Congressional commission sworn in to study moving Weitzman Jewish museum into Smithsonian
A bipartisan congressional commission was sworn in and met for the first time on Tuesday to advise Congress on whether Philadelphia's Weitzman National Museum of American Jewish History should join the Smithsonian. It has two years to report.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Right · 2A congressional commission studying whether Philadelphia's Weitzman National Museum of American Jewish History should become part of the Smithsonian Institution was sworn in and held its first meeting on Tuesday. JNSR “was sworn in and held its first meeting on Tuesday” Read at JNS ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “Its members were sworn in Tuesday, when they also held their first meeting.” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Right · 1Sens. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) and Dave McCormick (R-Pa.) swore in chair Philip Darivoff, vice chair Dara Horn and the six other commissioners. JNSR “Sens. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) and Dave McCormick (R-Pa.) swore in Darivoff, Horn and the six other commissioners on Tuesday.” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 1Congress passed the law creating the commission in 2024, and President Joe Biden signed it; JNS reports the House and Senate approved it unanimously. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries appointed Darivoff, a former chair of the Weitzman, and Senate Majority Leader John Thune chose Horn, an author. JNSR “Former President Joe Biden signed the law to establish the bipartisan commission in 2024 after the House and Senate approved it unanimously earlier that year.”“House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) appointed Darivoff to chair the group” Read at JNS ↗
Right · 1Other members include former Democratic congresswoman Kathy Manning, historian Tevi Troy and Michael Goldfarb, founder and publisher of the Washington Free Beacon. JNSR “Other members of the commission include former Democratic congresswoman Kathy Manning, historian Tevi Troy and Michael Goldfarb, founder and publisher of the Washington Free Beacon.” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 2The commission has two years from its first meeting to report to Congress and the president on issues including the possible transfer of collections, the financial implications, and the effect on combating Jew-hatred; Darivoff hopes to finish sooner. JNSR “The commission is tasked by law to send a report to Congress and the U.S. president within two years on issues including the potential transfer of collections” Read at JNS ↗ The Jerusalem PostRC “though Darivoff said he hopes to finish the work well before the deadline” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Right · 2Darivoff and Horn say Smithsonian membership would signal that Jewish American history matters to the nation and counter what they call an "epidemic of ignorance"; Horn argues the Holocaust should not be the main thing Americans learn about Jews, and Darivoff said people too often learn about Jews "from people who don't like Jews." The Jerusalem PostRC ““epidemic of ignorance” among Americans when it comes to knowledge of Jewish history and culture” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ JNSR ““Too many people in America learn about Jews from people who don’t like Jews,” Darivoff said.” Read at JNS ↗
Right · 1The Weitzman, founded in 1976, is already a Smithsonian affiliate with its own building and collection, which proponents hope could speed the process; its CEO Dan Tadmor said Smithsonian involvement would widen its educational reach. The Jerusalem PostRC “Founded in 1976, the Weitzman is already an existing, fully functioning institution — and also already a Smithsonian affiliate”““We have a national footprint for our educational programming, but of course we'd like to widen it,” he said.” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗ Right · 1The Smithsonian, an independent federal trust with 21 museums, would find the Weitzman unusual for being in Philadelphia rather than Washington, D.C., and the first such museum devoted to Jewish Americans; the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum is a federal institution but not part of the Smithsonian. JNSR “an independent federal trust that includes 21 museums, it would be unusual both for being in Philadelphia”“The U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington is a federal institution but not part of the Smithsonian” Read at JNS ↗ Right · 1The Jerusalem Post, carrying a JTA report, places the bid amid Trump administration efforts to exert more control over the Smithsonian, including a summer White House report alleging "radical ideology" and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum's plan for signs accusing its leaders of bias; Secretary Lonnie Bunch III leaves at year's end. A Smithsonian representative declined to comment, and the commissioners said the politics should not affect their work. The Jerusalem PostRC “This summer the White House issued a report alleging “radical ideology” in the museums' content”“A representative from the Smithsonian declined to comment to JTA on the Weitzman's bid”“Smithsonian Secretary Lonnie Bunch III is stepping down at the end of the year.” Read at The Jerusalem Post ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets, which are Israel-based and lean right, present the commission's work sympathetically, largely through interviews with chair Darivoff and vice chair Horn about the case for Smithsonian inclusion.
- Emphasis
- The commissioners' arguments about Jewish agency, ignorance of Jewish history, antisemitism and the Holocaust-centred view; JNS adds commission membership and the legal mandate, while the Jerusalem Post adds the Trump administration's Smithsonian dispute.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither quotes critics of the proposal or any Smithsonian leader. JNS leaves out the Smithsonian's current political turmoil; the Jerusalem Post gives less detail on appointments and the commission's remit.
- Charged language
- “epidemic of ignorance”“dead Jews”“Jew-hatred”
- For example
-
“said that the Weitzman joining the Smithsonian would send a powerful message that Jews are a crucial component of the history of the country.” — The Jerusalem Post
“bringing the museum into the Smithsonian fold would promote teaching Jewish history from a Jewish perspective.” — JNS
What every side reports
- The commission was sworn in and held its first meeting on Tuesday.
- Philip Darivoff chairs and Dara Horn is vice chair.
- The commission was created by a 2024 law signed by Biden and has two years to report.
- The commissioners argue Smithsonian membership would elevate Jewish American history beyond a Holocaust focus.
Philip Darivoff person
As commission chair, Darivoff says Smithsonian membership would make sense, would promote teaching Jewish history from a Jewish perspective, and would be an honour; he treats it as a long-term project unaffected by current politics.
““We think having a Smithsonian museum could make a great deal of sense.”” — JNS
““It'd be an honor to be included in the Smithsonian.”” — The Jerusalem Post
Weitzman National Museum of American Jewish History organisation
Its CEO Dan Tadmor says Smithsonian involvement would improve and widen its educational programming.
““Who would say no to a curriculum that's been developed by a Smithsonian museum?”” — The Jerusalem Post
Smithsonian Institution organisation
A Smithsonian representative declined to comment on the Weitzman's bid or the political conditions.
“A representative from the Smithsonian declined to comment to JTA on the Weitzman's bid” — The Jerusalem Post
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Jewish American history museum moves closer to joining Smithsonian amid political tensions
Sympathetic JTA copy run by the Jerusalem Post presents the bid as advancing Jewish history's place, set against Trump administration scrutiny of the Smithsonian.
-
JNSR ·
Sympathetic JNS reports the swearing-in largely through the chair's and vice chair's arguments about Jewish perspective and the limits of Holocaust-centred education.
- 14 Oct 03:20 First The Jerusalem PostRC Jewish American history museum moves closer to joining Smithsonian amid political tensions
- 14 Oct 20:51 +17h 31m JNSR Pennsylvania senators swear in panel to advise Congress on whether Smithsonian should take over Philadelphia Jewish museum
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…