Camas High runner moves from boys to girls team; teammates walk off race in protest
A Camas High School (Washington) cross country runner who began the season on the boys team switched to the girls team in September, and on Oct. 13 about a dozen girls walked off a race in protest. The school says it follows state law and WIAA rules; coverage so far comes only from right-leaning outlets.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Right · 1A Camas High School cross country runner in Washington state who began the season on the boys team switched to the girls team in September, drawing national attention to the debate over transgender athletes in sport. Fox NewsR “he started the year on the boys team — with which he finished 76th in a JV race — then switched to the girls team last month.”“A Camas High cross country runner switched from the boys team to the girls team midseason, sparking national debate over transgender athletes in sports.” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Fox News reports the runner finished 76th in a boys' junior varsity race at the Ultimook meet in Oregon on Sept. 5 and was competing in the girls' race at a Camas meet involving Skyview by Sept. 15; it also reports the runner won the girls' varsity race on Sept. 29. Fox NewsR “On Sept. 5, the runner finished 76th in a boys’ junior varsity race at the Ultimook meet in Oregon.”“By Sept. 15, the runner was competing in the girls’ race at a Camas meet involving Skyview.” Read at Fox News ↗ Fox NewsR “The male runner finished first in the girls' varsity race on Sept. 29 after finishing 76th in the boys' junior varsity race on Sept. 5.” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1On Saturday, Oct. 10, at the Nike Hole in the Wall invitational in Arlington, the runner placed 39th of 135 in the Women's Elite 5K in 18:36.8, according to a Fox News columnist, who calculated that the time would have been last of 159 in the men's race by about 30 seconds; the columnist also says the runner has finished second at another invitational. Fox NewsR “He finished 39th in a field of 135 in Saturday's race with a time of 18:36.8.”“had he run in the Men's Elite 5K, he would have placed last out of 159 runners by a good 30 seconds.” Read at Fox News ↗
Right · 2On Tuesday, Oct. 13, at a Camas–Battle Ground meet, about a dozen girls, including Camas runner Holly Burns, walked a few meters past the start and then left the course instead of racing; the runner in question ran. Fox NewsR “Holly Burns and about a dozen other girls walked away from a cross-country race in Washington on Tuesday.”“When the race began, half of the girls competing, and the male athlete, took off running.” Read at Fox News ↗ BreitbartR “About a dozen high school girls calmly walked out of a cross-country race rather than compete with a transgender runner in Washington State on Tuesday.” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1Holly Burns's parents, Kevin and Sarah, told OutKick (Fox News) they supported her decision after teammates discussed acting together, said the runner should compete with boys, and plan a more organised protest; they said security challenged their protest signs and that they could not say yet what sitting out would cost their daughter. Fox NewsR “The more I heard about her friends wanting to do something, the more I heard about her team wanting to do something, we definitely were in support of that,”“So we made a few contacts and we might go forward with that and have a more organized protest the next time,”“They said that we’re not allowed to hold up signs at this event today,” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Skyview High students Charlie Garret (spelled Garrett in an earlier Fox piece) and Sierra Retzlaff, who wore body paint reading "keep women in women's sports," also protested and appeared on Fox & Friends, saying the runner is taking a spot from girls; Fox reports Retzlaff's father was removed from the event and the athletic director reportedly called the signs inappropriate. Fox NewsR “"He’s taking that spot. I don’t think that that’s right or fair," Retzlaff said during an appearance on Fox News' "Fox & Friends."”“Retzlaff's parents brought signs supporting their daughter, but her father was removed from the event .” Read at Fox News ↗ Fox NewsR “Both wore body paint saying "Keep women in women's sports" that mid-September day” Read at Fox News ↗
Right · 2Camas School District says it follows Washington law and Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA) eligibility rules, under which such a switch is permitted; Breitbart says the state has had its rules for transgender athletes in place since 2007. Fox NewsR “Camas School District has said it follows Washington law and Washington Interscholastic Activities Association eligibility rules.” Read at Fox News ↗ Fox NewsR “such a switch is permitted under the rules of the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA)” Read at Fox News ↗ BreitbartR “The school said it follows Washington State’s education rules for transgender athletes, in place since 2007.” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1Opinion among parents at the Arlington meet was divided: most who spoke to the Fox columnist, many anonymously, opposed boys competing against girls, while a few urged empathy and said high school sports is about building confidence. What prompted the switch remains unclear, and no Camas coach would talk to the columnist. Fox NewsR “What prompted the Camas runner to switch from the boys to the girls team remains unclear.”“People can identify however they want. High school sports isn't about winning, it's about student athletes building confidence.” Read at Fox News ↗ Right · 1Washington voters will decide Initiative 638 on Nov. 3; it would bar students defined as biologically male from certain female-only interscholastic competitions and require verification of biological sex from a healthcare provider. It would take effect 30 days after the election, after the Nov. 7 state cross country championships. Fox NewsR “It would require students seeking to enter those competitions to provide verification of biological sex from a healthcare provider.” Read at Fox News ↗ Fox NewsR “Washington's state cross-country championships are scheduled for Nov. 7, and the measure would go into effect 30 days after the election.” Read at Fox News ↗
