Chris Columbus says he fired original Marv actor from Home Alone; Daniel Roebuck disputes details
On the Wildmen podcast, director Chris Columbus said the actor first cast as Marv in Home Alone was "awful" in a screen test and was the only person he ever fired. Daniel Roebuck, who has said he was that actor, told Entertainment Weekly no such screen test happened.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Daily Mail.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Home Alone director Chris Columbus said on the Wildmen podcast that another actor was cast as Marv before Daniel Stern, and that he fired him after a screen test. The IndependentLC “another actor was initially cast to play Marv — but he ended up being “awful.”” Read at The Independent ↗ Screen RantN “Chris Columbus explained that Stern and Pesci were the original choices to play Marv and Harry.” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Mixed · 2Columbus said Stern was unavailable at first because the studio would not pay for both Stern and Joe Pesci: "They said, ‘You only get one.’ So I said, ‘Okay, let’s go with Pesci.’" The IndependentLC ““We didn’t have Dan Stern because the studio wouldn’t pay for Dan Stern,”” Read at The Independent ↗ Screen RantN “And they said, ‘You only get one.’ So I said, ‘Okay, let’s go with Pesci.’”” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Mixed · 2He described the screen test with the replacement as bad: "Pesci was great. This other kid was, and he was a kid at the time, he was just awful," adding that it was the only time he had to fire anyone. The IndependentLC ““We did a screen test and they were horrible,” the Mrs. Doubtfire director continued.” Read at The Independent ↗ Screen RantN “that’s the only person I ever had to fire.”” Read at Screen Rant ↗
Mixed · 2Columbus said he told the actor in his office, "We’ll work together at some point," which has not happened, and that the actor was paid out on his Home Alone contract. The IndependentLC “Columbus said they never ended up working together, but the actor was paid out for his Home Alone contract.” Read at The Independent ↗ Screen RantN “which has not happened yet decades later” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Right · 1Asked whether he had followed through on that promise, Columbus answered "no", adding "What else am I going to say?"; he also said the studio "had to not only pay him, then they had to hire Dan Stern. So it ended up costing them more money." Daily MailR “Columbus gave a firm 'no', adding of his original offer, 'What else am I going to say?'”“had to not only pay him, then they had to hire Dan Stern. So it ended up costing them more money.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Left · 1Stern then returned, and Columbus said the screen test with Stern and Pesci was "amazing." The Independent notes Stern wrote in his 2024 memoir that backing out over a scheduling dispute was "one of the stupidest decisions in my showbusiness life." The IndependentLC ““Then we did the screen test with Stern and Pesci, and they were amazing,” Columbus recalled”“one of the stupidest decisions in my showbusiness life”” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 1Columbus did not name the fired actor, but Daniel Roebuck said on the What a Character! podcast in 2023 that he rehearsed with Pesci for four days before being let go, and that Columbus had promised him a great part in his next movie. The IndependentLC “Roebuck said that he rehearsed with Pesci for four days, but was ultimately fired.”““Chris Columbus said, ‘I will give you a great part [in] my next movie,’”” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2In 2023 Roebuck also said he was "never gonna be Marv" on film and recalled a cold handshake from writer-producer John Hughes. Screen RantN ““I was never gonna be Marv. Now that’s the one thing they never say.” Read at Screen Rant ↗ The IndependentLC “the “wettest handshake of my life” from writer and producer John Hughes” Read at The Independent ↗ Centre · 1Screen Rant reports that Entertainment Weekly asked Roebuck about Columbus's new comments. Roebuck said he has "enormous respect" for Columbus but finds the comments "troubling," that producers "did everything they could to get me to quit," and that "There was no screen test with Joe Pesci." Screen RantN ““I have enormous respect for Chris Columbus. I’ve enjoyed all of his movies. But I find these comments troubling.”“There was no screen test with Joe Pesci. That never ever happened, so that’s impossible.”” Read at Screen Rant ↗
Mixed · 2Roebuck still thinks Stern and Pesci were the right choices and hopes to work with Columbus. The Independent said it had contacted Roebuck for comment. Screen RantN “He ultimately feels that Stern and Pesci were "terrific" and the right choices for Marv and Harry” Read at Screen Rant ↗ The IndependentLC “The Independent has reached out to Roebuck for comment.” Read at The Independent ↗ Right · 1The Daily Mail, which also said it had reached out to representatives for Columbus and Roebuck, reports that Entertainment Weekly identified the fired actor as Roebuck, and that Roebuck said he has no hard feelings about not getting the part. Daily MailR “Entertainment Weekly reported that the actor was Daniel Roebuck, who previously confirmed he was fired from the film after four days”“The Daily Mail has reached out to representatives for Columbus and Roebuck for comment.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Centre · 1Screen Rant adds that Columbus is directing and co-writing Gremlins 3, due in cinemas on 6 October 2028, and that there are six Home Alone films, with Stern, Pesci and Macaulay Culkin absent from all since Lost in New York. Screen RantN “Gremlins 3, which is scheduled to be released in theaters on October 6, 2028.”“There are now a total of six Home Alone movies, but Stern, Pesci, and Culkin have not starred in any of them since Lost in New York.” Read at Screen Rant ↗
