Dalby residents divided over proposed $31bn Anthropic-linked datacentre in Western Downs
A proposed datacentre of about $31–32bn near Dalby, Queensland, to be used by Anthropic, has drawn a petition of more than 21,000 signatures and mixed local views. The state says it will take over assessment of datacentre applications from councils.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2A proposed datacentre, put at $31bn by the Guardian and $32bn by ABC News, is planned near Dalby in Queensland's Western Downs, about 180km west of Brisbane, and has drawn a mixed reaction from residents. The GuardianLC “If built, Australia’s largest datacentre would be about 15 minutes’ drive away from Kanowski’s home, outside Kogan, near Dalby, about 180km west of Brisbane.” Read at The Guardian ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “worried about the future now that a $32 billion data centre is proposed just out of town.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Left · 2The Guardian reports the project would sit on a 725-hectare plot now occupied by a 24,000-head feedlot and would power Anthropic's Claude model; ABC reports Anthropic has signed a deal to use the first of four buildings at the site even though no approvals have been issued. The GuardianLC “Anthropic’s project is to be built on a 725-hectare plot of land now occupied by a 24,000 head feedlot, surrounded by gas wells.” Read at The Guardian ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “Anthropic has signed a deal in Australia to use the first of four buildings at the proposed hyperscale facility, well before it has received any approvals.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Left · 1Developer Zerra DC, which is Singapore-based, says the cooling system would be far less water-intensive than most datacentres, with demand about equal to an average shopping centre. The Guardian says the site would need a peak power capacity of 2.16GW, about a quarter of total state energy demand, and would create about 1,400 long-term jobs, according to the company. The GuardianLC “its cooling system will be far less water intensive than most existing datacentres’, generating about the same demand as an average shopping centre.”“The Western Downs datacentre will require a peak power capacity equal to about a quarter of total state energy demand, 2.16GW.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Left · 2A petition opposing the Western Downs Digital Park had more than 21,000 signatures according to ABC, which says that is more than any other open Queensland petition. The Guardian puts it at more than 21,500, mostly from the area, according to co-launcher Mordechai Winters. ABC News (Australia)LC “A petition to parliament opposing the Western Downs Digital Park has gained more than 21,000 signatures — more than any petition currently open in Queensland.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ The GuardianLC “A petition that Winters helped to launch has been signed by more than 21,500 people – mostly from the area – in just a few weeks, he says.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 2Opponents draw on the area's coal seam gas history. Denver Kanowski, who has lived in the area for 70 years, called the project "shortsighted stupidity", and Cecil Plains farmer Liza Balmain sees "huge similarities" with the gas era. Antiques dealer Ross Thornton fears a repeat of the "boom-bust cycle" and wants a public meeting, saying people are "scared of the unknown". The GuardianLC ““This is the power of money and the power of greed and shortsighted stupidity,” Kanowski says.”“says she can see “huge similarities” between the coal seam gas era and the proposed datacentre.” Read at The Guardian ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “"It caused a boom-bust cycle and no-one wants that,"” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ Left · 2Other voices are more mixed. Businessman Doug Machin said "you never knock back development" but doubted the 1,500 construction workers could be found locally. Jo Sheppard, chief executive of Toowoomba and Surat Basin Enterprise, said most residents had not made up their minds and called it "a once in a generation opportunity", while stressing the need for social licence. ABC News (Australia)LC “"You never knock back development," he said, then added it would be challenging to source the suggested 1,500 jobs required to build the data centre.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ The GuardianLC “most residents of the area had not yet made up their minds about the project, but that it was important for the developer to maintain their social license.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Left · 2Resident Angela Prenzler doubted plans to rely mainly on rain and recycled water, saying the area is "always in drought". Researcher Dr Shay Dougall, who studied the gas industry's impact, urged up-front risk assessment and a consequential role for affected people. The Environmental Defenders Office reports a 250% rise in datacentre queries to its legal advice line since January and calls for a moratorium. ABC News (Australia)LC “"We are always in drought," Ms Penzler said.”“to try and require these sorts of projects to have up-front risk assessment,” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ The GuardianLC “the group had seen a 250% increase in queries about datacentres to the service’s free legal advice line since January.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 2The Queensland government said it will become the "responsible assessor and coordinator" of datacentre applications instead of local councils, under a planning framework not yet released that would mirror its renewable energy reforms. A spokesperson for planning minister Jarrod Bleijie said any deals must have the backing of councils and communities. ABC News (Australia)LC “The Queensland government confirmed it will be taking over from local governments as the "responsible assessor and coordinator" of data centre applications in a yet to be released planning framework.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗ The GuardianLC ““Any deals done must be with the backing of councils and communities,” a spokesperson for planning minister, Jarrod Bleijie, says.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 2Western Downs Mayor Andrew Smith had understood the project would stay with the council, which has about 35,452 residents, and did not endorse or oppose it. ABC reports Zerra DC has applied for "prescribed project" status, which would let the coordinator-general step in and fast-track approvals. Premier David Crisafulli told parliament the project could bring good jobs and lower power bills, and that the state would help the council assess it. The GuardianLC “Smith says the planning couldn’t be rushed – and was careful not to endorse or oppose the project.”““They see the same opportunity I do, and that opportunity is to make sure that there are jobs, very good jobs in regional areas” Read at The Guardian ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “has applied for "prescribed project" status, which means Queensland's coordinator-general could step in and fast-track approvals” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
Left · 2Anthropic wants to begin using the centre as early as next year. Unlike New South Wales and Victoria, Queensland has no dedicated datacentre planning pathway. The GuardianLC “Anthropic wants to start using the centre as early as next year.” Read at The Guardian ↗ ABC News (Australia)LC “Unlike New South Wales and Victoria, Queensland has no dedicated data centre planning pathway.” Read at ABC News (Australia) ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets, each rated lean left, centre on local residents' unease and compare the project with the coal seam gas boom and bust. The Guardian leads with strongly worded opposition and global AI concerns; ABC leads with residents' fears of being unable to stop a fast-tracked approval.
