Eiffel Tower chief to leave after women staff removed during Hindu group visit
SETE, which runs the Eiffel Tower, said director general Patrick Branco Ruivo will leave at the end of 2026 after women staff were removed during a 5 September visit by the Hindu group BAPS. Outlets differ on the strike date, whether the probe was internal or independent, and how much of BAPS's position they give.
Updated (version 6). New coverage since the last version from RFI, The Hill, The National.
1 / 8
The story, neutrally told
SETE, the company that runs the Eiffel Tower, said on 29 September that its director general, Patrick Branco Ruivo, will step down at the end of the year. The Straits TimesRC “said on Sept 29 its chief would step down at the end of this year” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The IndependentLC “He will remain in the role until the end of 2026.” Read at The Independent ↗ SETE said a probe found "operational flaws and shortcomings" in organising a 5 September visit, which led to the "unacceptable" removal of women staff; most outlets call the probe internal, while DW calls it independent. The NationalN “after an internal investigation found “operational flaws and shortcomings” in organising the visit” Read at The National ↗ Deutsche WelleN “An independent investigation found a series of failures surrounding the incident” Read at Deutsche Welle ↗ The visitors were about 100 members of BAPS, a Hindu group in the Swaminarayan tradition with ties to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in France for the opening of a temple near Paris. The NationalN “a delegation of about 100 people linked to the Hindu group” Read at The National ↗ France 24N “with ties to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi” Read at France 24 ↗
Staff said women were replaced by men at some posts and told not to cross certain areas while the delegation was present. The Straits TimesRC “In some posts, they were replaced by men.” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Staff then struck and the tower closed for a day; The Independent and DW give 7 September, while France 24 says the walkout was on 8 September. Deutsche WelleN “strike on September 7, forcing the landmark to close for a day” Read at Deutsche Welle ↗ France 24N “staged a walkout on September 8” Read at France 24 ↗ SETE had earlier acknowledged the delegation asked to limit "interactions with women" and said these conditions "should not have been accepted". The Straits TimesRC “these conditions should not have been accepted” Read at The Straits Times ↗
BAPS apologised for "any pain or inconvenience caused"; in DW's account it also denied asking for women to be removed or hidden, saying its monks' practices do not require women to be excluded. The Straits TimesRC “has apologised for “any pain or inconvenience caused” by the incident” Read at The Straits Times ↗ Deutsche WelleN “They do not require women to be excluded from the places they visit” Read at Deutsche Welle ↗ Paris mayor Emmanuel Gregoire, a Socialist, called the decision "absurd, unjust and unacceptable" and ordered two probes; a person close to the mayor told AFP the mayor acknowledged Ruivo's "responsible decision". The Straits TimesRC “a person close to him told AFP” Read at The Straits Times ↗ The IndependentLC “ordered two investigations” Read at The Independent ↗ SETE chair Ariel Weil said the coming months would prepare the leadership transition and asked for a "dedicated protocol department" and gender-equality measures and training. The IndependentLC ““The coming months will allow us to prepare for the leadership transition under the best possible conditions,” Mr Weil said.” Read at The Independent ↗
The Independent adds that Marine Le Pen and National Assembly president Yael Braun-Pivet criticised the move, and that BAPS reportedly made the request because monks in the delegation, including its 93-year-old spiritual leader, have vows forbidding contact with women. The IndependentLC “National Assembly president Yael Braun-Pivet also criticised the move.”“whose religious vows forbid contact with women” Read at The Independent ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on.
Left1 outlet
- Framing
- The Independent gives the fullest account, with political reaction, staff statements and the monks' vows as explanation.
- Emphasis
- Quotes from Le Pen, Braun-Pivet and Gregoire; the staff statement; the religious reason for the request.
- Leaves out or plays down
- BAPS's denial of asking for women to be removed.
- Charged language
- “made invisible because of their sex”
- For example
-
“I refuse to allow women to be compelled to step aside in order to meet the demands of foreign visitors.” — The Independent
Centre7 outlets
- Framing
- Mostly straight reports of the resignation, focused on SETE's findings and on BAPS's background and Modi ties.
- Emphasis
- The probe findings, BAPS's profile and apology; DW includes BAPS's denial.
- Leaves out or plays down
- France 24 and DW leave out the party-political quotes; only DW carries BAPS's denial.
- Charged language
- “scandal”“unacceptable”
- For example
-
“BAPS denied asking for female employees to be removed or hidden during the visit.” — Deutsche Welle
“Eiffel Tower chief to step down after female staff scandal” — France 24
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- The Straits Times runs AFP copy stressing the cross-party outcry; GB News leads on women left "humiliated" and on the chief having "quit".
- Emphasis
- Outcry in a country that prizes secularism and gender equality (AFP); women being replaced by men.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No BAPS denial or monks' vows detail; the Straits Times gives no strike date.
- Charged language
- “humiliated”“quits”“uproar”
- For example
-
“has quit after female staff were left "humiliated" by being sidelined for a Hindu religious group” — GB News
“an outcry across political spectrum in France which prizes secularism and gender equality” — The Straits Times
What every side reports
- Ruivo, director general since 2018, will leave at the end of 2026.
- SETE's probe found operational flaws that led to women staff being removed during a BAPS visit.
- The removal prompted a staff strike, a one-day closure and political outcry in France.
- BAPS apologised for any pain or inconvenience caused.
Where accounts differ
-
Date of the staff walkout
- Left
- The Independent says the strike was on 7 September.
- Centre
- DW says 7 September; France 24 says 8 September.
- Right
- Straits Times (AFP) gives no date, only a walkout and one-day closure.
-
Nature of the probe
- Left
- The Independent describes an internal investigation.
- Centre
- France 24, The National call it internal; DW calls it independent.
- Right
- Straits Times (AFP) and GB News describe an internal probe.
-
BAPS's role in the request
- Left
- The Independent says BAPS reportedly asked to limit contact with women because of its monks' vows.
- Centre
- DW reports BAPS denied asking for women to be removed or hidden, saying its monks' practices do not require exclusion.
- Right
- GB News says the delegation asked for arrangements to limit "interactions with women" to adhere to its faith.
-
An internal probe found operational flaws in organising the visit, leading to the removal of women staff, and Ruivo will step down at year end.
Reported- Disputes 1
- Deutsche Welle
- Reports 6
- The Independent, France 24, South China Morning Post, The National, GB News, The Straits Times
-
The visit prompted a staff walkout and a one-day closure of the tower.
Reported- Reports 3
- The Independent, South China Morning Post, The Straits Times
-
The walkout took place on 8 September.
Disputed- Disputes 2
- The Independent, The Straits Times
- Reports 1
- France 24
-
BAPS apologised and is described as close to India's ruling party of Narendra Modi.
Reported- Reports 5
- The Independent, France 24, South China Morning Post, The National, The Straits Times
-
BAPS asked SETE to limit interactions with women because its delegation included monks whose vows forbid contact with women.
Reported- Reports 4
- The Independent, The National, GB News, The Straits Times
SETE organisation
SETE says its probe found operational flaws and the removal of women was unacceptable; its chair is setting up a protocol department and training.
““operational flaws and shortcomings” in organising the visit led to the “unacceptable” removal of women staff” — The Straits Times
Patrick Branco Ruivo person
Ruivo, director general since 2018, is leaving at the end of the year; the mayor's circle calls it a "responsible decision".
“acknowledged Patrick Branco Ruivo’s responsible decision” — The Straits Times
BAPS organisation
BAPS apologised for any pain or inconvenience; in DW's account it denies asking for women to be removed or hidden.
“They do not require women to be excluded from the places they visit” — Deutsche Welle
UK and Ireland3 outlets
The Independent gives the most detail and political reaction; GB News stresses that women were "humiliated".
“Marine Le Pen, the far-right frontrunner in next year’s presidential election” — The Independent
“female staff were left "humiliated"” — GB News
The Independent, Sky News, GB News
Europe3 outlets
France 24 and DW report the departure and the staff strike; DW adds BAPS's denial and calls the probe independent.
“An independent investigation found a series of failures surrounding the incident” — Deutsche Welle
France 24, Deutsche Welle, RFI
East and Southeast Asia2 outlets
The Straits Times and SCMP carry AFP wire copy emphasising the cross-party outcry.
“an outcry across political spectrum in France which prizes secularism and gender equality” — The Straits Times
The Straits Times, South China Morning Post
Middle East1 outlet
The National adds background on BAPS's global temples, including Abu Dhabi.
“In 2024, Mr Modi inaugurated its temple in Abu Dhabi” — The National
The National
Left2 articles
-

