Devon bodies plan for possible rota cuts to home water supply in severe drought
About 60 organisations in Devon are preparing for a possible "Stage 4" severe drought in which household and business water could be supplied on a rota. Council figures have raised concerns about care homes and vulnerable residents.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2Around 60 organisations in Devon, including emergency services and councils, are preparing for the possibility of drought conditions reaching Stage 4, classed as severe, under which water supplies to households and businesses could be temporarily put on a rota basis. Daily MirrorL “Emergency services and local councils are among some 60 organisations in Devon preparing for the possibility of drought conditions reaching Stage 4 – classed as severe.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily MailR “Organisations across the county had met to plan a response for a possible 'stage four severe drought', including district councils and emergency services.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2Devon County Council chief executive Donna Manson disclosed the preparations to the council's cabinet; the Mirror dates this to 10 November. Daily MirrorL “Devon County Council chief executive Donna Manson disclosed the preparations to the council’s cabinet on November 10.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Daily MailR “Donna Manson, the chief executive of Devon County Council, shared the preparations with the council's cabinet last week.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2The Daily Mail reports that affected areas could face three days with water on and three days off, and says the plan was drawn up by South West Water. The Mirror describes the plan as preparation for a possibility and does not give a schedule. Daily MailR “potentially looking at three days with water on and three days off.”“The plan, drawn up by South West Water, decided that tap water in Devon will simply be turned off on a rota basis if severe drought conditions worsen.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Daily MirrorL “It could see water supplies to households and businesses temporarily put on a rota basis.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Left · 1Richard Keeling, the council's cabinet member for adult services, said he had "very real concerns" about what planning for cut-offs would mean, citing care homes and the 33,000 vulnerable people the council has in its care. Daily MirrorL ““I’m worried about all our care homes and the 33,000 vulnerable people we have in our care whom we would have to supply with water.”” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Right · 1Julian Brazil, the Liberal Democrat leader of the council, warned that the plan would be a "disaster for Devon's businesses, vulnerable people and schools", according to the Mail, which cites the Telegraph. Daily MailR “He warned that having to adhere to the plan would be a 'disaster for Devon's businesses, vulnerable people and schools', The Telegraph reported.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Left · 1Deputy council leader Paul Arnott called on South West Water to act immediately on leakage. According to the council, a joint letter from Defra, the Environment Agency and Ofwat said the company had been warned for seven successive years about missing its own leakage reduction forecasts. Daily MirrorL ““South West Water has got to up their game right now on leakage.”“South West Water had been warned for seven successive years about missing its own leakage reduction forecasts and putting supplies at risk.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗
Left · 1Environment Secretary Angela Eagle wrote to the council setting out plans for local authorities and a potential future Mayor of Devon to join a regional committee shaping South West Water's investment decisions. Arnott welcomed this but said the committees are perhaps a year away and would take about two years to show results. Daily MirrorL “outlining plans for local authorities and potentially a future Mayor of Devon to take part in a regional committee helping to shape South West Water’s future investment decisions.”“setting up these committees is maybe a year away and we won’t see what they can do in practice for perhaps two years.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Left · 1Cabinet members agreed to promote water conservation and to encourage vulnerable customers with medical or mobility needs to join South West Water's Priority Services Register. The council said registered customers would get bottled water deliveries if drought restrictions cut off tap supplies. Daily MirrorL “The council said the scheme would ensure bottled water deliveries to those registered if drought restrictions cut off tap supplies.” Read at Daily Mirror ↗ Right · 1The Mail places the plan in a wider crisis. It says ministers were warned last month that reservoirs could run dry within weeks, that Cobra held twice-weekly meetings, and that Devon was among six southern and south-western counties declared in severe drought. It reports Wimbleball reservoir at 13 per cent capacity at the end of October and Ardingly at 17 per cent. Daily MailR “The Government's emergency committee, Cobra, held meetings twice a week for crisis talks about water provision in the south-west of England and Sussex.”“was at 13 per cent capacity at the end of last month” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Right · 1The Mail also reports that South West Water privately told the Government it did not expect Wimbleball to run dry because of preventative measures. It adds that experts say normal rainfall will not offset the drought, and officials say rainfall would need to be 120 per cent higher than average over six months for recovery. Daily MailR “South West Water told the Government privately that it did not anticipate Wimbleball running dry, due to preventative measures it had put in place”“Officials said rainfall would need to be 120 per cent higher than average in the next six months in order to provide a nationwide recovery.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Local-government angle: the Mirror leads with Devon County Council's concerns about care homes and vulnerable residents and puts pressure on South West Water over leaks.
