Skip to content
Bramble

UK

Cass Review author says she does not support draft Conversion Practices Bill

Baroness Hilary Cass told a parliamentary committee she does not support the draft Conversion Practices Bill in its current form, though she welcomed it when it was published in June. The government said it welcomed her comments and wants to "get this ban right".

2 outlets · 0L · 1C · 1R First reported Account updated
Image: BBC News
Image: GB News

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2Baroness Hilary Cass, who led the independent review of gender identity services for young people, told a parliamentary committee scrutinising the draft Conversion Practices Bill that she does not support it in its current form. Right · 1She said she had spent a long time thinking about it and did not think it was "anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences". Centre · 1When the government published the draft in June, Cass was quoted in its publicity as pleased that it gave a clearer definition of what conversion practices are and are not, and as looking forward to further scrutiny.

Mixed · 2Asked about that earlier support, she said she backed the idea but had not had time to read the details before the press release; GB News reports she had one hour to review it and was 15 minutes from giving a speech. Mixed · 2Her main concern was that the bill's harm threshold, which requires "serious harm to the individual's physical or mental health, or serious alarm or distress" with a substantial effect on daily activities, could allow "vexatious" complaints against therapists and clinicians working with gender-distressed young people. Mixed · 2She said staff at the new NHS Gender Dysphoria Clinics feared that even complaints that did not lead to prosecution could be damaging, and, per GB News, that people have died by suicide while awaiting the outcome of a GMC referral.

Mixed · 2She also warned that parents could be caught by the bill, for example by withholding money they feared would be spent on a breast binder or hormones; GB News adds she cited declining to use a preferred pronoun, and quotes her saying there was no intent to catch parents but it was a potential risk of how the bill is framed. Centre · 1Cass said she still believes no LGBT person should be subjected to conversion practices, which she called "abhorrent" in her 2024 report, and that she wants a bill that protects those it is meant to protect without accidentally entrapping others. Mixed · 2A government spokesperson said it welcomed both her support for ending abusive conversion practices and her comments on avoiding adverse consequences, and would take all committee evidence seriously, describing the draft as put forward for pre-legislative scrutiny.

Mixed · 2The draft bill covers England and Wales and, according to GB News, would carry up to five years in prison and unlimited fines; Labour promised a ban in its 2024 manifesto, and earlier governments, beginning with Theresa May in 2018, made similar pledges. Right · 1GB News also reports other critics: clinical psychologist Dr Anna Hutchinson and BACP's Dr Lisa Morrison told the committee they knew of no abusive conversion practices or complaints of the kind described, over 1,000 church leaders oppose the bill, and Gay Men's Network director Dennis Kavanagh and Sex Matters chief executive Maya Forstater said Cass's move was damning and hard to see the bill surviving.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left0 outlets

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre1 outlet

Framing
Straight report of the committee evidence, leading on Cass's change of position and the 'serious unintended consequences' she described, with the government's response given prominence.
Emphasis
Cass's explanation of the earlier quote, her continued opposition to conversion practices, the definition of conversion practices, and the government's reply.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not carry the other witnesses, church leaders or campaigners' reactions, nor the penalties in the draft.
For example
“She told the committee she wants "a bill that protects the people it's supposed to protect, but doesn't accidentally entrap those who you don't want to [entrap]."” — BBC News

Right1 outlet

Framing
Presents Cass's evidence as a damaging reversal for Labour's bill, followed by critics who say it should be scrapped.
Emphasis
The u-turn, the penalties (up to five years), other sceptical witnesses, church opposition and reactions from Sex Matters and the Gay Men's Network.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not include her statement that she still believes no LGBT person should be subjected to conversion practices; the government response is taken from the BBC.
Charged language
“u-turned”“reversed her position”“damning”“tyrannical and poorly drafted”“Labour's ban on conversion therapy”
For example
“Director of the Gay Men's Network Dennis Kavanagh described Lady Cass's withdrawal of support as "damning" and called the legislation "tyrannical and poorly drafted", urging the government to scrap it entirely.” — GB News

Ask about this story

Loading…