Cancer survivor Imogen Brooks fitted with bespoke artificial tongue in reported NHS first
Dr Imogen Brooks, 30, who lost most of her tongue to cancer surgery, has been fitted with a custom prosthetic tongue made by a Guy's and St Thomas' team. It is believed to be the first of its kind made on the NHS.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Evening Standard.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Dr Imogen Brooks, 30, from Newham in east London, has been fitted with a bespoke artificial tongue made by a team at Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust, in what is reported as an NHS first. Daily MirrorL “A cancer survivor is the first to be fitted with a bespoke artificial tongue by the NHS .” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “A cancer survivor was made an artificial tongue following a major surgery in what is believed to be a first for the NHS.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2The Standard and the Express attribute Brooks's account to interviews with the Press Association, and describe her as an assistant medical writer. Evening StandardN “She told the Press Association:” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily ExpressR “an assistant medical writer from Newham in east London” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2Brooks was diagnosed with squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue at 26, after going to her GP fearing she was "overreacting" over very mild symptoms. Daily MirrorL “Her symptoms were very mild and she feared she was "overreacting" when she went to her GP to check her tongue” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “when she was just 26” Read at Daily Express ↗
Mixed · 2Outlets describe the cancer differently: the Mirror calls squamous cell carcinoma "a form of skin cancer", while the Standard and the Express call it "the most common type of head and neck cancer". Daily MirrorL “was diagnosed with a form of skin cancer called squamous cell carcinoma on her tongue” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Evening StandardN “a squamous cell carcinoma, the most common type of head and neck cancer” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Mixed · 2Surgery three years ago removed most of her tongue; her speech after reconstruction was good, but later radiotherapy shrank the tissue. Daily MirrorL “while her speech after reconstruction was good, subsequent radiotherapy then shrank the tissue” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “She had surgery three years ago that involved removing most of her tongue” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2She used speech assistance technology on phone calls, but said people she met in person would look at her "in fear", smile without responding, or guess what she had said. The Standard and the Express add that this caused problems at medical appointments and at work. Evening StandardN “Dr Brooks said this would cause issues with incorrect information, impacting her medical appointments and causing problems in the workplace.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily ExpressR “impacting her medical appointments and causing problems at work.” Read at Daily Express ↗
Mixed · 2After researching prosthetic tongues, she asked her clinicians whether she would be a good candidate. She said eight people were in the room at her next appointment and "everyone was willing to try". Daily ExpressR ““At my next appointment there were eight people in the room – everyone was willing to try,” she added.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Daily MirrorL “After doing research on prosthetic tongues, she asked her clinicians at Guy's and St Thomas' if she would be a good candidate.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Mixed · 2The Standard and the Express report that speech and language therapist Carolyn Doughty assembled a multi-disciplinary team from restorative dentistry. After months of research and scans, the team made two trial tongues before the final version, which Brooks received last year. Evening StandardN “They created two trial tongues after months of research and scanning before refining the final version.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily ExpressR “After months of research and scans, the team created two trial tongues before refining the final version, which she got last year.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2The final prosthetic is a U-shaped cobalt chrome frame that clips onto her bottom teeth, with a fixed silicone tongue tailored to her and shaped to allow the maximum number of sounds. Daily MirrorL “The final version is a U-shaped frame made of cobalt chrome which clips onto Dr Brooks' bottom teeth, with a fixed silicone tongue that was tailored to her.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “We based the design on a shape which would allow Imogen to make the maximum number of sounds.” Read at Daily Express ↗
Mixed · 2Michael Brown, a dental technician at Guy's Hospital, said the team had never made anything like it, and that finding a working shape took a lot of trial and error as she took designs home and returned with notes. Daily MirrorL “We'd never made something like this before, but our team loves a challenge.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “Then she would take home a design, try it out and come back to us with lots of notes.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2Brooks said it took about two weeks to get used to the device, though her speech improved after three days. She said it has made a "massive difference", with people more willing to listen and ask her to repeat herself, and that speaking is less tiring and more fluid. Daily ExpressR “It took a couple of weeks for Dr Brooks to get used to the new tongue, though she noticed improvements in her speech after just three days.” Read at Daily Express ↗ Daily MirrorL “I don't have to think as much about what I'm saying, so it means that my speech is much more fluid and it's much less tiring for me to speak.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Mixed · 2She said she can now hold proper conversations with her grandmother, who is hard of hearing and who told her she needed hand gestures less. Daily MirrorL “She told how she is now able to have proper conversations with her grandmother who is hard of hearing.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “she said this was the first time that I didn’t need hand gestures as much because she was able to follow me a lot better” Read at Daily Express ↗
