Lammy urges Labour to fight next election on a pledge to rejoin the EU
Former deputy prime minister David Lammy wrote in the Times that Labour under Andy Burnham should go into the next election committed to rejoining the EU. The prime minister has said Labour will keep its manifesto red lines and will set out options later this year.
Updated (version 2). New coverage since the last version from BBC News.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2David Lammy, the former foreign secretary who also served as deputy prime minister under Keir Starmer, has said Labour should fight the next general election on a commitment to rejoin the EU. Daily MirrorL “Labour should fight the next general election on a commitment to rejoin the EU, David Lammy has said.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ The GuardianLC “David Lammy has urged Andy Burnham to campaign on a promise to rejoin the EU at the next election.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 2Writing in the Times, Lammy said Burnham's Labour conference speech in Liverpool had not only ignited a debate about joining the EU but "blew the door wide open", and that forming the next government would give Labour the mandate to begin formal negotiations. Daily MirrorL “Forming the next government would give it the mandate to begin formal negotiations.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ The GuardianLC ““Forming the next government would give it the mandate to begin formal negotiations.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 1Lammy proposed that any deal be put to the public against the status quo, so that, unlike in the last referendum, voters would choose between two clearly defined options. The GuardianLC “Unlike the last referendum, the public should have the opportunity to decide between two clearly defined choices.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Centre · 1Speaking on Radio 4's Today programme, Lammy told the BBC his preference was for Labour to advocate rejoining at the next election, negotiate a deal and then give the public a vote on it. BBC NewsN “He said his preference would be for Labour to advocate rejoining at the next election, then negotiating a deal to return to the EU and giving the public a vote on whether to accept it.” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1He said returning to the customs union would not deliver "enough" growth and that rejoining the single market from the outside was "not a runner", since it would mean applying EU law without a say on its content. BBC NewsN “Returning to the bloc's customs union, in which EU member states charge the same taxes on imported goods, would not deliver "enough" economic growth, he said.”“He added that rejoining Europe's single market from the outside was "not a runner"” Read at BBC News ↗ Centre · 1Lammy argued the UK could rejoin while staying outside the Schengen travel zone and without adopting the euro, and appeared to concede that its EU budget rebate could become less generous, saying a "different formula" for contributions would be "up for negotiation". BBC NewsN “Lammy, who is also a former foreign secretary, argued the UK would be able to rejoin the EU whilst staying outside the passport-free Schengen travel zone and without committing to adopt the euro.”“a "different formula" for financial contributions would be "up for negotiation"” Read at BBC News ↗
Left · 1According to the Daily Mirror, Lammy also blamed Brexit for costing Britain influence and said that putting the issue on the ballot paper would expose Reform's Nigel Farage for "what he is", a defender of "a failed low-growth orthodoxy". Daily MirrorL “said putting the issue on the ballot paper at the next election would also expose Reform’s Nigel Farage for “what he is” and a defender of “a failed low-growth orthodoxy”.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 1On BBC Radio 4's Today programme, Lammy suggested they had pushed Starmer towards the end of Starmer's premiership to rip up Labour's red lines on Brexit, saying Starmer probably felt unable to get that past some Cabinet members and "was weakened at that point". Daily MirrorL “Mr Lammy suggested he had pushed Mr Starmer towards the end of his premiership to rip up Labour’s red Brexit lines.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Centre · 1The BBC reported that Lammy argued Burnham, a former mayor from the north of England, was "uniquely placed" to convince the public to reverse the decision to leave. BBC NewsN “Lammy argued the prime minister's status as a former mayor from the north of England meant he was "uniquely placed" to convince the public of the need to reverse the decision to leave.” Read at BBC News ↗
