Skip to content
Bramble

Sport

Dead Melbourne Cup runner So You Are found in Sydney skip bin

The body of Melbourne Cup runner So You Are, who died of colic, was found in a skip bin at Lucas Heights, Sydney. The horse's trainer, the equine hospital and Racing NSW all called the handling unacceptable, and investigations are under way.

7 outlets · 2L · 3C · 2R First reported Account updated

Updated (version 3). New coverage since the last version from Breitbart, CBS News, GB News.

Image: ABC News (Australia)
Image: BBC News
Image: GB News
Image: CNA
Image: CBS News
Image: Breitbart
Image: Gulf News

1 / 7

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2The body of racehorse So You Are, who finished eighth in this year's Melbourne Cup, was found in an industrial skip bin at Lucas Heights on the outskirts of Sydney. Left · 1Sydney man Gregg Jowett posted a video on social media after finding a horse in the skip that appeared to share So You Are's markings, and REC Equine Specialists confirmed it was the horse. Mixed · 2The five-year-old had been euthanised on Monday after a bout of severe colic.

Left · 1So You Are had won four times in the spring, including Group 3 races at Rosehill, Randwick and the Bendigo Cup, before finishing eighth in the Melbourne Cup, which Point of Law won. Mixed · 2Trainer Bjorn Baker said he was deeply distressed by the handling of the remains, that the horse deserved respect and dignity, and that he expected a full explanation from REC Equine Specialists, which he understood was investigating. Left · 1Baker also said his thoughts were with the Ramsey family, the owners, and with his staff, for whom this compounded an already devastating loss.

Centre · 1REC Equine Specialists apologised, saying the horse was collected by its contracted service provider and taken to a licensed landfill, and should have been promptly and respectfully buried; it called what happened unacceptable and disrespectful. Centre · 2The hospital said it did not carry out the burial itself but chose the provider and arrangements and takes full responsibility, has apologised personally to the owners and trainer, has stopped using the contractor, and is reviewing its processes for how horses are handled after leaving its facility. Centre · 1Racing NSW said the horse was awaiting burial when the video was recorded, called the way the body was left distressing and completely unacceptable, and noted that NSW Department of Primary Industries guidelines prefer a licensed landfill for animals euthanised with chemicals, but that burial should have been timely and respectful.

Centre · 1Racing NSW has an ongoing investigation and said it will take appropriate action if any wrongdoing is found. Centre · 2Racing NSW said a preliminary investigation found the horse was later properly buried. Centre · 1The video appeared to be filmed at the public Lucas Heights rubbish drop-off and land facility in Sutherland Shire, south of Sydney; the company running the site said the body had been moved to a skip bin in a permitted area, as reported by the ABC according to the BBC.

Left · 1Cleanaway, which runs the Lucas Heights landfill, told the ABC the site is licensed to accept animal carcasses and that the horse arrived in a small tipper truck not permitted on the tipping face for safety reasons, so the carcass was transferred into a skip bin for safe disposal. Left · 1CBS News, citing the Sydney Morning Herald, reported that racing stewards were investigating after a construction worker saw the horse in a dumpster at a licensed waste centre and posted a video on Facebook; it also said the industry guidelines preferring licensed landfill are now under review. Left · 1REC Equine Specialists managing partner Dr Jonathan Lumsden said the hospital should have known exactly how horses were handled after leaving its facility, that its process was not good enough and must change, and that it is working with the contractor and Racing NSW to establish what went wrong.

Left · 1New South Wales politician Emma Hurst called the news heartbreaking but not surprising, saying the horse had been treated as though he were a piece of rubbish and citing eight years of complaints about the racing industry. Centre · 2Racing NSW said the horse received urgent treatment but could not be saved and was euthanised under anaesthesia; Point of Law, the Cup winner, was previously owned by King Charles III.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left2 outlets

Framing
ABC broke the story with the discovery and the finder's video; CBS (US) followed with a fuller account built on ABC and Sydney Morning Herald reporting, giving the hospital's apology, Cleanaway's explanation, Racing NSW's response and a politician's criticism of the racing industry.
Emphasis
Institutional accountability: the hospital's admission of responsibility, regulator investigation and review of guidelines, and Emma Hurst's broader criticism of racing.
Leaves out or plays down
ABC's early report lacks the hospital's apology and Racing NSW's response; CBS does not report the preliminary finding that the horse was later properly buried.
Charged language
“dumpster”“treated as though he is nothing more than a piece of rubbish”
For example
“This horse has been treated as though he is nothing more than a piece of rubbish” — CBS News
“We should have known exactly how horses were handled after leaving our hospital, and we did not.” — CBS News

Centre3 outlets

Framing
CNA, BBC and Gulf News centre on institutional responses: Baker's demand for an explanation, the hospital's apology and responsibility, and Racing NSW's condemnation. Gulf News headlines 'Outrage' and hedges with 'reportedly'; BBC adds the landfill operator's account via ABC.
Emphasis
Apology and responsibility, licensed landfill burial guidance, preliminary finding of later burial, Racing NSW investigation, Point of Law's King Charles III link (BBC, Gulf News).
Leaves out or plays down
CNA omits the finder's name and pre-Cup wins; Gulf News and CNA omit the landfill operator's statement. CNA does not carry the burial finding.
For example
“The remains of a top Australian racehorse that died of colic on Monday were found at a public rubbish tip.” — BBC News

Right2 outlets

Framing
GB News frames it as a distressing discovery of a champion horse 'abandoned' and 'dumped' in a skip, leading with the owner's distress and the trainer's anger, while also relaying the hospital's apology and Racing NSW's finding of a later proper burial.
Emphasis
The horse's spring wins, Point of Law's former owner King Charles, Baker's demand for a full investigation and the hospital's personal apology to owners.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not carry Cleanaway's explanation beyond 'permitted zone', the licensed-landfill guidelines, or Racing NSW's ongoing investigation and warning of action if wrongdoing is found.
Charged language
“abandoned”“dumped”“surrounded by rubbish”“deeply distressed”
For example
“The body of a leading Australian racehorse, So You Are, has been discovered abandoned in a skip bin at a waste facility, surrounded by rubbish.” — GB News
“A preliminary investigation by the body established that So You Are was ultimately given a proper burial.” — GB News

Ask about this story

Loading…