Centre · 1Brooks said that even immediately after surgery she told her speech therapist she wanted to "fight for every single bit of intelligibility that is possible". Evening StandardN “I want to fight for every single bit of intelligibility that is possible” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Mixed · 2There is no sign of the cancer returning, and Brooks has passed an oral exam for her doctorate in skin disease therapies at King's College London. She hopes her case will inspire other medical professionals to collaborate with patients. Daily MirrorL “There has been no sign of Dr Brooks’ cancer returning and her new tongue has helped her pass an oral exam for her doctorate in skin disease therapies at King's College London.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily ExpressR “I hope this inspires other medical professionals to also collaborate with patients” Read at Daily Express ↗ Mixed · 2The Standard and the Express say Doughty, who has presented the findings at UK conferences, believes this is the first prosthetic of its kind made on the NHS; the claim rests on her belief, not a formal check. Evening StandardN “After presenting the findings at conferences in the UK, Ms Doughty believes this is the first time a prosthetic of this kind has been made on the NHS.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily ExpressR “Ms Doughty believes this is the first time a prosthetic of this kind has been made on the NHS.” Read at Daily Express ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Daily Mirror tells it as a human-interest story of a doctor who lost her tongue to cancer and built a replacement with colleagues, stating the NHS first as fact.
- Emphasis
- Brooks's own initiative, the 'Avengers' quote, her struggle to be understood, and her recovery and doctorate.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not name speech therapist Carolyn Doughty, the two trial prototypes, or the qualified wording of the 'first' claim.
- Charged language
- “in fear”
- For example
-
“A cancer survivor is the first to be fitted with a bespoke artificial tongue by the NHS .” — Daily Mirror
“the request "was like assembling the Avengers"” — Daily Mirror
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Evening Standard runs the Press Association-sourced story as a hedged human-interest piece: 'what is thought to be the first', with the first claim attributed to therapist Carolyn Doughty.
- Emphasis
- Brooks's own quotes, the Avengers remark, the team's process and her grandmother anecdote, plus the physical benefits to speech.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Offers no independent check of the 'first' claim, which it attributes to Doughty's belief.
- Charged language
- “in fear”
- For example
-
“what is thought to be the first bespoke artificial tongue on the NHS” — Evening Standard
“Ms Doughty believes this is the first time a prosthetic of this kind has been made on the NHS.” — Evening Standard
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Daily Express reports the Press Association-sourced story as an 'NHS first', with the claim hedged and attributed to a clinician.
- Emphasis
- The clinical process, including Doughty's role, months of research and scans, two trial tongues, and effects on work and medical appointments.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits the 'Avengers' quote.
- Charged language
- “NHS first”
- For example
-
“in what is believed to be a first for the NHS” — Daily Express
“the team created two trial tongues before refining the final version” — Daily Express
What every side reports
- Dr Imogen Brooks, 30, from Newham, east London, was diagnosed with squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue at 26.
- Most of her tongue was removed in surgery three years ago; radiotherapy later shrank the reconstructed tissue.
- Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust made a U-shaped cobalt chrome frame with a fixed silicone tongue that clips onto her bottom teeth.
- She says it has made a 'massive difference' to her speech and daily life, and there is no sign of the cancer returning.
Where accounts differ
-
How firmly the 'NHS first' is stated
- Left
- The Mirror says in its own voice that she is 'the first to be fitted' with such a tongue on the NHS.
- Right
- The Express says it is 'believed to be' a first, resting on therapist Carolyn Doughty's belief after presenting at conferences.
-
How the cancer is described
- Left
- The Mirror calls squamous cell carcinoma 'a form of skin cancer'.
- Right
- The Express calls it 'the most common type of head and neck cancer'.
-
Brooks is the first person to be fitted with a bespoke artificial tongue on the NHS.
Reported- Supports 1
- Daily Mirror
- Reports 2
- Evening Standard, Daily Express
-
The prosthetic tongue has markedly improved Brooks's speech and how well others understand her.
Supported- Supports 3
- Daily Mirror, Evening Standard, Daily Express
-
Squamous cell carcinoma is a form of skin cancer.
Mixed- Supports 1
- Daily Mirror
- Disputes 1
- Daily Express
- Earlier 1
- Evening Standard
Imogen Brooks person
Says the prosthetic has transformed her communication and made people more willing to listen. She hopes it inspires medical professionals to collaborate with patients on quality of life.
“What I really notice is how much more willing people are to listen to me” — Daily Mirror
“I hope this inspires other medical professionals to also collaborate with patients” — Daily Express
NHS England organisation
The NHS, via a Guy's and St Thomas' team, is credited with making the prosthetic. Staff describe the project as new to them, and a therapist believes it is the first of its kind on the NHS.
“Ms Doughty believes this is the first time a prosthetic of this kind has been made on the NHS.” — Daily Express
“A team of experts from Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust created the prosthetic” — Daily Mirror
Left1 article
-
Cancer survivor is first to get new artificial tongue on NHS
Sympathetic Uplifting personal story that states the NHS first as fact and centres Brooks's own voice and drive.

Centre1 article
-
Cancer survivor receives artificial tongue in NHS first
Sympathetic Hedged, quote-heavy PA-based feature on Brooks's recovery, crediting Doughty and Brown and attributing the 'first' to Doughty's belief.

Right1 article
-
Cancer survivor given artificial tongue in 'NHS first'
Sympathetic Press Association-based account that hedges the 'first' claim and gives more detail on the clinical team and process.

- 8 Oct 00:01 First Evening StandardN Cancer survivor receives artificial tongue in NHS first
- 8 Oct 00:01 +1m Daily MirrorL Cancer survivor is first to get new artificial tongue on NHS
- 8 Oct 00:02 +1m Daily ExpressR Cancer survivor given artificial tongue in 'NHS first'
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.