Left · 1Lammy also said they would not put their name forward for Mayor of London in the coming months if Sadiq Khan decides to stand down, citing a love of national politics, being MP for Tottenham and family. Daily MirrorL “I will not be putting my name forward in the coming months if he decides to stand down.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 2Burnham, now prime minister, promised in the September conference speech to set out options for a future relationship with Europe around the time of a major UK-EU summit in Brussels on Friday. Daily MirrorL “promising to set out options for a future relationship with Europe. He suggested this could come around the time of a major UK-EU summit in Brussels on Friday.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ The GuardianLC “The prime minister promised in his Labour conference speech in September that he would lay out different options to the country around the time of the November summit.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Centre · 1The summit on Friday is where both sides hope to unveil new agreements on food, youth visas and re-linking British industry to the EU's carbon trading regime; Burnham inherited those negotiations from Starmer, who began the talks last year. BBC NewsN “where both sides hope to unveil new agreements on food, youth visas and re-linking British industry to the EU's carbon trading regime.”“The prime minister inherited negotiations on those deals from his predecessor Sir Keir Starmer, who kicked off talks on the agreements last year.” Read at BBC News ↗
Left · 2That is now expected around the time of Burnham's 10-year plan for Britain, due before Christmas; Burnham denied changing the timeframe, saying the next phase would be set out next month, and rejected the suggestion that the debate is toxic. Daily MirrorL “But it is now expected around the time of his 10-year plan for Britain, which is expected before Christmas .” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ The GuardianLC “But I don’t agree with you at all, actually, that it’s a toxic debate.”” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 2Burnham has repeated a pledge to stick to the 2024 Labour manifesto's red lines, which rule out returning to the customs union, single market or free movement, before a general election. The GuardianLC “He repeated his pledge to stick to the 2024 Labour manifesto’s red lines – which rule out returning to the customs union, single market or free movement” Read at The Guardian ↗ Daily MirrorL “including no return to the bloc’s single market or customs union” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Centre · 1The BBC said Burnham has held out the possibility that he could ask to rejoin at some stage, and that his wider debate has been welcomed by some in his party but has led critics to accuse him of betraying the 2016 referendum result. BBC NewsN “The prime minister has held out the possibility he could ask to rejoin at some stage, whilst ruling out major changes before the next election.”“seen him accused by critics of betraying the result of the 2016 decision to leave.” Read at BBC News ↗
Centre · 1The BBC added that Labour's 2024 manifesto committed to "make Brexit work", and that any move away from the red lines would set up a major dividing line with the Conservatives and Reform UK at the next election. BBC NewsN “Labour's 2024 election manifesto committed the party to "make Brexit work" whilst ruling out rejoining either its customs union or single market.”“Any move away from those red lines by Burnham would set up a huge dividing line with the Conservatives and Reform UK at the next election.” Read at BBC News ↗ Left · 2Burnham also criticised Boris Johnson, who with David Cameron has warned against closer ties, saying Johnson left a bad Brexit deal and that Britain should build a better, more constructive relationship with its biggest market. Daily MirrorL “He [Johnson] left us with a bad Brexit deal that has led to Britain losing more than its gained” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ The GuardianLC “who alongside David Cameron has cautioned him against returning to the bloc.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 1Lammy's intervention follows former chancellor Rachel Reeves, who earlier this month said Brexit has made the UK "poorer, weaker and less secure" and welcomed Burnham's leadership on the debate. Daily MirrorL “Brexit has made us poorer, weaker and less secure.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Left · 1Separately, the Guardian (carrying Press Association copy) reports that the youth guarantee scheme, part of the reset talks with the EU, would be open only to British citizens, according to Burnham, amid concerns that a mobility scheme to be agreed at the summit could cut into support for young Britons. The GuardianLC “the youth guarantee scheme to get young people into work, which has formed part of the reset negotiations with the EU, would only be open to British citizens.” Read at The Guardian ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets lead on Lammy's Times intervention as a push for Burnham's Labour to commit to rejoining the EU. The Mirror adds the pledge to 'expose' Farage and Lammy's comments on Starmer and the London mayoralty. The Guardian (PA copy) sets it against the Brussels summit and Burnham's timeline.
- Emphasis
- The Mirror stresses Lammy's anti-Brexit argument, Reeves's similar comments and Burnham's attack on Boris Johnson. The Guardian stresses the summit, the timeline row and the youth guarantee scheme.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Neither carries a response from Labour opponents, Reform or pro-Brexit voices beyond Johnson and Cameron's warnings. The Guardian's PA copy omits Lammy's Farage remarks and the mayoral comments. The Mirror omits the youth guarantee row. Neither gives Lammy's reasoning on the customs union, single market, Schengen, euro or rebate reported by the BBC.
