Pre-COP31 climate talks open in Nadi, Fiji, with Pacific states pressing 1.5C and finance
Ministers and negotiators are meeting in Nadi, Fiji, in early October to prepare the COP31 summit in Turkey's Antalya province in November. Pacific nations are pushing for the 1.5C target, more climate finance and attention to oceans, while turnout of world leaders is under scrutiny.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Ministers, climate negotiators and a handful of leaders are due to meet in the Fijian city of Nadi in early October for preliminary talks ahead of the UN climate summit COP31. RFIN “Ministers, climate negotiators and a handful of leaders will meet in the Fijian city of Nadi for the 5-6 October talks.” Read at RFI ↗ Arab NewsRC “Ministers, climate negotiators and a handful of leaders will meet in the Fijian city of Nadi for the October 5-8 talks.” Read at Arab News ↗ COP31 is to be held in November in Turkey's Antalya province. The two AFP-based reports give different dates for the Nadi talks: 5-6 October in the RFI copy and 5-8 October in the Arab News copy. RFIN “They will be charting the course for a major UN-sponsored global climate summit, known as Cop31, to be held in November in Turkey's Antalya province.” Read at RFI ↗ Arab NewsRC “for the October 5-8 talks.” Read at Arab News ↗ Pacific leaders are pushing for the world to stick to a target of limiting global warming to 1.5C, to enhance access to climate finance and to give more attention to the impact on oceans. RFIN “Pacific leaders are pushing for the world to stick to a target of limiting global warming to 1.5C, enhance access to climate finance, and give more attention to the impact on oceans.” Read at RFI ↗ Arab NewsRC “Pacific leaders are pushing for the world to stick to a target of limiting global warming to 1.5C, enhance access to climate finance, and give more attention to the impact on oceans.” Read at Arab News ↗
A UN report released in August said sea level is rising at a record pace and that up to 1.2 billion people could be displaced by 2050, with Pacific island countries seeing sea level rise at twice the global average. It also pointed to a financing gap: developing countries need US$310-US$365 billion to adapt, but only US$26 billion in adaptation finance was available in 2023. RFIN “Up to 1.2 billion people could be displaced by 2050, with Pacific island countries experiencing sea level rise at twice the global average, said the report released in August.” Read at RFI ↗ Arab NewsRC “yet having only US$26 billion in adaptation finance available in 2023.” Read at Arab News ↗ Top delegates will hold a one-day retreat on low-lying Tuvalu, where they will be shown land reclamation efforts. The capital Funafuti's highest point is two metres above sea level, and two of the nine coral atolls are already largely swamped. Tuvalu is planning to relocate its population if the ocean consumes it. RFIN “Top delegates to the Pacific talks will hold a one-day retreat on low-lying Tuvalu, a small island nation laying plans to relocate the population if it is consumed by the ocean.” Read at RFI ↗ Arab NewsRC “two of its nine coral atolls are already largely swamped by rising seas.” Read at Arab News ↗ Tuvalu Prime Minister Feleti Teo told the UN General Assembly that "Sea-level rise is not a future threat, it is a present reality" and that the world must act now. Arab NewsRC ““Sea-level rise is not a future threat, it is a present reality,” Tuvalu Prime Minister Feleti Teo told the UN General Assembly ahead of the climate talks.” Read at Arab News ↗
Australia bowed out of a contest with Turkey to host COP31 last year in a deal that lets it preside over the negotiations and bring the preparatory talks to the Pacific. As a major coal exporter, it has faced criticism over the scale of its fossil fuel extraction. Climate minister Chris Bowen, president of the COP31 negotiations, says Australia is rapidly expanding renewable energy, which he calls essential for a transition away from fossil fuels. RFIN “Last year, Australia bowed out of a contest with Turkey to host the Cop31 summit in a deal that let it preside over negotiations and bring the preparatory talks to the Pacific.” Read at RFI ↗ Arab NewsRC “Chris Bowen, the country's climate minister, says Australia is rapidly expanding its renewable energy sources, which are essential for a transition away from fossil fuels.” Read at Arab News ↗ Bowen rejected media criticism that the talks had failed to draw enough world leaders, saying "It's not normally a leaders meeting". Fewer than a dozen leaders have publicly confirmed, mostly from the Pacific. Fiji said last month it expected the heads of state