British man Benjamin Braithwaite found dead in Sicily after attending queer pagan gathering
Benjamin Braithwaite, 35, from Leeds, was found dead on 13 September near Canicattini Bagni, Sicily, after joining a Radical Faeries gathering. The cause of death is unknown, and Italian investigators are keeping an open mind.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Benjamin Braithwaite, a 35-year-old British man, was found dead last month in the countryside near Canicattini Bagni, in Syracuse province, Sicily. Daily MailR “Benjamin Braithwaite, 35, was last month discovered dead in Piano Milo, Sicily, beside a length of rope.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “was found dead last month in a makeshift tent at a farmhouse near the village of Canicattini Bagni, Siracusa province.” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2The Daily Mail reports the body was found naked at around 3am on 13 September close to a farmhouse used by the community. It says a length of rope was nearby and initial examinations found marks around the neck. Metro says only that detectives found the body with various injuries. Daily MailR “Their body was found naked at around 3am on September 13, close to a farmhouse where members of the community had been staying.”“a rope was discovered nearby and initial medical examinations identified marks around their neck” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “Detectives discovered Mr Braithwaite” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2Braithwaite, reported to be non-binary and to use they/them pronouns, had joined a gathering of people calling themselves Radical Faeries. The Daily Mail says they went by names including River and Wasp and arrived several days before their death. Metro says the event was described by Eurofaeries as a radically inclusive gathering of queer people to celebrate the autumn equinox. Daily MailR “Braithwaite, who is said to have been non-binary and used the pronouns they/them, reportedly went by a number of names including River and Wasp.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “a radically inclusive gathering of queer people coming together to celebrate the autumn equinox” Read at Metro ↗
Mixed · 2The cause of death has not been established. A post-mortem has not given a definitive explanation, according to Italian reports cited by the Daily Mail, and toxicology and other tests are awaited. Speculation covers foul play, a sex game gone wrong and suicide. The Carabinieri are keeping an open mind and have declined to call the death a murder. Daily MailR “A post-mortem examination was carried out last month, although Italian reports say it has not yet provided a definitive explanation for how Braithwaite died.”“It is not yet known how they died but there are speculative theories over whether foul play or a sex game gone wrong are to blame” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “keeping an open mind in the case and have declined to call the death a murder.” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2Both outlets cite an anonymous former member who spoke to The Telegraph. He described the group as attracting vulnerable newcomers at a low ebb. He suggested Braithwaite could have died in a drug-fuelled choking sex game or through rape under the influence of drugs. The Daily Mail adds his claims of frequent drug-taking and sexual grooming, and says there is no suggestion the organisers knew of or supported such activities. Metro adds that he said the group had a malevolent undertone and that he had witnessed rituals close to the edge. Daily MailR “There is no suggestion the organisers of the group were aware of any such activities or that they support them.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “An anonymous whistleblower who was once part of the sect told the Telegraph the group attracted vulnerable people at”“adding he had witnessed several rituals which were” Read at Metro ↗ Right · 1The Daily Mail reports that group members believe Braithwaite died by suicide. It cites an encrypted chat message saying they 'took their own life' and claims of long-term depression. It also says local reports suggest investigators have moved away from suicide and are examining an erotic game gone wrong, while police have not said whether it was murder or an overdose. Daily MailR “Members of the organisation believe they died by suicide with one message in an encrypted chat room stating that 'Albion Faerie Wasp (also known by River) took their own life'”“But police have declined to comment on whether Braithwaite was murdered or died from an overdose.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Mixed · 2Police found drugs or a substance and ritual-style objects at the scene, including an image of a half-man, half-goat on a stone slab. The Daily Mail adds that authorities stress there is no evidence linking the death to an esoteric or occult ritual. It also describes a tent containing a bondage-style leather harness and rubber gas masks. Daily MailR “authorities have stressed that there is no evidence linking Braithwaite's death to an esoteric or occult ritual.”“Inside the tent a bondage-style leather harness hanging from the ceiling was found in addition to a shelf of rubber gas masks.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “alongside drugs and ritualistic objects on the scene, including a slab of a half man, half goat” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2Canicattini Bagni mayor Paolo Amenta said the people living in the area's communal farmhouses had always been kind and he hoped the investigation would clarify what happened. Metro reports that a local called Giuseppe, 38, found the case very strange but said the group kept to themselves. Daily MailR “We hope the investigations can clarify what happened,” Read at Daily Mail ↗ MetroLC “Giuseppe, 38, said the case was” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2Metro says Braithwaite was from Leeds and reportedly fell out with their mother, Angelique Wildbore, at around 18. It says she declined to comment. It also says the group is due to return to Featherstone Castle in Northumberland next month. The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office said it is supporting the family and is in touch with the local authorities. MetroLC “Mrs Wildbore has declined to comment on her son”“The group is set to return to Featherstone Castle in the northern English county next month.” Read at Metro ↗ Daily MailR “We are supporting the family of a British man who died in Italy and are in touch with the local authorities.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Metro runs a sensational angle on a 'faerie sex cult' where a tourist 'mysteriously dies', leaning on the whistleblower and adding local reactions.