- Emphasis
- Councillors' quotes, the seven years of missed leakage forecasts, Angela Eagle's letter on regional investment committees and the Priority Services Register.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Reservoir levels, the Cobra meetings and the three-days-on, three-days-off schedule.
- Charged language
- “put on rota system”
- For example
-
“Devon County Council has raised concerns over the impact of potential water restrictions on care homes and vulnerable residents” — Daily Mirror
“South West Water has got to up their game right now on leakage.” — Daily Mirror
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Crisis angle: the Mail presents rationing as a settled plan to avoid a 'Day Zero' when reservoirs run dry, and ties it to earlier reports of ministers being secretly warned.
- Emphasis
- Reservoir levels, Cobra, a worst-case scenario of reservoirs at zero within weeks, the possible three-days-on, three-days-off pattern and a Lib Dem leader's reaction.
- Leaves out or plays down
- The council's concerns about care homes and the 33,000 vulnerable people, the leakage warnings to South West Water, and the Priority Services Register and bottled water arrangements.
- Charged language
- “Day Zero”“terrifying”“shockingly”“chaos”
- For example
-
“Households could be about to get a lot thirstier as tap water in one county is set to be rationed under a rota system” — Daily Mail
“How would you cope if your family had tap water switched off for days at a time during a crisis?” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- About 60 organisations in Devon are preparing for a possible Stage 4 severe drought.
- Under that scenario, supplies to households and businesses could be put on a rota basis.
- Devon County Council chief executive Donna Manson told the council's cabinet about the preparations.
- Council figures have raised concerns about vulnerable residents and businesses.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the rota is a contingency or a decided plan
- Left
- The Mirror says organisations are preparing for the possibility of Stage 4 drought, in which supplies could be put on a rota.
- Right
- The Mail says the plan was drawn up by South West Water and that tap water in Devon will be turned off on a rota if severe drought worsens, with a possible three-days-on, three-days-off pattern.
Devon County Council organisation
Council figures voice concern about the effect of cut-offs on care homes and vulnerable people, and the cabinet agreed to promote conservation and the Priority Services Register.
“I have very real concerns about what planning for cut-offs would actually mean.” — Daily Mirror
“Cabinet members agreed to promote water conservation and encourage vulnerable customers” — Daily Mirror
South West Water organisation
The Mirror reports that regulators warned South West Water for seven years about missing leakage targets. The Mail says the company drew up the rota plan and privately told government it did not expect Wimbleball to run dry.
“South West Water had been warned for seven successive years about missing its own leakage reduction forecasts” — Daily Mirror
“South West Water told the Government privately that it did not anticipate Wimbleball running dry” — Daily Mail
Left1 article
-
Plans for home water taps to be 'put on rota system' in drought-hit part of UK
Sympathetic Centres council concerns for vulnerable residents and holds the water company to account on leakage.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Tap water in South West 'to be rationed' in plans to stave off Day Zero - when reservoirs run dry
Alarmist Presents rationing as a settled plan against a looming 'Day Zero', with dramatic wording and a direct question to readers.

-
GB NewsR ·

- 16 Nov 11:03 First Daily MirrorL Plans for home water taps to be 'put on rota system' in drought-hit part of UK
- 18 Nov 02:55 +39h 52m Daily MailR Tap water in South West 'to be rationed' in plans to stave off Day Zero - when reservoirs run dry
- 18 Nov 04:39 +41h 36m GB NewsR Tap water will be turned off on a rota for over a million Britons if severe drought conditions worsen
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…