Irish and Welsh children's laureates to give Sally Rooney royalties over Palestine Action ban
Chris Haughton, Ireland's children's literature laureate, and Nicola Davies, Wales's children's laureate, say they will donate royalties to Sally Rooney in solidarity over her support for the proscribed group Palestine Action. Rooney's books are no longer on sale in the UK.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Chris Haughton, Ireland's children's literature laureate, and Nicola Davies, children's laureate for Wales, say they will donate royalties from their books to the Irish author Sally Rooney in solidarity with her. The GuardianLC “The children’s laureates for Ireland and Wales are donating royalties from their works to Sally Rooney in a show of solidarity” Read at The Guardian ↗ Arab NewsRC “Two renowned children’s writers have said they will donate royalties to Irish author Sally Rooney in solidarity over her support for banned group Palestine Action.” Read at Arab News ↗ Mixed · 2Rooney's books are no longer sold in the UK. The Guardian says she was forced to stop selling them because of her support for Palestine Action. Arab News says her publisher withdrew them after she said she would use proceeds from sales to support the group. The GuardianLC “after she was forced to stop selling books in the UK because of her support for Palestine Action” Read at The Guardian ↗ Arab NewsRC “Rooney’s books were withdrawn from circulation in the UK by her publisher after she said she would use proceeds from sales to support Palestine Action.” Read at Arab News ↗ Mixed · 2Palestine Action became the first direct action group to be proscribed under the UK Terrorism Act, in July last year. The ban puts it in the same category as al-Qaida and Boko Haram. Providing money that one knows or has reasonable cause to suspect may be used for terrorism carries a maximum jail term of 14 years. The GuardianLC “became the first direct action group to be proscribed under the UK Terrorism Act in July last year, placing it in the same category as the likes of al-Qaida and Boko Haram”“Providing money one knows or has reasonable cause to suspect will or may be used for terrorism carries a maximum jail term of 14 years.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Arab NewsRC “providing it with financial aid carries a maximum sentence of 14 years in prison.” Read at Arab News ↗
Left · 1Haughton said he wanted to show the "absurdity" of Rooney being unable to receive royalties from her own UK sales. He called the situation "a farce" and said sending her money was "making a mockery of the law". He said he could not do what she had done because he is in the UK a lot of the time, but could support her instead of supporting Palestine Action. The GuardianLC “The entire situation is just a farce. Sending Sally Rooney the money adds another level of absurdity to this absurd situation, it’s making a mockery of the law.”“As someone who is in the UK a lot of the time, I can’t do what she has done, but I can support her instead of supporting Palestine Action.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2Haughton also said that Palestine Action is "the only organisation – or the most effective organisation" in the UK to have had some success in stopping arms going to a genocide. He said he was sure he would be "on the right side of history". The GuardianLC “Palestine Action are the only organisation – or the most effective organisation – in the UK that that has had some success in stopping arms going to a genocide” Read at The Guardian ↗ Arab NewsRC “I’m very sure that I will be on the right side of history,” he said.” Read at Arab News ↗ Left · 1The Guardian reports that Haughton has twice been arrested for holding placards allegedly supporting Palestine Action. The alleged offence carries a maximum sentence of six months in prison. The GuardianLC “Haughton said he has twice been arrested for holding placards allegedly supporting Palestine Action”“His alleged offence carries a maximum sentence of six months in prison.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Mixed · 2Davies, author of The Day War Came, about a child refugee from war, said she cannot claim to stand up for Wales's children while the children of Gaza are "murdered and mutilated without comment". She said she will donate to Rooney the royalties from that book when her half-year royalties arrive shortly. The GuardianLC “I can’t say that I am standing up for the children of Wales if I allow the children of Gaza to be murdered and mutilated without comment.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Arab NewsRC “when my half-year royalties arrive shortly, I will donate to her the royalties from my book ‘The Day War Came,’” Read at Arab News ↗ Left · 1Prime Minister Andy Burnham was asked at prime minister's questions whether he would review the ban in light of Rooney's situation. He replied that proscription "followed a rigorous and evidence-based process that came before this house, endorsed by parliament". The Guardian says he declined to comment further because of a pending court case. The GuardianLC “proscription “followed a rigorous and evidence-based process that came before this house, endorsed by parliament”.”“He said he would not comment further given that the supreme court is due to hear a legal challenge” Read at The Guardian ↗ Mixed · 2The Supreme Court is due to hear a legal challenge to the ban on 4 and 5 November. The Guardian says the challenge argues that the ban interferes disproportionately with the rights to freedom of expression and protest. Arab News notes that the decision was made under Burnham's predecessor, Keir Starmer. The GuardianLC “on the basis that it interferes disproportionately with the rights to freedom of expression and protest, on 4 and 5 November.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Arab NewsRC “made under his predecessor Keir Starmer” Read at Arab News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Guardian leads with the laureates' solidarity and frames Rooney's UK sales ban as an absurdity affecting free expression. It gives legal detail on the offences, including the six-month and 14-year maximum sentences.
