Sabia retracts false claim that Talarico received mental health treatment
Conservative journalist Carmine Sabia apologised for sharing an unverified report that Texas Democratic Senate nominee James Talarico was treated at an Ohio mental health facility. Breitbart's Alex Marlow doubted the claim but still called Talarico "completely nuts".
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 1Conservative journalist Carmine Sabia apologised on Tuesday 13 October for promoting a false report about James Talarico, the Democratic Senate nominee in Texas. Raw StoryL “Conservative journalist Carmine Sabia issued an apology Tuesday for promoting a false report about Democratic Senate nominee James Talarico” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Over the weekend, an allegation spread among conservative figures that Talarico, who is running against Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, had been treated at a mental health facility in Ohio. Raw StoryL “MAGA world went into a frenzy over an allegation that Talarico, who’s running against Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, had been treated at a mental health facility in Ohio.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Talarico's campaign called the claim a lie and said he was home in Austin recovering from the flu. Raw Story reports the story fell apart after analysts spotted details that made its timeline impossible. Raw StoryL “Talarico’s campaign called the claim a lie, saying he was home in Austin recovering from the flu. The story quickly fell apart after analysts spotted details that made its timeline impossible.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 1In a social media statement, Sabia said he relied on the reporting available at the time, got it wrong and retracted it, adding that he supports Paxton but that "the truth matters more than winning on a lie". He also posted a custom-made graphic repeating the retraction. Raw StoryL ““I relied on the reporting available then, but I got it wrong and retract it. I support Ken Paxton, but the truth matters more than winning on a lie.”” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Critics mocked the apology. The Bulwark's Will Sommer wrote that the story was so discredited that pundits were making "personalized retraction graphics". Commentator Adam Cochran and author John A. Daly speculated that Sabia had received a call from lawyers; this is speculation and Sabia has not said it. Raw StoryL “Others, such as commentator Adam Cochran, speculated that Sabia “got a call from the lawyers,” a suspicion shared by author John A. Daly” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1Eric Spracklen, a political commentator who identifies with the MAGA movement, called the episode "embarrassing and discrediting for everyone involved". Raw StoryL ““This is so embarrassing and discrediting for everyone involved it’s actually insane,” Spracklen wrote” Read at Raw Story ↗
Right · 1On his radio show on Wednesday, Breitbart Editor-in-Chief Alex Marlow said that "very credible conservative influencers" had suggested Talarico was treated at the Lindner Center of Hope near Cincinnati, but that it was "probably not" true. BreitbartR “Do you believe that James Talarico was in a mental institution for the last couple of weeks? My answer, in all honesty, is probably not.” Read at Breitbart ↗ Right · 1Marlow nonetheless said Talarico is "completely nuts" and claimed there was "tons and tons of evidence" for this, without presenting any in the segment. Breitbart's headline says Talarico "was always mentally unstable". BreitbartR “because you are completely nuts and we have tons and tons of evidence that you are completely nuts” Read at Breitbart ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Treats the apology as a sign of how discredited the story became, and relays critics suspecting legal pressure.
- Emphasis
- Mockery from Bulwark writers and even a MAGA-aligned commentator; the campaign's denial and the impossible timeline.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No comment from Sabia on the legal speculation; no Talarico statement beyond the campaign's denial.
- Charged language
- “MAGA pundit’s curious Talarico apology”“MAGA world went into a frenzy”
- For example
-
“The Talarico nervous breakdown story has become so discredited, conservative pundits are making personalized retraction graphics” — Raw Story
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Opinion radio segment that doubts the hospital story but uses it to attack Talarico's mental fitness.
- Emphasis
- Talarico's supposed instability and the implausibility of seeking treatment in Ohio before the election.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Sabia's apology, the campaign's flu explanation or the timeline problems.
- Charged language
- “Talafreako”“completely nuts”
- For example
-
“Marlow: Talafreako Was Always Mentally Unstable” — Breitbart
What every side reports
- A report circulated among conservative figures that Talarico had been treated at a mental health facility in Ohio.
- Neither outlet presents the claim as established fact; Raw Story calls it false and Marlow says it is probably not true.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Talarico has mental health problems
- Left
- Raw Story treats the treatment report as false and quotes the campaign saying he had the flu.
- Right
- Breitbart's Marlow doubts the hospital claim but asserts Talarico is "completely nuts" and always mentally unstable, without presenting evidence in the segment.
-
Why Sabia apologised
- Left
- Raw Story relays critics' speculation that he got a call from lawyers, while quoting his own statement that he got it wrong.
- Right
- Breitbart does not mention Sabia's apology.
Carmine Sabia person
Apologised, saying he relied on available reporting, got it wrong and retracts it, while still supporting Paxton.
“I apologize for sharing the false report about James Talarico receiving mental health treatment” — Raw Story
James Talarico person
His campaign called the claim a lie, saying he was home in Austin recovering from the flu.
“Talarico’s campaign called the claim a lie, saying he was home in Austin recovering from the flu.” — Raw Story
Alex Marlow person
Doubts the hospital story but says Talarico is "completely nuts".
“My answer, in all honesty, is probably not.” — Breitbart
Ken Paxton person
Is Talarico's Senate opponent; Sabia said he supports Paxton. No statement from Paxton in the coverage.
“I support Ken Paxton, but the truth matters more than winning on a lie.” — Raw Story
Left1 article
-
MAGA pundit’s curious Talarico apology sparks suspicion he ‘got a call from the lawyers’
Critical Reports the apology as curious and embarrassing for conservatives who spread the false story, quoting critics' legal speculation.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
BreitbartR · · Opinion
Marlow: Talafreako Was Always Mentally Unstable
Dismissive Opinion clip that doubts the hospital claim but insults Talarico and asserts he is unstable.
- 13 Oct 16:41 First Raw StoryL MAGA pundit’s curious Talarico apology sparks suspicion he ‘got a call from the lawyers’
- 14 Oct 08:46 +16h 5m BreitbartR Marlow: Talafreako Was Always Mentally Unstable Opinion
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…