of Antigua and Barbuda, Cape Verde, Thailand, the Maldives and Timor-Leste. RFIN “Fewer than a dozen world leaders have so far publicly confirmed that they will attend the meetings in Fiji and Tuvalu, mostly from the Pacific.” Read at RFI ↗ Arab NewsRC ““It’s not normally a leaders meeting,” Bowen told reporters in the run-up to the talks, which are usually held at the ministerial and senior-negotiator level.” Read at Arab News ↗ Organisers have not released detailed attendance figures. Bowen said last month that 4,000 people from 60 nations would attend, without a full breakdown. RFIN “Bowen said last month 4,000 people from 60 nations would attend, without providing a full breakdown.” Read at RFI ↗ Arab NewsRC “Organisers have not released detailed figures on attendance.” Read at Arab News ↗
Marine scientist Rajneel Singh, part of a team that reported large-scale coral death around Tuvalu after a 2024 marine heatwave, said he was disheartened by a perceived lack of attention: "There's no awareness of what's happening." Nepal's foreign minister, Shisir Khanal, has confirmed he will attend, after the 26 August Himalayan flood disaster that killed nearly 1,500 and left 5,800 missing in Nepal and China. Arab NewsRC ““It’s very, very sad. There’s no awareness of what’s happening,” Singh told AFP.” Read at Arab News ↗ RFIN “killed nearly 1,500 and left 5,800 missing in the two countries.” Read at RFI ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- RFI carries AFP's report framing the talks as world powers gathering in the Pacific to see island nations' plight, with scrutiny of Australia's coal exports and low leader turnout.
- Emphasis
- Sea-level data, Tuvalu's vulnerability, Australia's role, and attendance.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not state the talks run to 8 October, as Arab News's copy does.
- Charged language
- “haggle”
- For example
-
“World powers are flying delegates to the Pacific to haggle over the fight against global warming, and to see the plight of island nations surrounded by a rising ocean.” — RFI
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Arab News runs the same AFP report, with the same lead and structure.
- Emphasis
- Same as the AFP text: Pacific vulnerability, Australia's fossil fuel role and leader turnout.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Its copy lacks the RFI-inserted links to other stories on European heat stress and Nigerian heat deaths.
- Charged language
- “haggle”
- For example
-
“World powers are flying delegates to the Pacific to haggle over the fight against global warming, and to see the plight of island nations surrounded by a rising ocean.” — Arab News
What every side reports
- Ministers, negotiators and a few leaders are meeting in Nadi, Fiji, ahead of COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, in November.
- Pacific leaders want the 1.5C target kept, more climate finance and more attention to oceans.
- Fewer than a dozen world leaders have publicly confirmed attendance, mostly from the Pacific.
- Chris Bowen, Australia's climate minister, presides over the COP31 negotiations.
- Delegates will hold a one-day retreat on Tuvalu.
Where accounts differ
-
Dates of the Nadi talks
- Centre
- RFI's AFP copy says 5-6 October.
- Right
- Arab News's AFP copy says 5-8 October.
Fiji place
Fiji hosts the talks; it said last month it expected heads of state from Antigua and Barbuda, Cape Verde, Thailand, the Maldives and Timor-Leste.
“Fiji said last month it expected the heads of state for Antigua and Barbuda, Cape Verde, Thailand, the Maldives and Timor-Leste would attend.” — Arab News
COP31 event
COP31 is the UN-sponsored summit due in November in Antalya, Turkey, with Australia presiding over negotiations and the preparatory talks held in the Pacific.
“Last year, Australia bowed out of a contest with Turkey to host the COP31 summit in a deal that let it preside over negotiations and bring the preparatory talks to the Pacific.” — Arab News
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre1 article
-
RFIN ·
World powers gather in Pacific to chart climate battle
Neutral AFP copy on RFI presenting the Nadi talks as a Pacific bid for attention, with balanced reporting on Australia's coal role and turnout.

Right1 article
-
Arab NewsRC · · via AFP
World powers gather in Pacific to chart climate battle
Neutral AFP copy on Arab News with the same framing and content, giving 5-8 October as the dates.

- 2 Oct 06:50 First RFIN World powers gather in Pacific to chart climate battle
- 2 Oct 06:59 +9m Arab NewsRC World powers gather in Pacific to chart climate battle via AFP
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.