British father fined €3,000 over toddler son's fatal fall from Cyprus hotel window
Joshua Foster, 37, from Essex, was fined €3,000 (£2,500) by Paphos District Court after pleading guilty to causing his two-year-old son's death in a fall from a fourth-floor hotel window on 12 July.
1 / 8
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2A British man, Joshua Foster, 37, from Essex, was fined €3,000 (£2,500) at Paphos District Court on Friday 16 October for causing the death of his two-year-old son, and was not jailed. BBC NewsN “A father whose two-year-old boy fell to his death at a five-star hotel in Cyprus has been fined 3,000 euro (£2,500).” Read at BBC News ↗ GB NewsR “A British father has been spared jail after causing the death of his two-year-old son” Read at GB News ↗ Left · 1Foster had pleaded guilty to causing death through a reckless, rash or dangerous act; the sentence was read out by District Judge Froso Christodoulidou after a 25-minute hearing. The GuardianLC “Foster, an auditor, held back tears as his sentence was read out by the district judge Froso Christodoulidou.”“After the 25-minute hearing, Foster hugged his lawyer before embracing his parents.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2The boy fell nearly 40ft (about 12 metres) from the fourth floor of the five-star King Evelthon Beach Hotel and Resort in Chlorakas on 12 July, the first day of the family's holiday. BBC NewsN “The boy fell nearly 40ft (12.1m) from the fourth floor of the King Evelthon Beach Hotel and Resort on 12 July” Read at BBC News ↗ The GuardianLC “The boy fell from the fourth floor of the five-star King Evelthon Beach Hotel and Resort in Chlorakas on 12 July, the first day of the family’s holiday.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Mixed · 2The court had earlier heard that Foster, his father-in-law and the boy were walking to the lift at about 6pm when the child noticed a waterpark outside; Foster pushed the lift button and placed the child on the windowsill to see the view, and the boy fell before he could react. Evening StandardN “Foster pushed the elevator button, placed the child on the windowsill, the boy looked out, and the “inconceivable” happened before Foster had a chance to react, the court was told.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ The GuardianLC “At about 6pm, Foster, his father-in-law and son walked towards the lift” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2Foster thought the window was shut or protected by glass and had not realised that part of it was open, the court was told; he said in a voluntary police statement that his son "fell before he had a chance to grab him". Evening StandardN “It was previously heard that Foster thought there was protective glass and the window was shut when he “lost control” of his young son.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ The GuardianLC “In a voluntary statement to police, Foster said that when he placed his son on the windowsill, the boy “fell before he had a chance to grab him”.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Centre · 1Prosecutor Chryso Pergandi said police were alerted at about 6.40pm; the boy was taken to Paphos General Hospital, where he was pronounced dead despite resuscitation efforts. The window was 2.85 metres wide and 1.2 metres high. Evening StandardN “The boy was taken to Paphos General Hospital where, despite efforts to resuscitate him, he was pronounced dead.”“The court heard the window was 2.85 metres (9.3ft) wide and 1.2 metres (3.9ft) high.” Read at Evening Standard ↗
Left · 2The Guardian (carrying PA copy) and Metro report that a blood test after the incident put Foster's alcohol concentration at an estimated 124mg; the court heard alcohol was not a significant part of the case and his lawyer said there was no testimony that he was drunk. The GuardianLC “Alcohol consumption did not form a significant part of the case against Foster, and his lawyer said there was no testimony that he was drunk.” Read at The Guardian ↗ MetroLC “the alcohol concentration in his blood was an estimated 124mg.” Read at Metro ↗ Mixed · 2Foster's lawyer, Alexandros Alexandrou, said the moment would "haunt him for the rest of his life", that Foster had no previous convictions and that his remorse "is clear"; he said Foster was held in custody for eight days after the incident. Evening StandardN “Mr Alexandrou said the moment will “haunt him for the rest of his life”” Read at Evening Standard ↗ The GuardianLC “He said he was held in custody for eight days immediately after the incident” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 2Metro reported that Foster had faced a maximum four-year jail sentence; after sentencing he told reporters he was "looking forward to going home and being with my wife and daughter". MetroLC “had faced a maximum four-year jail sentence, officials previously said.” Read at Metro ↗ Daily MirrorL “I’m looking forward to going home and being with my wife and daughter.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left4 outlets
- Framing
- Fuller human-interest and court detail, with headlines stressing the fine, the 'plunged nearly 40ft' fall or that he was 'spared jail'.
- Emphasis
- Foster's emotional reaction, his post-sentence statement, the alcohol test, custody and his employment.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The Mirror omits the alcohol test and custody details that the Guardian and Metro include.
