Skip to content
Bramble

World

Watchdog logs thousands of 'false flag' posts after flydubai attack; UK MP criticised

The Combat Antisemitism Movement says conspiracy posts blaming Israel or Jews for the flydubai FZ1073 incident appeared on X 67 minutes after the first distress signal. Four right-leaning outlets cover it; two also report criticism of UK MP Ayoub Khan's "smell a rat" remark.

4 outlets · 0L · 0C · 4R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from Breitbart, GB News. Previously: “Watchdog tracks thousands of 'false flag' posts blaming Israel after flydubai attack”.

Image: JNS
Image: The Jerusalem Post
Image: GB News
Image: Breitbart

1 / 4

The story, neutrally told

Right · 2The Combat Antisemitism Movement (CAM) said antisemitic conspiracy theories began appearing on X 67 minutes after flydubai Flight FZ1073 sent its first emergency signal on Wednesday. Right · 1The flight was travelling from Dubai to Tel Aviv when, according to the reports, the co-pilot allegedly stabbed Capt. Smit Machchhar and apparently tried to crash the Boeing 737. Right · 2Passengers overpowered the attacker after the wounded captain opened the cockpit door, and two other flydubai pilots on board landed the plane at Tabuk, Saudi Arabia. The Jerusalem Post says it carried 174 passengers and was a Boeing 737 MAX 8.

Right · 2CAM's Antisemitism Research Center counted 2,963 posts on X over a 12-hour monitoring period that blamed Israel, the Mossad, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Zionists or Jews for the incident. Right · 2It collected 4,136 posts containing the phrase 'false flag', about 72% of which promoted such claims, a share that rose to 82% in the final hour. Right · 2The Jerusalem Post gives a fuller timeline: 100 posts by 3:07 AM ET, 500 by 5:42 AM ET, 1,000 by 7:35 AM ET and 2,000 by 9:36 AM ET, with a peak of 623 posts between 9:00 and 10:00 AM ET. JNS says 1,000 posts were documented within five hours.

Right · 1Examples in the report included posts claiming Netanyahu staged the event to cancel elections or distract from criminal charges, and posts comparing it to September 11 and October 7. Right · 2CAM research associate Oliver Marks said the speed was striking and that the narrative is 'part of a script that already exists'. The study said the pattern mirrors influence operations by hostile states, Russia foremost among them. The coverage presents this as CAM's assessment and gives no independent evidence of state involvement. Right · 1CyberWell founder and CEO Tal-Or Cohen Montemayor also said 'false flag' claims quickly emerged, calling them a form of 'conspiratorial self-victimization', and urged platforms to use real-time expertise to respond.

Right · 1JNS reports that Israeli authorities were participating in the investigation, and that the motive remained under investigation. Right · 1GB News reported that Ayoub Khan, independent MP for Birmingham Perry Barr, said he was "genuinely shocked as to the speed of this enquiry by the Israeli spokespeople" and added: "Normally it takes them months if not years. I think I smell a rat!" Right · 2Labour peer Lord Austin said Khan needed to apologise for a comment that "appears to endorse crazy conspiracy theories that the Flydubai terror attack was somehow a false flag by Israel"; Khan rejected the call, said he wouldn't believe Netanyahu's word unless independently corroborated, and, asked who he thought responsible, replied "I don't know".

Right · 1Khan said any reasonable person would wait for the black box recording and testimony from the cockpit. GB News also recounted his earlier controversies, including that he was ordered to undergo antisemitism training as a councillor in 2023, which he later said he had not agreed to. Right · 1Breitbart, citing Australia's ABC News, said one X post by American commentator Jackson Hinkle claiming Netanyahu staged the attack because he was expected to lose the election gathered over 1.5 million views, and an AI-generated deepfake imitating a BBC report that alleged an India-Israel plot was viewed over 300,000 times before X added a warning. Right · 1Former US ambassador to Israel David Friedman said the claims ignore that a near catastrophe linked to a failure to vet an Omani co-pilot does not help those in charge; Breitbart also relayed CyberWell's warning that such content could feed AI systems.

Right · 2Reports differ on passenger numbers: the Jerusalem Post said 174, GB News 180. GB News also said the plane dropped from 33,000 to 17,000 feet in a minute and that the co-pilot was arrested in Saudi Arabia, with identity and motive unknown.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left0 outlets

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right4 outlets

Framing
JNS and the Jerusalem Post relay CAM's study as evidence of how fast antisemitic conspiracy narratives spread; GB News turns to a UK MP accused of endorsing a conspiracy theory; Breitbart combines the CAM findings with Khan and strongly dismisses the theories.
Emphasis
Speed and volume of posts, CAM and CyberWell quotes, Lord Austin's rebuke of Ayoub Khan, Khan's past controversies, and Breitbart's use of ABC News on Jackson Hinkle's post and the BBC deepfake.
Leaves out or plays down
None offers independent verification of CAM's counts or the Russia comparison; none includes a response from X or the posters beyond Khan; Khan's remarks are mostly given through critics' framing, and no left or centre outlet in this set covers it.
Charged language
“I smell a rat!”“crazy conspiracy theory”“basement-dwelling pseudonymous hatemonger”“Pro-Gaza MP”
For example
“A pro-Gaza MP has been accused of sharing a "distasteful" conspiracy theory” — GB News
“Not everyone spreading these conspiracy theories is a basement-dwelling pseudonymous hatemonger.” — Breitbart
“Watchdogs uncovered conspiracy theories blaming Israel for staging flydubai incident” — The Jerusalem Post

Ask about this story

Loading…