- Charged language
- “blew the door wide open”“expose”“a failed low-growth orthodoxy”
- For example
-
“The ex-Foreign Secretary said putting the issue on the ballot paper at the next election would also expose Reform’s Nigel Farage for “what he is”” — Daily Mirror
“His intervention comes as Burnham prepares for a major UK-EU summit in Brussels amid renewed scrutiny over Britain’s relationship with the bloc.” — The Guardian
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- The BBC reports Lammy's call as a policy argument, centred on what rejoining would involve (customs union, single market, Schengen, euro, rebate) and sets it against Burnham's wider debate and the coming summit.
- Emphasis
- Lammy's reasoning on membership options and his admission that the rebate could shrink; the summit deals; criticism of Burnham from those who say he is betraying the 2016 result; the dividing line with the Conservatives and Reform.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not carry Lammy's remarks on Farage or the London mayoralty, Reeves's comments, or Burnham's criticism of Boris Johnson.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Lammy wrote in the Times that Labour should go into the next election clear that its intention is to rejoin the EU.
- Burnham's Liverpool conference speech in September reopened the debate on Europe.
- A major UK-EU summit is due in Brussels on Friday.
- Burnham has pledged to stick to the 2024 manifesto red lines before the next election.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether Burnham has delayed the Europe options timeline
- Left
- The Guardian (PA) says Burnham appeared to prolong the timeline, but Burnham denied changing it. The Mirror says the options are now expected with the 10-year plan, not around the summit.
-
Labour should go into the next general election committed to rejoining the EU
Supported- Supports 3
- Daily Mirror, The Guardian, BBC News
-
Burnham has committed to keep Labour's manifesto red lines before the next election
Reported- Reports 3
- Daily Mirror, The Guardian, BBC News
-
Burnham will set out options for the UK's long-term EU relationship around the 10-year plan, before Christmas
Reported- Reports 3
- Daily Mirror, The Guardian, BBC News
David Lammy person
Argues Labour should enter the next election clear it intends to rejoin the EU, with a mandate to negotiate and a later vote on the deal against the status quo. Says this would expose Farage.
““Burnham’s Labour should go into the next election clear that its intention is to rejoin the EU,” Lammy wrote in the Times.” — The Guardian
“would also expose Reform’s Nigel Farage for “what he is”” — Daily Mirror
Andy Burnham person
Says they are negotiating improvements to the Brexit deal, will set out options later this year with the 10-year plan, and will keep the manifesto red lines before the election. Rejects the view that the debate is toxic and criticises Boris Johnson's Brexit deal.
““I’m in a negotiation about improving the Brexit deal. That’s what I’m doing this week.” — The Guardian
“He [Johnson] left us with a bad Brexit deal that has led to Britain losing more than its gained” — Daily Mirror
Nigel Farage person
Lammy portrays the Reform leader as a defender of a failed low-growth orthodoxy; no response from Farage is reported.
“a defender of “a failed low-growth orthodoxy”” — Daily Mirror
Left2 articles
-
Labour should commit to rejoin the EU and 'expose' Nigel Farage, says David Lammy
Sympathetic Presents Lammy's call as a bold case against Brexit, alongside supportive remarks from Reeves and Burnham's rebuke of Johnson.

-
The GuardianLC · · via PA
David Lammy urges Andy Burnham to campaign on rejoining EU at next election
Neutral PA copy reporting Lammy's call in the context of the Brussels summit, Burnham's timeline and the youth guarantee debate.

Centre1 article
-
Lammy urges Burnham take UK back into the EU
Neutral Explains Lammy's proposal and its policy trade-offs, with context on the summit and the political risk for Burnham.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 18 Nov 08:20 First Daily MirrorL Labour should commit to rejoin the EU and 'expose' Nigel Farage, says David Lammy
- 18 Nov 08:42 +23m The GuardianLC David Lammy urges Andy Burnham to campaign on rejoining EU at next election via PA
- 18 Nov 09:03 +43m BBC NewsN Lammy urges Burnham take UK back into the EU
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…