Drummer Boy, Angel Studios' Revolutionary War musical, gets mixed-to-positive reviews
Angel Studios' Revolutionary War musical "Drummer Boy", co-directed by and starring Joel David Smallbone, opened in US theaters on 6 November. Screen Rant and Variety both find a pleasant but conventional film with handsome visuals and forgettable songs.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2"Drummer Boy", a musical from Angel Studios set at the start of the American Revolutionary War, was released in theaters on Friday 6 November 2026. Screen RantN “Drummer Boy releases in theaters on Friday, November 6.” Read at Screen Rant ↗ VarietyLC “This latest collaboration between Angel Studios and Christian pop group For King + Country” Read at Variety ↗ Mixed · 2Joel David Smallbone of the Christian pop group For King + Country stars as Jeremiah Clem and co-directs with his brother Ben Smallbone. Lucas Leach plays his brother Benjamin. VarietyLC “comprising brothers Luke and Joel David Smallbone, the latter of whom both stars and co-directs with third Smallbone brother Ben” Read at Variety ↗ Screen RantN “Jeremiah (Joel David Smallbone) and Benjamin Clem (Lucas Leach), a pair of brothers who find themselves on opposing sides of the conflict” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Left · 1The story follows the Clems, a family of millers in Kingston, New York, whose two sons end up on opposing sides: Jeremiah joins the British army under the aristocratic Lord Balfour, while Benjamin, who has a disability, becomes a drummer for the Patriot forces. VarietyLC “Jeremiah makes amends by signing up as a British Army redcoat under Lord Balfour’s command.”“He’s rejected at first due to disability, then proves his value with an impromptu drum solo” Read at Variety ↗
Mixed · 2A secondary plot involves Emmaline (India Brown), a servant in the Balfour household, who writes letters to Jeremiah that he believes come from Balfour's daughter, Lizzie (Beth Easdown). VarietyLC “Emmaline plays Cyrano — writing letters to Jeremiah that he assumes are from Lizzie” Read at Variety ↗ Screen RantN “her conflict with her owner, Beth Easdown's Elizabeth” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Centre · 1Screen Rant's review says the film works better as a period character drama than as a musical. It praises the nuanced, morally grey treatment of the brothers' conflict and Cathal Watters' cinematography, but calls the songs repetitive, ballad-heavy and quickly forgettable, and the plot reliant on tropes. Screen RantN “Drummer Boy works better as a period-piece character drama than a Revolutionary War musical, but benefits from solid visual elements.”“with an overreliance on ballads that leaves the soundtrack feeling unfortunately repetitive” Read at Screen Rant ↗ Left · 1Variety calls the film "a pleasant if simplistic take" on the independence struggle and a "confident, mostly pleasing throwback" to original screen musicals. It says the film will mostly appeal to existing fans of Angel Studios and For King + Country, and that viewers wanting something secular may find it hokey. VarietyLC “is a pleasant if simplistic take on the United States’ foundational struggle for independence”“Viewers preferring wholly secular entertainment may find it on the hokey side” Read at Variety ↗
Left · 1Variety adds that religious messaging is soft-pedaled in favour of a general plea for "forgiveness and reconciliation", and that the film's 18th century looks "very scrubbed and pretty", with some Irish locations standing in for upstate New York. It also says the film avoids race and slavery despite its interracial romance and sets aside historical detail. VarietyLC “religious messaging is relatively soft-pedaled here in favor of a more generalized plea for societal “forgiveness and reconciliation””“neither race nor slavery ever actually get mentioned” Read at Variety ↗ Mixed · 2Both reviews measure the film against Hamilton and, in Screen Rant's case, 1776. Screen Rant says the music is closer to 1776, while Variety writes "'Hamilton,' it's not." Screen RantN “The music is closer to the former than the latter” Read at Screen Rant ↗ VarietyLC ““Hamilton,” it’s not.” Read at Variety ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- Variety treats the film as a sincere, faith-adjacent crowd-pleaser aimed at Angel Studios and For King + Country fans. It is gently wry about its tidiness and anachronisms.
- Emphasis
- The target audience, the soft religious messaging, the idealised look, the pop sound, and the film's timing after the semiquincentennial and a contentious midterm election.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Says little about the quality of individual performances beyond calling the leads appealing and the older actors wasted.
- Charged language
- “swoony”“hokey”“freshly laundered”“Not a movie for the cynical”
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Screen Rant judges the film on craft: it has better ideas than execution, and works better as drama than as a musical.
- Emphasis
- Character drama, the brothers' moral complexity, cinematography, and repetitive, forgettable songs and trope-heavy plotting.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not discuss the audience, the faith-based context, or the film's omission of race and slavery.
- Charged language
- “bland”“Clunky in places”“trope-y”
- For example
-
“Clunky in places but with strong underlying bones to its story and performances” — Screen Rant
“Drummer Boy isn't necessarily a poor musical, but it does often feel like a bland one.” — Screen Rant
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- Drummer Boy is an Angel Studios Revolutionary War musical opening in theaters on 6 November.
- Joel David Smallbone stars and co-directs; Cathal Watters is the cinematographer.
- The story centres on two brothers on opposite sides of the war, with a subplot involving Emmaline and Lizzie/Elizabeth.
- Both reviewers praise the visuals and find the story conventional.
- Both compare the film with Hamilton, with Screen Rant also citing 1776.
Where accounts differ
-
How well the film works as a musical
- Left
- Variety calls it a "confident, mostly pleasing throwback" with catchy melodies, though the lyrics are banal.
- Centre
- Screen Rant says the songs are repetitive and forgettable, and that the film is stronger as a drama.
Left1 article
-
VarietyLC · · Opinion
Mixed A mildly affectionate review that calls the film pleasant but simplistic and innocuous, and places it in the Christian-entertainment market and the national mood.

Centre1 article
-
Screen RantN · · Opinion
Drummer Boy Review: Spiritual Successor To 1776 Has Better Ideas Than Execution
Mixed A craft-focused review that finds a solid period drama weighed down by bland, repetitive songs and familiar tropes.

Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 4 Nov 19:17 First Screen RantN Drummer Boy Review: Spiritual Successor To 1776 Has Better Ideas Than Execution Opinion
- 6 Nov 17:49 +46h 32m VarietyLC ‘Drummer Boy’ Review: Love, Family and Revolution Conflict at Musket’s Point in a Swoony Period Musical Opinion
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…