Lawyer for Cornell 7 defendant seeks gag order on accuser's attorney Thomas Giuffra
An attorney for Diego Sarabia, one of seven men accused in a Cornell fraternity rape lawsuit, asked a Manhattan judge to bar the accuser's lawyer from public statements, citing a "media tour". Thomas Giuffra says the move is an attempt to silence his client and him.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Lawyers for Diego Sarabia, one of the seven accused Cornell fraternity members known as the "Cornell 7", have asked a Manhattan judge to impose a gag order on the accuser's attorney, Thomas Giuffra. New York PostR “Lawyers for one of the “Cornell 7’’ frat bros is demanding a Manhattan judge slap a gag order on the accuser’s attorney” Read at New York Post ↗ The IndependentLC “An attorney for one of the men accused in the Cornell gang-rape case has requested that the judge impose a gag order to limit what can be said in public.” Read at The Independent ↗ Right · 1The filing argues that Giuffra "has been trying his case in the media since filing the lawsuit, and reporting indicates that this was deliberate and planned," and that this could taint the jury pool. New York PostR “has been trying his case in the media since filing the lawsuit, and reporting indicates that this was deliberate and planned”“could blow any chance of an impartial jury” Read at New York Post ↗ Right · 1Sarabia's lawyers, James Knox and Alishah Bhimani, cited more than two dozen "extrajudicial statements" or media appearances by Giuffra and said these were only a small subset of the "media tour"; they asked the judge to sign the order immediately. New York PostR “The filing cited more than two dozen “extrajudicial statements” or media appearances made by Giuffra”“because there appears to be no end to plaintiff’s ongoing media campaign.” Read at New York Post ↗
Left · 1Knox wrote that the "media blast was not merely an organic result of inquiry, but has been an orchestrated campaign from the outset," posing a "risk of prejudice to our client, and more generally, all defendants." The IndependentLC “Plaintiff’s attorney’s media blast was not merely an organic result of inquiry, but has been an orchestrated campaign from the outset”“risk of prejudice to our client, and more generally, all defendants” Read at The Independent ↗ Left · 1The filing also pointed to online doxing, noting that the court has already found that an erroneous address linked to a defendant was used to threaten a nonparty's family; the Independent reports this involved a U.S. Marine with the same name as a defendant. The IndependentLC “The Court has already found that information appearing in filed documents was used by online observers to threaten and dox a nonparty’s family”“The Marine and his family were harassed as a result.” Read at The Independent ↗ Right · 1The defence said the case is "in its infancy" and that several of the accused have not yet had lawyers appear. New York PostR ““The case is in its infancy,” the defendant’s camp said” Read at New York Post ↗
Left · 1Giuffra responded that the request is an attempt "to silence me and Ms. Doe because we have been so successful in rebutting their ineffectual attempts to undermine her story," adding "Truth always wins out." The IndependentLC “to silence me and Ms. Doe because we have been so successful in rebutting their ineffectual attempts to undermine her story.”““Truth always wins out,” Giuffra told the New York Post.” Read at The Independent ↗ Mixed · 2The underlying lawsuit was filed last month by a woman identified as Jane Doe, who alleges that seven members of Cornell's Chi Phi fraternity sexually assaulted her in October 2024 and accuses the university of a cover-up; the Post says Sarabia is accused of forcibly kissing her and snorting ketamine off her body. The IndependentLC “alleging that she was sexually assaulted by seven members of Cornell’s Chi Phi fraternity in October 2024, accusing the university of a cover-up” Read at The Independent ↗ New York PostR “accused of forcibly kissing the unnamed woman and snorting ketamine off her naked body” Read at New York Post ↗ Left · 1None of the men has been criminally charged and all have denied wrongdoing; two were expelled and others suspended after a months-long university investigation, according to the Independent. The IndependentLC “None of the men have been criminally charged, and all have denied wrongdoing.”“Two of the men were expelled and others were suspended.” Read at The Independent ↗
Left · 1Cornell president Michael Kotlikoff said last week in a video message that he supports an independent review of the school's handling of the case, with details to come from the Board of Trustees, and backed Gov. Kathy Hochul's decision to hand the criminal investigation to the state attorney general. The IndependentLC “Kotlikoff reaffirmed his commitment to supporting an independent review of Cornell's handling of the case”“He also showed support for New York Governor Kathy Hochul’s decision to turn the criminal investigation over to the state attorney general.” Read at The Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Independent reports the request as one development in a wider scandal, adding context on doxing, the university's response and the Cornell president's statement.
