Brisbane chef's dismissal claim fails on lateness after pineapple-on-pizza refusal
Australia's Fair Work Commission dismissed Italian chef Davide Tamburella's challenge to his May sacking from a Brisbane restaurant because it was filed too late. The ruling recorded that Tamburella had refused to put pineapple on pizza, calling it an insult to Italian culture.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Australia's Fair Work Commission has dismissed a claim by Italian chef Davide Tamburella, who was sacked from La Costa Restaurant and Bar in Fortitude Valley, Brisbane, in May. Daily MailR “An Italian chef who worked at a Brisbane restaurant has had a workplace claim dismissed” Read at Daily Mail ↗ BBC NewsN “He lost his unfair dismissal claim on the grounds that the application had been filed too late, according to the ruling.” Read at BBC News ↗ Right · 1The Daily Mail says Tamburella was dismissed on 20 May, after a meeting two weeks earlier about "performance concerns". Daily MailR “Davide Tamburella was dismissed from La Costa Restaurant and Bar in Fortitude Valley on May 20.”“Two weeks earlier, Mr Tamburella had a meeting with his employer to discuss 'performance concerns'” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2One concern was Tamburella's refusal to put pineapple on pizza at a function, despite a direction from the restaurant's boss, Elliot Ingram. According to the commission's ruling, Tamburella said that as an Italian, they considered it an insult to their culture. Daily MailR “Mr Tamburella confirmed at the meeting he was aware that his boss, Elliot Ingram, had directed for the tropical fruit to be placed on the Italian dish.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ BBC NewsN “"he considers, as an Italian, that putting pineapple on a pizza is an insult to his culture"” Read at BBC News ↗
Mixed · 2The ruling noted it was the third time in four years that Tamburella had refused to use pineapple on pizzas, and that Tamburella had asked the boss to research how important it is to Italians not to put pineapple on pizza. BBC NewsN “It also noted that it was the third time Tamburella had refused to use the fruit on pizzas in the past four years.” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MailR “He also told his boss to research the cultural importance some Italians placed on not putting pineapple on pizza.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Other concerns included foul or inappropriate language, communication style and escalation of frustration during service. BBC NewsN “Other concerns were raised about Tamburella using foul language, his communication style and "escalation of frustration in the workplace".” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MailR “'Your acknowledged use of inappropriate language and escalation of the situation during service,' the reasons stated.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2The ruling also described an April incident in which Tamburella fractured bones in the right hand after striking a metal handrail. BBC NewsN “The ruling also detailed an incident at work in April this year where Tamburella fractured bones in his right hand when he struck a metal hand rail.” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MailR “an incident on April 24, when he fractured the fingers on his dominant hand after striking a metal handrail.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Centre · 1The BBC reports that Tamburella had hoped the restaurant would sponsor a permanent skilled-worker visa, and that the restaurant ended that process after the sacking, the tribunal heard. BBC NewsN “However after his sacking, the restaurant ended that process, the tribunal heard.” Read at BBC News ↗ Right · 1Commissioner Jennifer Hunt's decision was published on 3 November. The application was dismissed because it was lodged outside the statutory deadline. Daily MailR “a Fair Work Commission ruling published on November 3 by Commissioner Jennifer Hunt.”“his challenge was dismissed after Commissioner Hunt found that the application had been lodged outside the statutory deadline.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Right · 1Ingram, the restaurant's managing director, told the Daily Mail there was "more to this story than a pizza toping". Ingram said the refusal was one of several matters raised and that the injury, medical leave and workers' compensation claim played no part in the decision. Ingram added that the commission refused an extension to the filing deadline and did not finally determine the claim about the reasons for dismissal. Daily MailR “Elliot Ingram, managing director of La Costa Restaurant and Bar, told the Daily Mail there was 'more to this story than a pizza toping.'”“It did not finally determine his claim about the reasons for his dismissal,' he said.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Mixed · 2The BBC describes the restaurant as now closed. Both outlets say Tamburella now works at another Brisbane restaurant (the Daily Mail names it as Don Gino in West End, as head chef, citing LinkedIn). Both approached Tamburella for comment. BBC NewsN “Davide Tamburella was fired from the now-closed La Costa restaurant in May”“The BBC has approached Tamburella for comment.” Read at BBC News ↗ Daily MailR “Mr Tamburella has since become head chef at Don Gino in West End, according to his LinkedIn profile.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- BBC News runs it as a light human-interest story, with the headline saying the chef was fired over the pineapple refusal. It adds Queensland's pineapple-growing context and a check of the chef's new employer's menu.
- Emphasis
- The ruling's wording on culture, the third refusal in four years, the visa sponsorship ending, and the lateness of the claim.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not give Ingram's statement that the commission did not finally decide the reasons for dismissal, or that the injury played no part.
- Charged language
- “insult to his culture”
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The Daily Mail leads on the chef losing his "workplace bid" after refusing pineapple on a pizza he "branded" an insult to his culture, with extended input from the employer.
- Emphasis
- The chef's acknowledged refusals, other conduct concerns, and Ingram's statement that the case was about more than a topping and that the commission made no final finding on the reasons.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the visa sponsorship ending or that the restaurant has closed.
- Charged language
- “branded”“insult to his culture”
- For example
-
“Brisbane chef loses workplace bid after refusing to put pineapple on pizza he branded an 'insult to his culture'” — Daily Mail
“'more to this story than a pizza toping.'” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- Davide Tamburella, an Italian chef, was sacked from a Brisbane restaurant in May.
- The Fair Work Commission ruling recorded that Tamburella refused to put pineapple on pizza as an insult to Italian culture, for the third time in four years.
- The claim failed because it was filed after the deadline.
- Other concerns included language and escalation at work, and an April hand injury.
- Restaurant managing director Elliot Ingram said there was more to the story than a pizza topping.
Where accounts differ
-
Why Tamburella was dismissed
- Centre
- BBC says the chef was fired after management had a string of complaints, including the pineapple refusal, and headlines it as a firing over pineapple.
- Right
- Daily Mail reports Ingram saying the pineapple was one of several matters and that the injury and compensation claim played no part; the commission did not finally determine the reasons.
Davide Tamburella person
Tamburella told the employer that pineapple on pizza was offensive to Italians and that directions need not be followed when offensive to their culture. Both outlets approached Tamburella for comment and report no response.
“need not be followed when it is offensive to his culture” — BBC News
“The Daily Mail have approached him for comment.” — Daily Mail
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
Italian chef fired after refusing to put pineapple on pizza
Neutral Wry but even-handed report built on the commission ruling, with local pineapple context and mention of the visa consequences.
Right1 article
-
Mixed Light tabloid account that foregrounds the pineapple dispute but gives the employer space to say the dismissal involved other conduct and was not finally decided on its merits.
- 5 Nov 03:49 First Daily MailR Brisbane chef loses workplace bid after refusing to put pineapple on pizza he branded an 'insult to his culture'
- 5 Nov 07:56 +4h 7m BBC NewsN Italian chef fired after refusing to put pineapple on pizza
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…