Egyptian court shuts Mada Masr and convicts editor Lina Attalah of operating without a licence
A Cairo court ordered the independent news site Mada Masr closed on 27 October after convicting editor-in-chief Lina Attalah of running it without a licence. She was fined 3 million Egyptian pounds and taken into custody pending payment or bail.
1 / 4
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2A Cairo court on Tuesday 27 October ordered the independent Egyptian news site Mada Masr closed after convicting its editor-in-chief, Lina Attalah, of running the site without a licence. The Straits TimesRC “A court ordered a leading independent Egyptian news site closed on Tuesday after its editor-in-chief was convicted of running the site without a licence” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The Media LineN “A court in Cairo ordered the closure of independent news website Mada Masr on Tuesday after convicting its editor-in-chief, Lina Attalah, of operating without a license under Egypt’s media law.” Read at The Media Line ↗ Mixed · 2Attalah was fined 3 million Egyptian pounds (about $53,400 to $54,000), and the court ordered the outlet's equipment confiscated and took her into custody; Reuters reported this was pending bail, while The Media Line said pending payment of the fine. The Straits TimesRC “was fined 3 million Egyptian pounds ($53,400), her lawyers told Reuters.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The Media LineN “ordered the confiscation of the outlet’s equipment, and had her taken into custody pending payment.” Read at The Media Line ↗ Mixed · 2Mada Masr said the court gave her the maximum penalty; The Media Line reported the fine was the maximum permitted under the 2018 law governing press and media operations. The Straits TimesRC “The court gave her the maximum penalty, ordering the website to be shut down and its equipment confiscated, Mada Masr said in a statement.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The Media LineN “The fine was the maximum permitted under the 2018 law governing press and media operations.” Read at The Media Line ↗
Centre · 1Attalah's lawyer, Hassan al-Azhari, said the legal team intends to appeal, and lawyers said the judge refused requests for more time to examine evidence and prevented them from calling witnesses. The Media LineN “Attalah’s lawyer, Hassan al-Azhari, said her legal team intended to appeal. Lawyers said the judge refused requests for more time to examine evidence and prevented them from calling witnesses.” Read at The Media Line ↗ Mixed · 2Mada Masr, founded in 2013, says it has sought a licence from the Supreme Council for Media Regulation repeatedly since 2018 without a reply, learned of a rejection only in 2022 when prosecutors raised the issue in an earlier case, and has had a latest application unanswered since 2023. The Straits TimesRC “Mada Masr says it has asked for a licence from the Supreme Council for Media Regulation repeatedly since 2018 but heard nothing back and only learned of a rejection when prosecutors raised the issue during an earlier case in 2022.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The Media LineN “A subsequent application remains unanswered, according to the outlet.” Read at The Media Line ↗ Mixed · 2Egyptian authorities say the state is committed to freedom of expression but that media must operate within the law, respect national security and counter misinformation; the council has not commented on the case. The Straits TimesRC “Egyptian authorities say the state is committed to upholding freedom of expression but that the media must operate within the law, respect national security and counter misinformation.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The Media LineN “The Supreme Council for Media Regulation has said it supports outlets meeting official conditions but has not publicly addressed this case.” Read at The Media Line ↗
Right · 1Prosecutors referred Attalah to trial the previous Thursday; 119 rights groups and media outlets, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and the Committee to Protect Journalists, called the case an "unprecedented attack on press freedom", and US Senator Chris Van Hollen called the charges baseless. The Straits TimesRC “a group of 119 rights groups and media outlets, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and the Committee to Protect Journalists, called the case an "unprecedented attack on press freedom".”“the charges were baseless and that "journalism is not a crime".” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Centre · 1After the verdict, CPJ regional director Sara Qudah called it "a devastating blow to press freedom in Egypt" and urged Attalah's release. The Media LineN “called the ruling “a devastating blow to press freedom in Egypt” and urged Attalah’s release.” Read at The Media Line ↗ Mixed · 2Mada Masr has been blocked inside Egypt since 2017 but kept publishing; it says six cases have been brought against it and its journalists over six years, though rights groups say this is the first referred to trial. The Straits TimesRC “It has been blocked inside the country since 2017. Mada Masr says six cases have been brought against it and its journalists over the last six years, though rights groups say this is the first of its kind to be referred to trial.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The Media LineN “although it has continued publishing” Read at The Media Line ↗
Mixed · 2The case follows the September arrest of journalists at the fact-checking outlet Matsaddash (spelled Matsadaash by The Media Line); Reuters said the entire newsroom was arrested, The Media Line said six journalists were detained. The Straits TimesRC “follows the arrest last month of the entire newsroom of the fact-checking outlet Matsaddash.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The Media LineN “The verdict follows the September detention of six journalists from the fact-checking outlet Matsadaash” Read at The Media Line ↗ Right · 1Reuters also noted that in September the US waived rights conditions, which include protecting media freedoms, on part of the roughly $1.3 billion in military aid it sends Egypt each year. The Straits TimesRC “In September, the US waived rights conditions, which include protecting media freedoms, on a portion of the roughly $1.3 billion of military aid it sends Egypt each year.” Read at The Straits Times ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left1 outlet
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre1 outlet
- Framing
- Straight news report of the verdict, with emphasis on the legal process and Attalah's lawyers' complaints about the trial.