- Emphasis
- Doxing of a mistakenly named Marine's family, widespread social media circulation of the accused's names, Kotlikoff's video message and the independent review.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include the Post's detail of the specific allegations against Sarabia or that several defendants lack counsel.
- Charged language
- “media blast”“orchestrated campaign”
- For example
-
“Her attorney has given dozens of media interviews since filing the lawsuit, which attorneys for some of the accused want to stop.” — The Independent
““My heart aches when I think of what she experienced,”” — The Independent
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- The New York Post leads with the defence demand and its jury-taint argument, in a short, tabloid-style report on the "frat bros" and an "explosive rape case".
- Emphasis
- Defence arguments about the "media tour", the more than two dozen statements cited, and Sarabia's alleged conduct.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Omits Giuffra's response, the doxing concern, and the university's and president's response.
- Charged language
- “frat bros”“explosive rape case”“media tour”“slap a gag order”
- For example
-
“claiming his “media tour’’ over the explosive rape case could sway potential jurors.” — New York Post
“Sarabia is one of seven fraternity brothers at Cornell University accused in the alleged drugging and gang-rape” — New York Post
What every side reports
- A lawyer for one of the Cornell 7 asked a Manhattan judge for a gag order on Jane Doe's attorney Thomas Giuffra.
- The filing quotes that Giuffra has been "trying his case in the media since filing the lawsuit".
- Seven fraternity members are accused in Jane Doe's lawsuit.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Giuffra's media activity is a deliberate campaign justifying a gag order
- Left
- The Independent relays Knox's claim of an "orchestrated campaign" and Giuffra's reply that the request aims to silence him and Doe.
- Right
- The Post relays only the defence view that the "media tour" threatens an impartial jury.
-
Date of the filing
- Left
- The Independent says Knox made the filing on Oct. 9.
- Right
- The Post says the papers were filed Monday (Oct. 12).
Thomas Giuffra person
Giuffra says the gag request is an attempt to silence him and his client because they have successfully rebutted the defence, and that "Truth always wins out."
“to silence me and Ms. Doe because we have been so successful in rebutting their ineffectual attempts to undermine her story.” — The Independent
Cornell 7 other
Through Sarabia's lawyers, the defence says the plaintiff's media campaign risks prejudicing jurors and defendants; all the accused have denied wrongdoing and none is criminally charged.
“could blow any chance of an impartial jury” — New York Post
“None of the men have been criminally charged, and all have denied wrongdoing.” — The Independent
Chi Phi organisation
The Chi Phi fraternity was suspended after Doe's report to Cornell police, according to the Independent.
“triggering the suspension of the Chi Phi fraternity and prompting a months-long investigation” — The Independent
Left1 article
-
One of the ‘Cornell 7’ wants a gag order to limit what can be said publicly about alleged gang-rape
Neutral Reports the filing and Giuffra's rebuttal alongside doxing concerns and Cornell's institutional response.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right1 article
-
‘Cornell 7’ lawyer demands gag order on accuser’s attorney over crucial issue
Mixed Short report relaying the defence's jury-prejudice argument in colloquial language, without Giuffra's reply.
- 12 Oct 17:23 First New York PostR ‘Cornell 7’ lawyer demands gag order on accuser’s attorney over crucial issue
- 12 Oct 21:39 +4h 17m The IndependentLC One of the ‘Cornell 7’ wants a gag order to limit what can be said publicly about alleged gang-rape
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…