Skip to content
Bramble

World

Right-leaning commentary marks third anniversary of the October 7 attack

Two opinion pieces in US right-leaning outlets mark three years since the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack on Israel: one on how the victims are viewed, the other on stories of survival.

4 outlets · 0L · 0C · 4R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from JNS, Reason.

Image: Washington Examiner
Image: Fox News
Image: Reason
Image: JNS

1 / 4

The story, neutrally told

Right · 2Four opinion pieces from right-leaning outlets, three in the US and one Israeli, marked three years since the October 7, 2023 attack on Israel. Right · 1In the Washington Examiner, Hugo Gurdon wrote that Palestinian militants invaded Israel from Gaza and murdered 1,200 people, including children and babies, and kidnapped hundreds more. Right · 1Its headline argues that many people refuse to see Jews as victims of the attack, which it calls a "moral inversion".

Right · 1In Fox News, Dr Marc Siegel wrote that the attack involved more than 6,000 Hamas and related operatives and that it was followed by miraculous recoveries and narrow escapes, which he attributes to angels sent by God. Right · 1Siegel promotes his book "The Angels Among Us" and recounts an Israeli medic, Shlomi, who got a combat-gauze question wrong on a paramedic test, then studied it and used the gauze on 12 January 2024 to save a wounded soldier in Khan Yunis whose femoral artery was severed by shrapnel. Right · 1He also links the 30 September 2026 Flydubai Flight FZ1073 incident to the anniversary, saying a co-pilot, described as a reported radical extremist, attacked the pilot before passengers, including a dentist and two off-duty pilots, subdued him; this is Siegel's account and is not corroborated in the coverage.

Right · 1In Reason, law professor Ilya Somin wrote that the war has never wholly ceased despite various ceasefires and the release of the remaining hostages, with fighting involving Israel, Hamas and Hezbollah continuing and a related Iran War under way. Right · 1Somin's post is a compendium of his own earlier writings; he says he backs Israel's right to seek Hamas's elimination and calls Israel "incomparably superior to its enemies", while criticising the present Israeli government, settler violence against West Bank Palestinians, and hostage deals with terrorists. Right · 1He also lists pieces arguing that Trump's strikes on Iran were unconstitutional.

Right · 1In JNS, Phyllis Chesler reflected on the October 7 anniversary through the memoir of Geula Cohen, a late member of the Jewish underground group Lechi, praising the willingness to sacrifice shown by Cohen, Menachem Begin and David Ben-Gurion and saying Israel needs heroes. Right · 1Chesler relays, as an unverified secondhand claim from an anti-Netanyahu Israeli, that a politician received an 11-page military intelligence report warning of the attack weeks or months earlier and that Netanyahu "did nothing"; she uses it to question why that politician did not go public.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left0 outlets

No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right4 outlets

Framing
Opinion pieces treat the anniversary as a moral, spiritual and political reflection: denial of Jewish victimhood (Washington Examiner), miracles and angels against evil (Fox News), a liberal-democratic case for Israel alongside criticism of its government (Reason), and a call for heroic sacrifice drawn from Lechi history (JNS).
Emphasis
Victimhood of Jews and Israelis, scale of the atrocities, survival stories, Israel's moral superiority over Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran, and the need for sacrifice and heroes.
Leaves out or plays down
All four are opinion with no opposing views; Palestinian casualties and the wider course of the war are largely absent, apart from Reason's note on West Bank settler violence.
Charged language
“moral inversion”“demons”“incomparably superior to its enemies”“Big Lie”
For example
“In moral inversion, many refuse to see Jews as victims of 2023 Hamas attack” — Washington Examiner
“The massive damage inflicted by these demons caused a countersurge of angels released by God.” — Fox News
“For all its serious flaws from the standpoint of liberal values, Israel is incomparably superior to its enemies.” — Reason

Ask about this story

Loading…