Right · 1Fox News places the dispute within a wider conflict: President Trump's Feb. 5, 2025 executive order on women's sports, a federal investigation opened in April 2025 into Washington's Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction, and State Superintendent Chris Reykdal's position that the state has allowed participation consistent with gender identity since 2007. A separate wrestling case has reached the U.S. Supreme Court, where the WIAA opposed emergency relief and no ruling had been issued. Fox NewsR “Federal officials opened an investigation into Washington’s Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction in April 2025.”“The Supreme Court’s docket showed the responses filed Tuesday and no ruling on the application.” Read at Fox News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both Fox News (OutKick) and Breitbart cast the story as girls and parents standing up against a male athlete in girls' competition, using the walk-off as the lead and quoting protesters and parents sympathetically.
- Emphasis
- Protesters' and parents' voices, the viral walk-off, the runner's earlier boys' JV result versus later girls' win, Initiative 638, and links to federal and Supreme Court disputes.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No on-record comment from the runner, the runner's family, Camas officials or WIAA beyond a standing policy statement; supportive or neutral views appear only as a few anonymous parent remarks in one piece. The runner's reasons are described as unclear. No left or centre outlet has covered it.
- Charged language
- “male athlete”“biological male”“boy”“Women's spaces will be erased”“plaguing Washington state”
- For example
-
“igniting widespread awareness for one of the trans athlete incidents currently plaguing Washington state.” — Fox News
“a boy to switch from the boys’ cross-country team to the girls’ team right in the middle of the season.” — Breitbart
“He’s taking that spot. I don’t think that that’s right or fair,” — Fox News
What every side reports
- The runner began the season on the boys team (76th in a JV race) and later raced for the Camas girls team.
- About a dozen girls walked off the course at a race on Tuesday, Oct. 13.
- Camas School District says it follows Washington law and WIAA eligibility rules.
- Initiative 638 goes to Washington voters on Nov. 3.
Where accounts differ
-
Which race the runner won first
- Right
- Breitbart, citing Fox, says the runner won in the first girls' race; Fox's own pieces say the runner was racing girls by Sept. 15 and won the girls' varsity race on Sept. 29, and a Fox columnist says the runner won a varsity meet and was second at another invitational.
-
Timing and place of the Skyview students' walk-off
- Right
- A Fox columnist places Garrett and Retzlaff's start-line walk-off in mid-September; a later Fox piece describes them among girls who walked off on Tuesday, though they attend Skyview, not Camas.
Camas High School organisation
The district says it follows Washington law and WIAA eligibility rules; Fox says Camas coaches declined to talk and OutKick sought comment.
“Camas School District has said it follows Washington law and Washington Interscholastic Activities Association eligibility rules.” — Fox News
“No Camas coach would talk” — Fox News
Transgender athletes in sport topic
Coverage presents the issue as contested: protesting girls and most quoted parents call it unfair to girls, while a few parents urge empathy; state officials defend current inclusion rules.
“Most, however, were like Kevin Ess” — Fox News
“State Superintendent Chris Reykdal defended Washington’s protections.” — Fox News
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right4 articles
-
A cross country runner switched to the girls team midseason, parents voice their disapproval at meet
Critical First-person OutKick column from an Arlington meet, collecting mostly opposed parents' views while noting a few sympathetic ones.

-
Sympathetic Interview with the Burns family presenting the walk-off as principled protest against unfair treatment of girls.

-
WATCH: High School Girls Walk Out of Track Meet in Protest of Trans Runner
Critical Short Breitbart item relaying Fox's reporting, describing a calm girls' protest against the school's decision.

-
Sympathetic Fox & Friends-linked piece giving Skyview protesters' view, praising the Camas girls as brave.

- 12 Oct 21:42 First Fox NewsR A cross country runner switched to the girls team midseason, parents voice their disapproval at meet
- 14 Oct 11:33 +37h 51m Fox NewsR Washington girls walk off cross country meet in protest of male athlete, parents reveal how it came to this
- 14 Oct 17:12 +43h 30m BreitbartR WATCH: High School Girls Walk Out of Track Meet in Protest of Trans Runner
- 14 Oct 18:13 +44h 31m Fox NewsR Washington HS girls blast male athlete participating in track meet: 'Don't think that that's right or fair'
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…