- Emphasis
- Defence complaints that the judge refused more time and barred witnesses; the planned appeal; the CPJ reaction; that a false-news accusation was not part of the referral.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not mention the 119-group statement, Senator Van Hollen or US military aid.
- Charged language
- “a devastating blow to press freedom in Egypt”
- For example
-
“Lawyers said the judge refused requests for more time to examine evidence and prevented them from calling witnesses.” — The Media Line
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Reuters wire copy run by The Straits Times presents the verdict as a test case for independent media, with international criticism and the political context of US aid.
- Emphasis
- Rights groups' and US Senator Van Hollen's condemnation, Mada Masr's international profile and the US waiver on aid conditions.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not report the defence's complaints about trial procedure or plans to appeal.
- Charged language
- “unprecedented attack on press freedom”“journalism is not a crime”
- For example
-
“a group of 119 rights groups and media outlets, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and the Committee to Protect Journalists, called the case an "unprecedented attack on press freedom".” — The Straits Times
What every side reports
- A Cairo court ordered Mada Masr closed on 27 October 2026 after convicting editor-in-chief Lina Attalah of operating without a licence.
- Attalah was fined 3 million Egyptian pounds, her outlet's equipment was ordered confiscated, and she was taken into custody.
- Mada Masr, founded in 2013, has been blocked inside Egypt since 2017 and says it has sought a licence since 2018 without a response.
- Egyptian authorities say media must comply with licensing and national security laws; the media council has not commented on the case.
- The case follows the September detention of staff of the fact-checking outlet Matsaddash.
Where accounts differ
-
Why Attalah was taken into custody
- Centre
- The Media Line says she was held pending payment of the fine.
- Right
- Reuters, carried by The Straits Times, says she was held pending bail.
-
Scale of the Matsaddash arrests
- Centre
- The Media Line says six journalists were detained.
- Right
- Reuters says the entire newsroom was arrested.
Mada Masr organisation
Mada Masr says it has sought a licence since 2018 without a response, that it contested a rejection in court, and that the court imposed the maximum penalty.
“The outlet contested that decision in court, and says its latest application has been awaiting a response since 2023.” — The Straits Times
Egypt place
Egyptian authorities say they uphold freedom of expression but that media must operate within the law, respect national security and counter misinformation.
“Egyptian authorities say the state is committed to upholding freedom of expression but that the media must operate within the law, respect national security and counter misinformation.” — The Straits Times
East and Southeast Asia1 outlet
Reuters copy run by The Straits Times stresses international reaction and US-Egypt aid context.
“In September, the US waived rights conditions, which include protecting media freedoms, on a portion of the roughly $1.3 billion of military aid it sends Egypt each year.” — The Straits Times
The Straits Times
Israel1 outlet
The Media Line stresses the trial's procedural fairness and the licensing dispute.
“Lawyers said the judge refused requests for more time to examine evidence and prevented them from calling witnesses.” — The Media Line
The Media Line
Centre1 article
-
Egypt Orders Independent Mada Masr Closed, Fines Editor $54,000
Neutral Concise account of the verdict and sentence, giving space to the defence's procedural complaints and CPJ's reaction.
Right2 articles
-
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via Reuters
Court orders Egyptian website closed in case seen as test for independent media
Neutral Reuters wire copy framing the verdict as a test for independent media, citing rights groups' and a US senator's criticism alongside the authorities' stance.
- 27 Oct 12:51 First IJRRC Egypt court orders Mada Masr closure, fines Attalah
- 27 Oct 12:55 +5m The Straits TimesRC Court orders Egyptian website closed in case seen as test for independent media via Reuters
- 27 Oct 15:16 +2h 25m The Media LineN Egypt Orders Independent Mada Masr Closed, Fines Editor $54,000
- 27 Oct 17:09 +4h 18m The IndependentLC Egypt convicts Mada Masr editor in ‘draconian’ press crackdown
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…