Skip to content
Bramble

UK

Dry summer leaves Lundy island critically short of water, with visitor caps and evacuation talk

No significant rain has fallen on Lundy, 10 miles off north Devon, since early May. Water use is restricted, visitor numbers are capped and evacuation of the island's 28 residents has been discussed.

2 outlets · 1L · 0C · 1R First reported Account updated
Image: The Guardian
Image: GB News

1 / 2

The story, neutrally told

Mixed · 2Lundy, a three-mile-long island in the Bristol Channel about 10 miles off the coast of north Devon, is critically short of water after a dry summer, with no significant rain since the start of May. Mixed · 2Restrictions have been imposed, visitor numbers limited, and there has been talk of evacuating the island's 28 residents. Mixed · 2The island relies on rainwater and five boreholes. Island manager Matt Scantlebury said that a fortnight before the Guardian's report the tanks were at 13% capacity, enough for about a week, and tonnes of water were being brought over in 1,000-litre containers on the island boat, the MS Oldenburg.

Mixed · 2The campsite has been shut, the toilets at the Marisco Tavern pub closed, and bath plugs removed from holiday lets, which can house up to 110 people. Residents were asked to think twice before flushing, and some catch shower water in a bucket to flush toilets. Mixed · 2Water from Pondsbury, a freshwater pool, was confirmed as good enough quality to use. About 12,000 litres a day have been taken from it, lifting tank levels to 22.5%, but the pond is now starting to run dry and no proper rain is forecast. Mixed · 2A new 300,000-litre water tank has been ordered. A desalination plant has been suggested, but Scantlebury said it would be expensive and would probably need more energy than the island can produce.

Mixed · 2Conservation farmer Tom Carr blames climate change combined with the island's topography, saying rain clouds tend to split as they approach and leave the island dry. Engineer Tristan Howes said conserving water is crucial and that a broken pipe would be a disaster. Left · 1The Guardian also reports that the island is owned by the National Trust and managed by the Landmark Trust, that visitors and residents are taking the restrictions in good spirits, and that the dry summer has benefited butterflies, moths and the Lundy cabbage.

Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.

Left1 outlet

Framing
Feature reporting from the island, mixing the water crisis with a climate-change explanation and upbeat human colour from residents and visitors.
Emphasis
Climate change, resident and visitor voices, adaptation, wildlife winners such as the Lundy cabbage.
Leaves out or plays down
Does not present the evacuation as an imminent risk beyond 'talk of'.
Charged language
“climate emergency”“brink”
For example
“reckons the combination of the climate emergency and the topography of the granite outcrop, which soars out of the Bristol Channel, is the problem” — The Guardian

Centre0 outlets

No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.

Right1 outlet

Framing
Short rewrite of the Guardian report that leads on the evacuation risk and the unflushed toilets.
Emphasis
Evacuation risk, toilet restrictions, cost of desalination.
Leaves out or plays down
Leaves out the National Trust/Landmark Trust ownership, the upbeat resident and visitor accounts, wildlife effects, and Scantlebury's reasons for doubting desalination; attributes the climate quotes to The Guardian rather than reporting independently.
Charged language
“water crisis”“critical water shortage”
For example
“Lundy's population of 28 people face the risk of evacuation, with locals even resorting to not flushing the toilet in an attempt to save water.” — GB News