Experts warn NOAA staffing cuts leave US less prepared for strong El Niño this winter
Former officials and scientists told the Guardian that staff and funding cuts under President Trump have weakened NOAA's ability to forecast and respond to extreme weather as a potentially historic El Niño strengthens. NOAA and the Commerce Department did not respond to requests for comment.
1 / 2
The story, neutrally told
Left · 2Former government officials and scientists have warned that cuts at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) under President Donald Trump have hampered the US capacity to forecast, research and respond to extreme weather, as a potentially historic El Niño develops this winter. The GuardianLC “have severely hampered the country’s capacity to forecast, research and respond to extreme weather events, former government officials and scientists have warned” Read at The Guardian ↗ Raw StoryL “just as the country faces a potentially historic El Niño this winter, former officials and scientists warned” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 2According to US Office of Personnel Management workforce data last updated in August, NOAA has lost more than 3,000 staffers since January 2025, roughly 20% of its staff, and has made only 525 new hires, leaving a deficit of about 2,500. The GuardianLC “Noaa has lost more than 3,000 staffers, according to workforce data from the US office of personnel management”“the agency was able to bring on just 525 new hires since January 2025, leaving a gaping 2,500-person deficit” Read at The Guardian ↗ Raw StoryL “has lost more than 3,000 staffers since January 2025, roughly 20 percent of its workforce” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 2The Guardian reported that the public affairs team was roughly halved, IT management staff fell by about 27%, and there are about 10% fewer meteorologists and meteorology technicians, with only 40 meteorologists added between January and August; hundreds of positions are vacant across the National Weather Service's 122 forecast offices. The GuardianLC “The public affairs team that helps disseminate important information, was roughly halved.”“Only 40 Meteorologists were added to the ranks across Noaa between January and August this year” Read at The Guardian ↗ Raw StoryL “hundreds of positions sit vacant across the National Weather Service’s 122 forecast offices” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 2The El Niño is expected to strengthen through the northern hemisphere's autumn and winter and could intensify storms in parts of the western US, raise sea levels in California by up to a foot, and bring debris flows, landslides and flash floods. The GuardianLC “El Niño will supercharge storms in parts of the American west, raise sea levels in California by up to a foot” Read at The Guardian ↗ Raw StoryL “could supercharge storms in parts of the West, raise sea levels in California by up to a foot, and trigger debris flows, landslides and flash floods” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 2Tom Di Liberto, a former NOAA climate scientist now at Climate Central, said the system has not really been tested since the cuts and that it is a big question whether the country can handle coast-to-coast extremes this winter; Monica Medina, NOAA's principal deputy administrator under Obama, said she worried about loss of life and that if this is a real test, "we’re going to flunk". The GuardianLC ““The system has not really been tested since all the cuts happened,” said Tom Di Liberto”““If this is a real test”, of a hotter, more precarious future, she added, “we’re going to flunk”.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Raw StoryL “Monica Medina, NOAA’s principal deputy administrator under President Barack Obama, warned of the stakes.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 2The reports point to signs of strain already: delayed or limited weather balloon launches left parts of the Great Plains unprepared for tornadoes, rural Alaska communities received limited warning before floods that displaced more than 1,500 people, and a Government Accountability Office (GAO) finding said cuts undermined multilingual alerts, putting 26 million people at higher risk. The GuardianLC “limited warnings to rural communities in Alaska, where more than 1,500 people were displaced by floods earlier this year” Read at The Guardian ↗ Raw StoryL “A Government Accountability Office report found staffing and funding cuts undermined the weather service’s alerts in languages other than English, putting 26 million people at greater risk.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 1Raw Story, citing NPR, adds that NOAA's El Niño research effort has been scaled back, with only "a handful of unmanned watercraft" planned for the Pacific this year compared with aircraft, drones, balloons and a research vessel in 2015-16, and that about $6 billion was cut from planned weather satellite investment, which the GAO warns could leave a coverage gap. Raw StoryL “This year, NPR reported, it will deploy only “a handful of unmanned watercraft” into the Pacific.”“The administration has also cut roughly $6 billion from planned investment in weather satellites, which the GAO warns could leave a gap in coverage.” Read at Raw Story ↗ Left · 1The Guardian also cited Grant Witness figures showing more than $28m in terminated grants and fiscal 2026 grant awards 37% below the 2021-2024 average. The GuardianLC “a loss in more than $28m in funding for states, cities, non-profits and universities, according to calculations from Grant Witness”“the number of grant awards in fiscal year 2026 was 37% lower than the 2021-2024 average” Read at The Guardian ↗ Left · 2Trump has proposed cutting $1.6bn from NOAA's budget next year, a 26% drop, though many of the cuts are unlikely to survive the budget process. The GuardianLC “Trump has proposed cutting $1.6bn in Noaa funding – a 26% drop – for next year’s budget.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Raw StoryL “though many of those cuts are unlikely to survive the budget process” Read at Raw Story ↗
Left · 2Di Liberto said remaining NOAA employees fear getting in trouble for saying anything that conflicts with the administration's messaging on climate. NOAA and the Commerce Department did not respond to the Guardian's requests for comment, so the administration's response is not given in this coverage. The GuardianLC “Requests for comment sent to Noaa and its parent agency, the Department of Commerce, were not returned before publication.” Read at The Guardian ↗ Raw StoryL “NOAA and the Commerce Department did not respond to the Guardian’s requests for comment.” Read at Raw Story ↗
Every sentence links to the reporting it rests on. The pill in front of each says where its sources sit: Left, Centre or Right when one side supplies at least half of them, Mixed when they are evenly split. The number is how many outlets it cites.
