CSIRO study counts 2.8 million basketwork eels gathering at Patience Seamount off Tasmania
A CSIRO-led study estimates about 2.8 million basketwork eels gather for most of each year at Patience Seamount off Tasmania, apparently to spawn. Why they choose this site is unknown.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2A CSIRO-led study published in Royal Society Open Science estimates that about 2.8 million basketwork eels (Diastobranchus capensis) gather at a ridge next to Patience Seamount in the Huon Marine Park, south of Tasmania. ABC News (Australia)LC “About 2.8 million basketwork eels (Diastobranchus capensis) — or 3.5 tonnes' worth — make the pilgrimage to a site next to Patience Seamount in the Huon Marine Park” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ MetroLC “published today in Royal Society Open Science, counted them for the first time.” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 2ABC News gives the aggregation's weight as 3.5 tonnes; Metro says the eels weigh nearly 3.5 million kilograms, a figure that does not match ABC's. ABC News (Australia)LC “or 3.5 tonnes' worth” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ MetroLC “which weigh nearly 3.5million kilograms” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 1Lead author Ben Scoulding, a CSIRO fisheries acoustics researcher, said it is the only known aggregation of any deep-sea eel anywhere, and ABC reports it as the only known spawning site globally for purely oceanic eels. ABC News (Australia)LC “"It's the only known aggregation of … any deep-sea eel anywhere."”“The annual aggregation is the only known spawning site globally for purely oceanic eels.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
Left · 1Fishers have known the site as "Eel Hill" because they caught the eels as bycatch while targeting orange roughy, and CSIRO confirmed the eels' presence with a camera in the mid-2000s. ABC News (Australia)LC “Dr Scoulding said fishers nicknamed the site "Eel Hill" as they regularly caught the species as bycatch while targeting orange roughy”“"Then CSIRO conducted some work on the RV Southern Surveyor in the mid 2000s and put a camera down … to confirm the presence of the eels."” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Left · 2Surveys between 2023 and 2025 used hydro-acoustic sonar from the research ship RV Investigator, which Scoulding called a "really expensive scientific fish finder", along with camera surveys; the eels reflect sound strongly because of their large swim bladders. ABC News (Australia)LC “These included hydro-acoustic surveys, which Dr Scoulding described as a "really expensive scientific fish finder", from Australia's flagship ocean science ship the RV Investigator.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ MetroLC “called a hydro-acoustic survey, to ping sound waves down below.” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 2The researchers estimated the aggregation lies at about 1,000 metres depth and covers roughly 2 by 3 kilometres, densest at its centre where Scoulding said the eels are "almost touching each other". ABC News (Australia)LC “the researchers estimated the eel aggregation was about 1,000 metres deep and covered an area of about 2 by 3 kilometres.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ MetroLC “Dr Scoulding said the ball was about 1,000 metres deep and covered an area about two by three kilometres wide.” Read at Metro ↗
Left · 2Scoulding said the aggregation persists "for the majority of the year". ABC says the eels start gathering in December, peak from May to August and are gone by October, while Metro says the peak is March to May before they disperse in October. ABC News (Australia)LC “The eels start gathering at Patience Seamount in December every year.”“numbers then peaked around May to August before the eels disappeared in October.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ MetroLC “peaking from March to May before dispersing in October.” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 2The researchers caught several eels and all had empty stomachs. ABC reports one female had already spawned and the others were close to spawning, while Metro says most females were close to laying eggs. Metro adds that earlier catches found males and females in peak spawning condition, and that a 2015 estimate was tens of thousands of eels. ABC News (Australia)LC “Dr Scoulding said one female had spawned and all the others were close to spawning.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ MetroLC “with most of the females close to laying eggs, called spawning.”“which was 10s of thousands of eels in April that year.” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 1Why the eels choose Patience, one of 120 seamounts in the marine park, is unknown. Further research is looking at how eel populations around Australia and New Zealand are connected, and where the eels come from and their offspring go. ABC News (Australia)LC “"It's one of 120 seamounts within Huon Marine Park … so it's quite unique that all the eels chose Patience to aggregate at," Dr Scoulding said.”“Research is ongoing into the connectivity of basketwork eel populations around Australia and New Zealand” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
Left · 2The species is listed as vulnerable to extinction, partly because it is caught as bycatch in orange roughy fisheries, and populations on a New Zealand slope have declined 85 per cent in 40 years. Whether Patience Seamount has seen similar declines is unclear. ABC News (Australia)LC “Basketwork eels are considered vulnerable to extinction on a global list of threatened species.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ MetroLC “Populations of the eel on the slopes in New Zealand have declined 85% in the past 40 years” Read at Metro ↗ Left · 1Parks Australia's Shaun Barclay said the study gives a baseline for measuring future change and that Patience Seamount was protected from bottom trawling through a new management plan last year. ABC News (Australia)LC “Parks Australia island and marine parks branch head Shaun Barclay said the new study helped give a baseline for measuring future change for the eels.”“Mr Barclay said Patience Seamount was protected from the fishing practice of bottom trawling through a new management plan last year.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- ABC News (Australia) runs a science report built on Scoulding's interview, covering the method, the conservation context and park management. Metro (UK) retells it as a quirky animal story with a jokey, sexualised headline and wording.
- Emphasis
- ABC stresses the survey method, uniqueness of the site and conservation baseline; Metro stresses the spectacle of the 'ball' and the mating, with the IUCN threat status and the 2015 comparison.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Metro leaves out the Parks Australia comment and bottom-trawling protection, and its weight and peak-season figures differ from ABC's. ABC leaves out the 2015 estimate.
- Charged language
- “having an orgy”“Giant ball”
- For example
-
“Millions of eels gather like clockwork each year to make out along a ridge at the bottom of a deep-sea mountain off Tasmania.” — ABC News (Australia)
“For almost 10 months straight every year, millions of eels gather at a deep-sea mountain near Australia to have an orgy.” — Metro
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- About 2.8 million basketwork eels gather at Patience Seamount off Tasmania
- The CSIRO-led study was published in Royal Society Open Science, with surveys in 2023-2025
- The aggregation is about 1,000 metres deep and 2 by 3 km
- The sampled eels had empty stomachs
- New Zealand populations of the eel have declined 85% in 40 years
Where accounts differ
-
Weight of the eels
- Left
- ABC says 3.5 tonnes; Metro says nearly 3.5 million kilograms.
-
Peak season
- Left
- ABC says May to August; Metro says March to May.
-
Spawning condition of sampled eels
- Left
- ABC says one female had spawned and the rest were close to spawning; Metro says most females were close to laying eggs.
CSIRO organisation
CSIRO researchers, led by Ben Scoulding, present the count as the first of a unique spawning aggregation, while saying why the eels choose Patience is unknown.
“Why exactly the eels chose to gather at Patience specifically was unknown.” — ABC News (Australia)
“published today in Royal Society Open Science, counted them for the first time.” — Metro
Left2 articles
-
Giant ball of 2.8 million eels gathers off Tasmania's coast to spawn
Neutral Explanatory science report centred on the study's method, the site's uniqueness and conservation protection.
-
MetroLC ·
A giant ball of 2,800,000 eels is having an orgy off the coast of Australia
Mixed Light-hearted retelling of the ABC-reported study with innuendo, though it includes the threatened status.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 28 Oct 00:02 First ABC News (Australia)LC Giant ball of 2.8 million eels gathers off Tasmania's coast to spawn
- 28 Oct 12:36 +12h 35m MetroLC A giant ball of 2,800,000 eels is having an orgy off the coast of Australia
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…