Equality watchdog writes to Green Party over 'Zionism is racism' conference motion
The Equality and Human Rights Commission has asked the Green Party of England and Wales for more information about a 'Zionism is racism' motion passed at its conference, after receiving complaints under the Equality Act. The Greens say the motion is a political position that does not affect membership.
1 / 3
The story, neutrally told
Mixed · 2The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has written to the Green Party of England and Wales to ask for more information about a 'Zionism is racism' motion passed at the party's conference earlier this month, in order to assess its practical implications and potential impact. Evening StandardN “has asked for “more information” to “assess its practical implications and potential impact”” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has written to Zack Polanski's party to demand more information” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2An EHRC spokesperson said the watchdog had received complaints alleging unlawful activity under the Equality Act 2010, including concerns that Jewish people could face discrimination because of their beliefs following the motion's adoption. Evening StandardN “We have received complaints alleging unlawful activity under the Equality Act 2010” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “including concerns that Jewish people could face discrimination because of their beliefs” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2The EHRC said it would assess the information carefully and take action where appropriate, recognised that many Jewish people would be feeling vulnerable following the motion, and said compliance with the Act was likely to hinge on the motion's practical effects. Evening StandardN “compliance with the Equality Act is likely to hinge on the practical effects of the motion” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “We recognise that many Jewish people will be feeling vulnerable following the party's motion.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Right · 1The Daily Mail reported that the EHRC also said freedom of expression is fundamental and must be protected, that it is not mutually exclusive with freedom from discrimination, and urged those in authority to balance the two. Daily MailR “The right to freedom of expression and the right to be free from discrimination are not mutually exclusive and must be considered together.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2A Green Party spokesperson said the party will not discriminate against or exclude people for holding Zionist views, that the motion sets out a political position with no impact on membership conditions or internal disciplinary processes, and that its antisemitism guidance is unchanged. Evening StandardN “The motion passed at conference sets out a political position. It has no impact on membership conditions or internal disciplinary processes.” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “The Green Party will not discriminate against or exclude people for holding Zionist views.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Mixed · 2The letter followed Labour's announcement that it would end local council power-sharing deals with the Greens unless local Green groups reject the policy; the Daily Mail reported that Labour is in coalition with the Greens in Sheffield, Lewes and Warwick, and that local Green groups were given seven days to respond. Evening StandardN “Labour announced it will end its power-sharing agreements with the Green Party on local councils if they do not reject the new policy” Read at Evening Standard ↗ Daily MailR “Local Green groups are being given a seven-day deadline to respond.” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Right · 1According to the Daily Mail, Prime Minister Andy Burnham told PMQs on Wednesday that Labour 'cannot support a partnership' with the Greens and called the motion 'anti-Semitic', and Labour chair Bridget Phillipson said the policy has no place in British politics. Daily MailR “I condemn the motion that was passed unequivocally,' the PM added. 'It is wrong, it is anti-Semitic”“Labour chair Bridget Phillipson said” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Right · 1The Greens called Labour's instruction to local parties undemocratic and accused it of conflating criticism of Israel with antisemitism, while leader Zack Polanski, who said he is 'the only Jewish leader of a political party', replied to Burnham on X. Daily MailR “Trying to tell local parties what to do and who they can work with is undemocratic.”“I'm the only Jewish leader of a political party.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ Right · 1The Daily Mail added that Karen Newman of the Board of Deputies of British Jews welcomed Labour's move, that opponents say the motion calls for the eradication of Israel because it refers only to a single Palestinian state, and that Polanski skipped the 4 October conference vote in Brighton to campaign in the Holborn and St Pancras by-election, which he lost to Labour. Daily MailR “Opponents also claim the motion effectively calls for the eradication of Israel as it refers only to a single Palestinian state.”“Mr Polanski then went on to lose the contest in the north London constituency to Labour” Read at Daily Mail ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre2 outlets
- Framing
- Short, straight report centred on the EHRC letter and its statement, with the Green Party's reply and Labour's move as context.
- Emphasis
- The EHRC's wording and the Greens' response.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Does not include Burnham's or Phillipson's remarks, Polanski's response, or the by-election background.
- For example
-
“which has been widely criticised as antisemitic” — Evening Standard
“Britain’s equalities watchdog has written to the Green Party about its “Zionism is racism” policy” — Evening Standard
Right1 outlet
- Framing
- Frames the EHRC letter within a wider 'anti-Semitism crisis' for the Greens and Polanski, with heavy space given to Labour's pressure and the Prime Minister's condemnation.
- Emphasis
- Labour's threat to local deals, Burnham's condemnation, Polanski's leadership problems and the by-election defeat.
- Leaves out or plays down
- Gives the Greens' reply but little detail of the EHRC's caution that compliance depends on practical effects beyond one quoted line.
- Charged language
- “anti-Semitism crisis engulfing Mr Polanski's party”“an extremist party”
- For example
-
“amid the anti-Semitism crisis engulfing Mr Polanski's party” — Daily Mail
“A storm of criticism has seen the motion described as an 'attack' on the Jewish community and the Greens branded 'an extremist party'.” — Daily Mail
What every side reports
- The EHRC has written to the Green Party of England and Wales about its 'Zionism is racism' motion.
- The EHRC has received complaints alleging breaches of the Equality Act 2010.
- The EHRC said compliance is likely to hinge on the motion's practical effects.
- The Green Party says it will not discriminate against people for holding Zionist views and that the motion does not affect membership conditions.
- Labour has said it will end local power-sharing deals unless Greens reject the policy.
Where accounts differ
-
Whether the motion is antisemitic
- Centre
- Describes the motion as 'widely criticised as antisemitic' without asserting it.
- Right
- Quotes the PM calling it 'anti-Semitic' and refers to an 'anti-Semitism crisis'; the Greens say it is a political position and that conflating criticism of Israel with antisemitism is wrong.
Equality and Human Rights Commission organisation
Says it has received complaints under the Equality Act 2010, wants more information on the motion's practical impact, recognises Jewish people may feel vulnerable, and says compliance is likely to hinge on practical effects.
“compliance with the Equality Act is likely to hinge on the practical effects of the motion” — Evening Standard
“We also recognise the right to freedom of expression is fundamental to our democracy” — Daily Mail
Green Party party
Says the motion is a political position with no effect on membership or discipline, that it will not discriminate against Zionists, and that Labour's intervention is undemocratic.
“The Green Party said it “will not discriminate against or exclude people for holding Zionist views”.” — Evening Standard
“Trying to tell local parties what to do and who they can work with is undemocratic.” — Daily Mail
Zack Polanski person
Responded to Burnham on X, saying he is the only Jewish leader of a political party and a victim of antisemitism, and that Jewish people are welcome in his party.
“I've made it clear Jewish people are welcome in my party.” — Daily Mail
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre2 articles
-
Equalities watchdog writes to Green Party to probe impact of Zionism policy
Neutral Concise account of the EHRC letter and statement, with the Greens' response and brief Labour context.
-
Right1 article
-
Critical Treats the EHRC letter as part of an anti-Semitism crisis for the Greens, alongside Labour's threat and the PM's condemnation, and notes Polanski's leadership troubles.
- 15 Oct 16:53 First Daily MailR Greens have left British Jews 'feeling vulnerable' says equalities watchdog as it probes 'Zionism is racism' motion - while Labour threatens to scrap local deals with Zack Polanski's party
- 15 Oct 16:59 +6m Evening StandardN Equalities watchdog writes to Green Party to probe impact of Zionism policy
- 15 Oct 17:35 +41m BBC NewsN Equality watchdog writes to Greens over 'Zionism is racism' motion
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…