- Emphasis
- The legal consequences, Haughton's arrests, and the Supreme Court challenge on freedom of expression and protest grounds.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not explain how or by whom Rooney's books were withdrawn from sale.
- Charged language
- “absurdity”“farce”“making a mockery of the law”
- For example
-
“Chris Haughton, Ireland’s children’s literature laureate, said he also wanted to demonstrate the “absurdity” of the bestselling author being unable to receive royalties from her own UK sales” — The Guardian
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Arab News reports the pledge as a show of support for Rooney's stance, drawing on the Guardian's interview with Haughton. It calls Palestine Action a "banned group" and the writers "renowned".
- Emphasis
- The writers' quotes and the publisher's withdrawal of Rooney's books. It adds that Burnham's decision was made under his predecessor Starmer.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Leaves out the six-month maximum sentence for Haughton's alleged offence and the grounds of the Supreme Court challenge.
- Charged language
- “banned group”“Renowned writers”
- For example
-
“Haughton highlighted the “absurdity” of the situation, telling The Guardian” — Arab News
What every side reports
- Chris Haughton and Nicola Davies say they will donate royalties to Sally Rooney.
- Palestine Action is proscribed under the UK Terrorism Act, and providing it with financial support carries a maximum 14-year sentence.
- Andy Burnham said proscription followed a rigorous, evidence-based process endorsed by parliament.
- A Supreme Court challenge to the ban is due on 4 and 5 November.
Where accounts differ
-
Why Rooney's books are not on sale in the UK
- Left
- The Guardian says she was forced to stop selling books in the UK because of her support for Palestine Action.
- Right
- Arab News says her publisher withdrew the books from circulation after she said she would use sales proceeds to support the group.
Sally Rooney person
Rooney said she would use proceeds from her sales to support Palestine Action. The coverage reports no new comment from her on the laureates' pledge.
“Rooney, whose books include Normal People and Conversations with Friends, said that she would use proceeds from her sales to support Palestine Action.” — The Guardian
UK and Ireland1 outlet
The Guardian gives more domestic legal and political detail, including the arrest, sentencing maximums and the grounds of the Supreme Court challenge.
“Haughton said he has twice been arrested for holding placards allegedly supporting Palestine Action” — The Guardian
The Guardian
Middle East1 outlet
Arab News retells the story from the Guardian's interview, with less legal detail, and notes that Burnham's decision was made under his predecessor Starmer.
“telling The Guardian” — Arab News
Arab News
Left1 article
-
Two children’s laureates to give Sally Rooney royalties after ban on UK sales
Sympathetic Presents the laureates' pledge as principled solidarity and gives space to their criticism of the ban, alongside Burnham's response and the legal context.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
Renowned writers pledge royalties to support Sally Rooney’s Palestine Action stance
Mixed Condensed rewrite of the Guardian report that presents the pledge as support for Rooney, mostly in the writers' own words, while using neutral legal descriptors such as "banned group" and "proscribed group".
- 25 Oct 12:00 First The GuardianLC Two children’s laureates to give Sally Rooney royalties after ban on UK sales
- 25 Oct 16:38 +4h 38m Arab NewsRC Renowned writers pledge royalties to support Sally Rooney’s Palestine Action stance
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…