ESA's Rosalind Franklin Mars rover rehearsed in Spain's Tabernas Desert before 2028 launch
Scientists are testing a replica of ESA's Rosalind Franklin rover in Spain's Tabernas Desert, which resembles its Oxia Planum landing site. The rover is built to drill two metres down in search of signs of past or present life.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
RightScientists and engineers have spent recent weeks testing a replica of the European Space Agency's (ESA) Rosalind Franklin Mars rover in Spain's Tabernas Desert, in Andalusia near Almería. Daily MailR “scientists have taken its replica, Charlie, out to Spain's Tabernas Desert for testing” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “In recent weeks, the team has been rehearsing navigation procedures in Spain's Tabernas desert near Almería” Read at GB News ↗ RightThe Daily Mail reports that the real rover is kept in an ultra-clean room in Turin, Italy, while a near-exact, cheaper and repairable copy called Charlie is driven out into the desert each day for three weeks in what the team call 'emulations'. Daily MailR “while the real Rosalind Franklin sits safely in an ultra–clean room in Turin, Italy, scientists have made a near–exact copy, known as Charlie”“Every day for the last three weeks, scientists have been carting Charlie out into the middle of the Tabernas Desert” Read at Daily Mail ↗ RightThe desert's layered, dry, clay-rich terrain is said to resemble Oxia Planum, the near-equatorial site where the rover is due to land. Professor Susanne Schwenzer of the Open University, field geologist for the tests, said it is 'visually very, very similar to Mars'. Daily MailR “so it is visually very, very similar to Mars.” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “The rover will touch down at Oxia Planum, a site close to the Martian equator selected for its ancient clay-rich sedimentary deposits” Read at GB News ↗
RightSchwenzer said the tests also train the team to link what scientists want to do with what the machine can do. The Mail says she sweeps away footprints so the control team, viewing through the rover's cameras, are not given reference points they would not have on Mars. Daily MailR “testing and training people to actually use this to the best effect before we get to Mars.”“Professor Schwenzer follows along with a broom, sweeping away the footprints” Read at Daily Mail ↗ RightThe rover's main feature is a drill able to take samples from two metres below the surface, where material should be shielded from the radiation that has sterilised the top of the soil. Both outlets say this depth is critical, and GB News says it would be the first spacecraft to do so. Daily MailR “newly designed drill, capable of taking pristine soil samples from up to two metres below the surface” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “poised to become the first spacecraft to bore two metres beneath the Martian surface” Read at GB News ↗ RightInstruments choose drilling sites. The Mail describes the WISDOM ground-penetrating radar, tested in the desert, which looks for water-formed minerals and ice layers. GB News names a panoramic camera designed by University College London and an infrared spectrometer built at Aberystwyth University. Onboard analysis will look for biosignatures such as chirality, a preference for one molecular 'handedness'. Daily MailR “WISDOM is tuned to look for layers in the Martian soil that might contain certain minerals created by water, or even layers of ice”“one key biomarker the rover is looking for is called 'chirality'” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “a panoramic camera designed by University College London and an infrared spectrometer built at Aberystwyth University” Read at GB News ↗
RightTiming and cost are reported differently. GB News says launch is due in 2028 with arrival in 2030. The Daily Mail says the mission could reach Mars 'in just two years' and puts the cost at about $1.3 billion (£980 million), while its headline says £1 billion. GB NewsR “is due to launch in 2028, with a planned arrival on Mars in 2030” Read at GB News ↗ Daily MailR “around $1.3 billion (£980 million) in investment” Read at Daily Mail ↗ RightAirbus built the rover in Stevenage. It was originally due to launch in 2022, and the Mail also cites Covid-19 as a delay. After Russia's invasion of Ukraine, ESA cut ties with Roscosmos, which had supplied key components. The Mail says all Russian components had to be replaced, and GB News says NASA and the UK Space Agency stepped in. Daily MailR “first by Covid–19 and then by the Russian invasion of Ukraine, which required all the Russian components to be replaced” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “Nasa and the UK Space Agency subsequently stepped in to provide replacements.” Read at GB News ↗ RightRadio signals take at least 20 minutes to reach the rover according to the Mail, and between four and 21 minutes according to GB News. Because of this the rover must work autonomously on daily instructions from ESA's control centre, which GB News places in Turin, and nothing can be repaired if it fails. Daily MailR “It takes at least 20 minutes for a signal to travel from ESA's command centre to the rover on Mars” Read at Daily Mail ↗ GB NewsR “Because radio signals between Earth and Mars take between four and 21 minutes, the rover must operate autonomously” Read at GB News ↗
RightGB News stresses what finding life could mean. Schwenzer said that if life there is the same, 'we are all from the same ancestor', though panspermia is unproven. Benoît Pouffary, ESA's head of exploration, preparation, research and technology, said he believes life 'may have happened on Mars' and that finding it would change how we imagine the universe. GB NewsR “If life is the same there, it may be that we are all from the same ancestor.”“I do believe that life may have happened on Mars, it seems something that is credible.” Read at GB News ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split.
