California woman sues DMV over recalled "RVRTSEA" pro-Palestine vanity plate
Iasmine Abdennabi has filed a federal First Amendment suit after California's DMV recalled her "RVRTSEA" vanity plate, a reference to "from the river to the sea." The DMV and a judge found the phrase could be read as degrading or inciting violence.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Right · 2Iasmine Abdennabi, a Bay Area woman from Contra Costa County, has sued the California Department of Motor Vehicles, saying its recall of her "RVRTSEA" vanity plate violates her First Amendment rights. New York PostR “Iasmine Abdennabi accused the DMV of violating her First Amendment rights after the department recalled her vanity plate featuring the letters “RVRTSEA,”” Read at New York Post ↗ JNSR “Iasmine Abdennabi, of Contra Costa County, Calif., is suing the head of the state’s Department of Motor Vehicles” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 1According to JNS, the complaint was filed on Monday in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, and the defendant is DMV director Steve Gordon. JNSR “which was filed on Monday in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California”“Steve Gordon, the DMV director and defendant in the lawsuit” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 1The plate refers to the phrase "From the river to the sea," which denotes the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, including Israel, the West Bank and Gaza. Pro-Palestine activists describe it as a call for freedom from oppression, while Jewish groups call it antisemitic for implying the elimination of Israel. New York PostR “Pro-Palestine activists say the slogan is simply a call for freedom from oppression, while Jewish groups have criticized it as antisemitic for implying the elimination of Israel.” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1The lawsuit says Abdennabi applied for the plate in December 2023 and received it in May 2024. It says the plate was meant to express support for human rights "for all persons living between the Jordan River and Mediterranean Sea." New York PostR “Abdennabi applied for the plate in December 2023, just two months after the deadly Hamas attack on Israel”“Abdennabi ultimately received the plates in May 2024” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 2The DMV ordered the plate canceled and returned in October 2025, after several drivers behind her car complained. One complainant wrote that it "supports terrorism and encourages violence," according to the San Francisco Chronicle as cited by the New York Post. New York PostR “they were recalled in October 2025 after multiple drivers in cars behind her vehicle filed complaints to the DMV.” Read at New York Post ↗ JNSR “The DMV ordered that it be canceled and returned in October 2025, according to the filing.” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 2Records showed the DMV appeared to agree the phrase could be "interpreted as racially or ethnically degrading and negative." An administrative law judge upheld the recall, finding the plate could refer to genocide or create a "risk of inciting violence." Gordon adopted that decision in August and it took effect in September, per JNS. New York PostR “The DMV appeared to agree that the phrase could be “interpreted as racially or ethnically degrading and negative,” records showed.” Read at New York Post ↗ JNSR “A judge upheld the recall and found that the plate could refer to genocide or create a “risk of inciting violence.””“adopted that decision in August, and it took effect in September.” Read at JNS ↗
Right · 1The judge's decision describes motorists who read the plate as a call for Israel's destruction. One reported feeling "fear, anxiety and a clear sense of being personally targeted." Abdennabi denies intending a threat or advocating violence. JNSR “One reported feeling “fear, anxiety and a clear sense of being personally targeted.””“Abdennabi denied intending a threat or advocating violence, according to the complaint.” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 1Abdennabi asks the court to order the DMV to reverse the recall and to rule that it violated her constitutional rights. She also asks for a declaration that, even if the plate carries the meaning the DMV attributes to it, it does not incite violence. JNSR “Abdennabi wants the court to order the DMV to reverse the recall so she can continue to use the license plate.”“even assuming the configuration bears the meaning attributed to it by the DMV,” it isn’t inciting violence.” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 1Her attorney, Michael Millen, told the Chronicle she has a high chance of success, citing similar past cases, and said the plates were still on her vehicle. Both the DMV and Abdennabi declined to comment to the Chronicle. New York PostR “Her attorney Michael Millen told the outlet that she has a high chance of succeeding, pointing to similar past cases.”“Both the DMV and Abdennabi declined comment to the Chronicle.” Read at New York Post ↗
Right · 1Jayne Zirkle, director of communications at the Lawfare Project, told JNS that free speech matters but so does the right of Jewish Americans to live without intimidation. She noted that Hamas, a U.S.-designated foreign terrorist organization, has used the slogan. JNSR ““Free speech matters. So does the right of Jewish Americans to live without intimidation,” she told JNS.”“Zirkle noted that Hamas, a U.S.-designated foreign terrorist organization, has used the slogan in its messaging.” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 1The DMV manual requires refusing plates that carry connotations offensive to good taste and decency, including those with "a negative connotation to a specific group." The New York Post also reports that Abdennabi is an in-house corporate lawyer and wellness-brand founder whose name appears on a Law For Palestine open letter. New York PostR “requests that “has a negative connotation to a specific group.””“Her name appears on an open letter by Law For Palestine” Read at New York Post ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets present the suit as a clash between a speech claim and complaints that the slogan is antisemitic or threatening. The Post's headline puts "antisemitic" in quotes and relays her claim of silencing; JNS leads with the Lawfare Project's quote on Jewish safety.
- Emphasis
- The Post stresses the complainants' reactions, Abdennabi's background and past pro-Palestine activism, and the DMV rulebook. JNS stresses the judge's finding of a risk of inciting violence, the complaint's details and Hamas's use of the slogan.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither outlet quotes Abdennabi or the DMV directly, since both declined comment. Neither gives a pro-Palestine advocacy group's response to the suit.
- Charged language
- “antisemitic”“anti-Israel slogan”“controversial pro-Palestine slogan”
- For example
-
“California woman sues after DMV yanks ‘antisemitic’ vanity plate — claims pro-Palestine views were silenced” — New York Post
“a reference to the anti-Israel slogan “from the river to the sea.”” — JNS
What every side reports
- Iasmine Abdennabi sued over the DMV's recall of her "RVRTSEA" plate, citing the First Amendment.
- She received the plate in May 2024 and the DMV recalled it in October 2025.
- An administrative law judge upheld the recall.
Where accounts differ
-
Meaning and harm of the slogan
- Right
- The New York Post notes pro-Palestine activists call the slogan a call for freedom while Jewish groups call it antisemitic. JNS calls it an "anti-Israel slogan" and quotes the Lawfare Project on public-safety implications.
California Department of Motor Vehicles organisation
The DMV recalled the plate after complaints. Records show it appeared to agree the phrase could be read as degrading, and its director adopted the judge's ruling. It declined comment to the Chronicle.
“The DMV appeared to agree that the phrase could be “interpreted as racially or ethnically degrading and negative,” records showed.” — New York Post
“A judge upheld the recall and found that the plate could refer to genocide or create a “risk of inciting violence.”” — JNS
The Lawfare Project organisation
The Lawfare Project's Jayne Zirkle says free speech matters but so do Jewish Americans' safety and protection from intimidation. She points to Hamas's use of the slogan.
““The Jewish community has the same right to safety and equal protection under the law as every other community,”” — JNS
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Mixed Reports the suit with a scare-quoted "antisemitic" headline, complainants' reactions and the plaintiff's pro-Palestine background, and includes her attorney's optimism.
-
JNSR ·
California woman sues DMV, wants ‘RVRTSEA’ license plate back
Critical Treats the slogan as anti-Israel and leads with the Lawfare Project's safety message, alongside the judge's findings and the complaint's requests.
- 28 Oct 19:19 First New York PostR California woman sues after DMV yanks ‘antisemitic’ vanity plate — claims pro-Palestine views were silenced
- 28 Oct 20:26 +1h 7m JNSR California woman sues DMV, wants ‘RVRTSEA’ license plate back
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…