- Emphasis
- The cult label, sex and drugs, the Northumberland castle event and the family estrangement.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not report the members' belief in suicide, the lack of a definitive post-mortem, or authorities' statement that no occult link has been found. It refers to Braithwaite as 'Mr' and 'his', not as non-binary.
- Charged language
- “faerie sex cult”“cult”“sect”
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The Daily Mail leads with the LGBTQ pagan gathering and allegations of dangerous sex games and drug-taking, with more detail on the investigation and competing theories.
- Emphasis
- Whistleblower allegations, the scene's contents, the suicide and foul-play theories, and the group's own website text.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Braithwaite's Leeds origin, the family estrangement or the Northumberland castle event.
- Charged language
- “dangerous sex games and drug-taking”“sexual grooming”“naked body”
- For example
-
“A non-binary British person whose naked body was found in Italy had attended an LGBTQ 'pagan gathering' where some members allegedly engaged in dangerous sex games and drug-taking.” — Daily Mail
“There is no suggestion the organisers of the group were aware of any such activities or that they support them.” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- Benjamin Braithwaite, 35, was found dead last month near Canicattini Bagni, Syracuse province, Sicily.
- They had attended a gathering of Radical Faeries, a queer pagan group.
- A former member told The Telegraph the group attracted vulnerable people.
- Italian authorities are keeping an open mind and have not called the death a murder.
- Mayor Paolo Amenta described the people in the area as peaceful.
Where accounts differ
-
Setting and nature of the death scene
- Left
- Metro says Braithwaite died at a 'Sicilian resort', was found in a makeshift tent and had various injuries.
- Right
- The Daily Mail says the body was found naked close to a farmhouse, beside a rope, with marks around the neck.
-
Whether the group is a 'cult'
- Left
- Metro's headline and text call it a 'faerie sex cult' and a 'sect'.
- Right
- The Daily Mail calls it an LGBTQ 'pagan gathering' and a New Age organisation, and says there is no suggestion organisers knew of dangerous activities.
-
Likely cause of death
- Left
- Metro relays the whistleblower's suggestion of rape under drugs or a choking sex game.
- Right
- The Daily Mail adds that members believe it was suicide, while local reports suggest investigators have moved away from that theory.
Benjamin Braithwaite person
The subject of the story, who cannot speak for themselves. Reports say they were non-binary, used they/them pronouns and had a history of depression, per members. The Daily Mail reports their family has been informed.
“Braithwaite, who is said to have been non-binary and used the pronouns they/them” — Daily Mail
“claims Braithwaite had been suffering with depression 'most of their life'” — Daily Mail
Left1 article
-
MetroLC ·
British man mysteriously dies in ‘faerie sex cult’ in Sicily
Alarmist Sensational 'sex cult' framing that stresses mystery and the whistleblower's claims, with local residents' calmer views included.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Mixed Detailed account that foregrounds allegations of drug-taking and sex games but includes the organisers' disclaimers, the suicide view and authorities' caution.

- 5 Oct 12:33 First Daily MailR Brit whose naked body was found in Italy had attended LGBTQ 'pagan gathering' where some members engage in 'dangerous sex games and drug-taking'
- 5 Oct 15:38 +3h 6m MetroLC British man mysteriously dies in ‘faerie sex cult’ in Sicily
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.