-
Eiffel Tower chief steps down after female staff sidelined for Hindu delegation’s visit
Neutral Detailed account with staff statement, politicians' quotes and the monks' vows as the reported reason.
Centre8 articles
-
Eiffel Tower chief to step down over removal of women staff during Hindu group's visit
Neutral Straight report of the resignation with BAPS's profile and Modi ties; gives 8 September for the walkout.

-
South China Morning PostN · · via AFP
Eiffel Tower chief stepping down over removal of women staff for Hindu group’s visit

-
Eiffel Tower chief to step down after 'unacceptable' sidelining of female staff
Neutral Reports the resignation with a union voice and background on BAPS's global temples.

Show 4 moreShow fewer
-
Neutral Focuses on the investigation's findings, and includes BAPS's denial.

-

-

-

Right2 articles
-
The Straits TimesRC · · via AFP
Paris Eiffel Tower says chief to step down after uproar over removing women staff
Neutral AFP copy carried by the Straits Times, stressing cross-party outcry and the mayor's reaction.
-
GB NewsR ·
Eiffel Tower boss quits after 'humiliated' female staff sidelined for Hindu religious group
Critical Leads on women left "humiliated" and the boss having "quit"; cites the CGT union.

- 29 Sep 15:22 First France 24N Eiffel Tower chief to step down over removal of women staff during Hindu group's visit
- 29 Sep 16:21 +59m The IndependentLC Eiffel Tower boss to resign after anger over female staff exclusion during Hindu delegation visit
- 29 Sep 17:43 +2h 21m The Straits TimesRC Paris Eiffel Tower says chief to step down after uproar over removing women staff via AFP
- 29 Sep 18:36 +3h 14m South China Morning PostN Eiffel Tower chief stepping down over removal of women staff for Hindu group’s visit via AFP
- 29 Sep 20:01 +4h 39m Sky NewsN Eiffel Tower boss to stand down after female staff excluded during Hindu group visit
- 30 Sep 06:23 +15h 1m The IndependentLC Eiffel Tower chief steps down after female staff sidelined for Hindu delegation’s visit
- 30 Sep 06:45 +15h 23m GB NewsR Eiffel Tower boss quits after 'humiliated' female staff sidelined for Hindu religious group
- 30 Sep 08:56 +17h 34m The NationalN Eiffel Tower chief to step down after 'unacceptable' sidelining of female staff
- 30 Sep 09:54 +18h 32m Deutsche WelleN Eiffel Tower chief Patrick Branco Ruivo to step down after female staff excluded during Hindu group's visit
- 30 Sep 12:11 +20h 49m France 24N Eiffel Tower chief to step down after female staff scandal
- 30 Sep 15:24 +24h 2m The HillN Head of Eiffel Tower to resign after controversial order to female staff
- 30 Sep 15:46 +24h 24m RFIN Eiffel Tower chief to leave after women sidelined during Hindu visit
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.