- Emphasis
- Petition size, water and energy demand, loss of local say, state takeover of planning, and expert warnings from the Environmental Defenders Office and a gas-industry researcher.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither includes any comment from Anthropic or Zerra DC beyond company claims on water and jobs. Few supporters are quoted; the Guardian carries the mayor's positive view of the gas industry and the premier's case.
- Charged language
- “shortsighted stupidity”“money-crazed idiots”“steamrolled”“new frontier”
- For example
-
““This is the power of money and the power of greed and shortsighted stupidity,” Kanowski says.” — The Guardian
“fears residents will be steamrolled in the push to embrace the artificial intelligence boom.” — ABC News (Australia)
““I would say the datacentre is the new frontier,” she says.” — The Guardian
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- The proposed datacentre is near Dalby in the Western Downs, Queensland, and Anthropic is linked to it.
- Developer Zerra DC is Singapore-based.
- A petition against the project has more than 21,000 signatures.
- The Queensland government will take over assessment of datacentre applications from councils.
- Residents draw comparisons with the coal seam gas boom and bust.
Where accounts differ
-
Project cost and jobs
- Left
- The Guardian says $31bn and about 1,400 long-term jobs; ABC says $32bn and about 1,500 jobs needed to build it.
-
Who will assess the project
- Left
- The Guardian reports the mayor expected it to stay with council before the state announced it was taking over datacentre assessment; ABC says the mayor was assured it would stay with council but it may be out of its hands, since the developer applied for prescribed project status.
Anthropic organisation
Has signed a deal to use the first of four buildings at the proposed site and wants to start using the centre as early as next year; no approvals have been issued. No comment from the company is quoted.
“Anthropic has signed a deal in Australia to use the first of four buildings at the proposed hyperscale facility, well before it has received any approvals.” — ABC News (Australia)
“Anthropic wants to start using the centre as early as next year.” — The Guardian
Western Downs place
The Western Downs council mayor says the region's capacity to assess large developments is strong and the council has had good conversations with the state, but is careful not to endorse or oppose the project.
“"We've had good conversations with the state. We're confident in our ability to assess large scale development," he said.” — ABC News (Australia)
“Smith says the planning couldn’t be rushed – and was careful not to endorse or oppose the project.” — The Guardian
UK and Ireland1 outlet
The Guardian's Australian edition adds the global context of AI datacentre backlash in the US and uses a character-led rural portrait.
“Three-quarters of Americans now oppose them, and more than 500 counties have imposed a ban.” — The Guardian
The Guardian
Oceania1 outlet
ABC focuses on the planning process, fast-tracking and local calls for information and consultation.
“Unlike New South Wales and Victoria, Queensland has no dedicated data centre planning pathway.” — ABC News (Australia)
ABC News (Australia)
Left2 articles
-
Sympathetic Features rural residents' scepticism and the gas-boom history, with the premier's and local business leaders' optimism as counterweight.

-
Residents fear there is no stopping $32b hyperscale data centre
Mixed Presents residents worried about being steamrolled and left uninformed, alongside a conflicted businessman and the government's planning rationale.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 4 Oct 15:00 First The GuardianLC Rural Queenslanders have seen gas projects come and go – but a 725-hectare datacentre poses a whole new level of ‘stupidity’
- 4 Oct 21:33 +6h 33m ABC News (Australia)LC Residents fear there is no stopping $32b hyperscale data centre
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.