scoring.” — Fox News