Left2 outlets
- Framing
- Both outlets frame the story as the consequence of Trump's cuts to NOAA, with an approaching El Niño as the test. Raw Story's piece largely condenses the Guardian's reporting and adds NPR and GAO details on research and satellites.
- Emphasis
- Staffing losses, expert warnings of lost capacity and possible loss of life, and staff fear of contradicting the administration's climate messaging.
- Leaves out or plays down
- No administration or NOAA response is included; neither outlet reports any justification for the cuts, and the Guardian does not quantify how the staff reductions affect forecast accuracy.
- Charged language
- “taken an axe to”“gutted”“monster El Niño”“hollowing out”
- For example
-
“President has taken an axe to National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration” — The Guardian
“Grim warning as monster El Niño bears down on storm watchers Trump gutted” — Raw Story
““There has been this hollowing out – there’s no time to do anything other than the very basics,”” — The Guardian
Centre0 outlets
No centre outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
Right0 outlets
No right outlet in our sources has covered this story yet.
What every side reports
- NOAA has lost more than 3,000 staff since January 2025, about 20% of its workforce, with 525 hires.
- A potentially historic El Niño is expected to strengthen this winter.
- Trump has proposed a $1.6bn (26%) cut to NOAA's budget next year.
- NOAA and the Commerce Department did not respond to requests for comment.
NOAA organisation
NOAA and its parent Commerce Department did not respond to requests for comment; the coverage describes the agency as stretched, with low morale and staff afraid to speak.
“Requests for comment sent to Noaa and its parent agency, the Department of Commerce, were not returned before publication.” — The Guardian
“a chaotic and volatile environment has plummeted morale, increased burnout and hampered vital work” — The Guardian
Donald Trump person
Presented as having cut NOAA staff, grants and contracts and as proposing a further $1.6bn budget cut; no statement from Trump or the administration is quoted.
“Trump has proposed cutting $1.6bn in Noaa funding – a 26% drop – for next year’s budget.” — The Guardian
“Trump’s sweeping cuts to the nation’s top weather and climate agency have severely weakened its ability to forecast and respond to extreme weather” — Raw Story
El Niño topic
Described as a strengthening 'super' event that could bring simultaneous extremes and also a research opportunity that a shrunken NOAA may miss.
“It’s already climbing off the charts and is expected to strengthen through the northern hemisphere’s autumn and winter.” — The Guardian
“experts worry a shrunken Noaa is missing a vital research opportunity” — The Guardian
Left2 articles
-
Trump’s cuts have exposed US to ‘cascade’ of El Niño dangers, experts warn
Critical Detailed investigative-style report presenting expert warnings that Trump's cuts have eroded NOAA's capacity ahead of El Niño.

-
Grim warning as monster El Niño bears down on storm watchers Trump gutted
Alarmist Short aggregation of the Guardian report with NPR and GAO additions, headlined as a 'grim warning' about a storm-watching agency Trump 'gutted'.

Centre0 articles
No coverage yet.
Right0 articles
No coverage yet.
- 27 Oct 11:00 First The GuardianLC Trump’s cuts have exposed US to ‘cascade’ of El Niño dangers, experts warn
- 27 Oct 13:57 +2h 57m Raw StoryL Grim warning as monster El Niño bears down on storm watchers Trump gutted
Times are when each article was published, or when we first saw it if the outlet gave no time.
Ask about this story
Loading…