- Charged language
- “plunged nearly 40ft to death”“spared jail”
- For example
-
“Brit dad fined £2,500 after son, 2, plunged nearly 40ft to death from Cyprus hotel” — Daily Mirror
“British dad whose son, 2, fell to death from Cyprus hotel window is spared jail” — Metro
“Alcohol consumption did not form a significant part of the case against Foster” — The Guardian
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Straight court report: the Standard previewed the sentencing, and the BBC reported the fine in a short breaking item.
- Emphasis
- The fine, the guilty plea and the circumstances heard in court.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither mentions the alcohol test, custody or the maximum sentence.
- For example
-
“Dad fined after son, 2, died in Cyprus hotel fall” — BBC News
“will be sentenced at the same court on Friday” — Evening Standard
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Short report framing the outcome as a father 'spared jail'.
- Emphasis
- The sentence and the lawyer's description of a 'pleasant, joyous moment'.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the alcohol test, custody and the judge's name.
- Charged language
- “spared jail”
What every side reports
- Joshua Foster, 37, was fined €3,000 (£2,500) rather than jailed.
- He pleaded guilty to causing death through a reckless, rash or dangerous act.
- The boy, aged two, fell from the fourth floor of the King Evelthon Beach Hotel and Resort in Chlorakas on 12 July.
- Foster placed him on a windowsill to see a waterpark, believing the window was closed.
Where accounts differ
-
Height of the fall
- Left
- Mirror, Metro, Guardian say nearly 40ft (about 12m).
- Centre
- BBC says nearly 40ft (12.1m).
- Right
- GB News says 10 metres.
-
Joshua Foster was fined about £2,500 (3,000 euro) rather than jailed over his son's death.
Reported- Reports 5
- Daily Mirror, Metro, The Guardian, BBC News, GB News
-
Foster placed his son on the windowsill believing the window was closed or protected by glass.
Reported- Reports 6
- Daily Mirror, Metro, The Guardian, BBC News, Evening Standard, GB News
-
The two-year-old boy fell from a fourth-floor window of the King Evelthon Beach Hotel in Chlorakas on 12 July.
Reported- Reports 6
- Daily Mirror, Metro, The Guardian, BBC News, Evening Standard, GB News
Joshua Foster person
Foster pleaded guilty. His lawyer says he believed the window was shut or glazed and was in a happy moment, and that he is remorseful. After sentencing he thanked supporters.
“We’re allowed, even when we’re happy, to lose our concentration.” — Evening Standard
“Thank you for the support.” — Daily Mirror
Left4 articles
-
Brit dad fined £2,500 after son, 2, plunged nearly 40ft to death from Cyprus hotel
Sympathetic Reports the fine with vivid detail of the fall and Foster's emotion.
-
British father avoids jail for causing son's death in Cyprus hotel fall
Neutral Headline reports that the father avoided jail and was fined €3,000.
-
MetroLC ·
British dad whose son, 2, fell to death from Cyprus hotel window is spared jail
Sympathetic Detailed report including the alcohol test, maximum sentence and Foster's job.
-
The GuardianLC · · via PA
British man fined €3,000 for causing two-year-old son’s death in Cyprus
Neutral PA copy giving full court detail including alcohol and custody.
Centre3 articles
-
Neutral Pre-sentencing court report of the earlier hearing's evidence.
-
Dad fined after son, 2, died in Cyprus hotel fall
Neutral Short breaking-news report of the fine.
-
Right2 articles
-
GB NewsR ·
British dad spared jail after causing death of two-year-old son who fell from Cyprus hotel window
Neutral Brief report with a 'spared jail' angle.
-
- 16 Oct 06:54 First Evening StandardN British man to be sentenced for causing death of two-year-old son who fell from hotel window in Cyprus
- 16 Oct 10:29 +3h 35m Daily MirrorL Brit dad fined £2,500 after son, 2, plunged nearly 40ft to death from Cyprus hotel
- 16 Oct 10:33 +3h 39m GB NewsR British dad spared jail after causing death of two-year-old son who fell from Cyprus hotel window
- 16 Oct 10:37 +3h 43m BBC NewsN Dad fined after son, 2, died in Cyprus hotel fall
- 16 Oct 10:41 +3h 46m The IndependentLC British father avoids jail for causing son's death in Cyprus hotel fall
- 16 Oct 11:03 +4h 9m MetroLC British dad whose son, 2, fell to death from Cyprus hotel window is spared jail
- 16 Oct 11:05 +4h 11m The GuardianLC British man fined €3,000 for causing two-year-old son’s death in Cyprus via PA
- 16 Oct 12:20 +5h 26m Daily MailR UK father whose toddler fell to his death from Cyprus hotel window weeps as he walks free from court with €3,000 fine after judge says: 'You'll feel guilt for the rest of your life'
- 16 Oct 13:08 +6h 13m Evening StandardN Father should never have gone to court over death of son in Cyprus, says lawyer
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…