Right · 1The Daily Mail also notes that Macaulay Culkin was linked in July to a possible Disney reboot; journalist Matthew Belloni said on his podcast The Town that Disney is courting Culkin, adding "It may not happen, but I think it will." Daily MailR “In July, Culkin was linked to a possible reboot of the blockbuster for Disney.”“'It may not happen, but I think it will,' Belloni said.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Reports Columbus's podcast remarks as a casting-trivia revelation, supplemented by Roebuck's earlier 2023 account and Stern's memoir.
- Emphasis
- Columbus's quotes, the studio budget reason, Roebuck's earlier account, and Stern's memoir regret.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include Roebuck's new response disputing the screen test; it says it has asked him for comment.
- For example
-
“The Independent has reached out to Roebuck for comment.” — The Independent
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Presents Columbus's explanation 36 years on, then gives Roebuck's rebuttal and the franchise's wider context.
- Emphasis
- Roebuck's disagreement with Columbus's version, plus Home Alone sequels' reception and Columbus's upcoming Gremlins 3.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits Stern's memoir remarks and Roebuck's claim about Columbus's promise to work together later.
- For example
-
“There was no screen test with Joe Pesci. That never ever happened, so that’s impossible.” — Screen Rant
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Leads with Columbus 'ripping' a 'horrible' actor he fired, in a tabloid style, then gives Roebuck's denial and a Culkin reboot rumour.
- Emphasis
- Columbus's harsh wording, his 'no' on working with the actor again, Roebuck's rebuttal, and Disney's courtship of Culkin.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention Stern's memoir or Columbus's Gremlins 3 plans.
- Charged language
- “rips”“horrible”“He was just awful”
- For example
-
“Home Alone director Chris Columbus rips 'horrible' actor he fired from the beloved holiday classic: 'He was just awful'” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- Chris Columbus told the Wildmen podcast that the studio would not pay for Daniel Stern, so Joe Pesci was chosen first.
- Columbus did not name the actor he fired as Marv's first casting, and called him "awful" in a screen test.
- Columbus said it was the only time he had to fire someone and that he told the actor they would work together at some point.
- Daniel Roebuck said in 2023 that he was the actor replaced as Marv.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether a screen test with Pesci took place and why the actor left
- Left
- The Independent relays Columbus's account of a bad screen test and firing, and Roebuck's 2023 account that he rehearsed with Pesci for four days; it says it has asked Roebuck for comment.
- Centre
- Screen Rant relays Columbus's account, then Roebuck's response to Entertainment Weekly: no screen test with Pesci occurred and producers tried to make him quit.
-
The studio would not pay for both Daniel Stern and Joe Pesci, so Stern was initially not cast as Marv.
Reported- Reports 3
- The Independent, Screen Rant, Daily Mail
-
The first-cast Marv actor was fired after a bad screen test with Joe Pesci.
Disputed- Disputes 2
- Screen Rant, Daily Mail
- Reports 1
- The Independent
Chris Columbus person
Says the first Marv actor was bad in a screen test with Pesci and was the only person he has fired, and that the actor was paid out.
“that’s the only person I ever had to fire.”” — The Independent
“the actor was paid out for his Home Alone contract.” — The Independent
Daniel Stern person
Was originally unavailable and returned; in his 2024 memoir he called backing out over a scheduling dispute one of his stupidest decisions. Screen test with Pesci was "amazing" per Columbus.
“one of the stupidest decisions in my showbusiness life”” — The Independent
Left1 article
-
Home Alone director reveals why original actor for Marv was fired
Neutral Straight entertainment news recounting Columbus's podcast comments with background from Roebuck's earlier interview.

Centre1 article
-
Why Home Alone Recast Marv Addressed By Director 36 Years Later
Neutral Explainer that adds Roebuck's rebuttal and franchise context to Columbus's remarks.

Right2 articles
-
Mixed Tabloid-styled lead stressing Columbus's harsh words about the fired actor, balanced by Roebuck's denial and a Culkin reboot tangent.

-

- 17 Nov 19:25 First The IndependentLC Home Alone director reveals why original actor for Marv was fired
- 18 Nov 01:02 +5h 37m Screen RantN Why Home Alone Recast Marv Addressed By Director 36 Years Later
- 18 Nov 01:03 +5h 38m Daily MailR Home Alone director Chris Columbus rips 'horrible' actor he fired from the beloved holiday classic: 'He was just awful'
- 18 Nov 15:33 +20h 8m Daily MailR Heartbroken fired Home Alone star blasts 'lying' director Chris Columbus for calling him a 'horrible actor' - before he was replaced by Daniel Stern
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…