Left0 outlets
No left outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets present the mission as a British-linked, high-stakes search for life. The Daily Mail gives a first-person reportage from the desert, and GB News leads on the British build and the chance of finding humanity's ancestors.
- Emphasis
- The Daily Mail stresses field-test detail, the cost, the delays and the 'could finally find life' prospect. GB News stresses the Stevenage and UK university links, panspermia and the Mars climate history.
- Leaves out or plays down
- GB News gives no cost figure and little on the testing itself. The Daily Mail gives no launch date and does not mention panspermia or NASA and UK Space Agency replacements. Neither outlet quotes critics or notes uncertainty about the schedule.
- Charged language
- “could finally find life on Mars”“most important mission in space exploration history”“British rover sent to Mars”
- For example
-
“what's tipped to be the most important mission in space exploration history” — Daily Mail
“A British-constructed Mars rover is poised to become the first spacecraft to bore two metres beneath the Martian surface” — GB News
What every side reports
- The Rosalind Franklin rover was built by Airbus in Stevenage for ESA.
- A replica is being tested in Spain's Tabernas Desert, whose terrain resembles Oxia Planum, the landing site.
- The rover carries a drill that can sample to two metres below the surface.
- The mission was delayed by the war in Ukraine, which ended Russian participation.
- Susanne Schwenzer of the Open University is quoted by both outlets.
Where accounts differ
-
When the rover reaches Mars
- Right
- Daily Mail: it could find out 'in just two years'. GB News: launch in 2028, arrival in 2030.
-
Radio signal delay between Earth and Mars
- Right
- Daily Mail: at least 20 minutes. GB News: between four and 21 minutes.
-
Cost
- Right
- Daily Mail: £1 billion in the headline and about £980 million ($1.3 billion) in the text. GB News gives no figure.
European Space Agency organisation
ESA, through Benoît Pouffary, says life may well have existed on Mars and that finding it would change how we see the universe. It is running emulations to prepare operators before the rover launches.
“The way we imagine our universe would be changed forever.” — GB News
“how ESA and Airbus are getting ready” — Daily Mail
Left0 articles
No coverage yet.
Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right2 articles
-
Celebratory First-person feature that makes the desert test vivid and presents the rover as a possible finder of life on Mars.

-
GB NewsR ·
British rover sent to Mars on mission to discover humans' ancient ancestors
Sympathetic Stresses the British manufacture and the prospect of discovering humanity's origins, with the science background and ESA quotes.

- 2 Oct 13:45 First Daily MailR The rover that could finally find life on Mars: I travelled to a remote desert in Spain to see ESA's £1billion Rosalind Franklin put to the test - and for a moment, I could have sworn I was on the Red Planet
- 2 Oct 15:05 +1h 20m GB NewsR British rover sent to Mars on mission to discover humans' ancient ancestors
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.